Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Decisions Decisions

Posts

Decisions Decisions

#1

Decisions Decisions

Dwain

>With the current state of the economy, cutbacks and layoffs at work I decided to save up for my TBS.

I have been in the market from summer 2008 with two foiled attempts at getting a Powermatic, but the freight company failed twice and then I saw the new Delta that would be coming out spring of this year, so I decided to hold off.

Well, I decided to hold off even longer till I had saved most of the cost to avoid creating any debt. Well, holding off has created the delema of decision making because now Saw Stop has come out with a competitor and then I noticed a post on Fine Woodworking for the Grizzly sliding table table saw that is also in the price range.

With that said I'm curious to hear from you guys.

Thank you,

Dwa

Re: Decisions Decisions

#2

Re: Decisions Decisions

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Sounds a bit like you don't know what you're going to use it for.

Clint

Re: Decisions Decisions

#3

You suffer from

Forrest Addy

>You suffer from premature buyer's remorse. You wait and wait for the next better thing putting off grabbing the gusto. You hate to think that you'll miss the latest improved, up-to-date table saw so youll never commit to second best. In human relationships the phenomena is called life long bachelorhood.

Hold off long enough and you'll die owning the perfect brand new saw your heirs will sell for a nickel on the dollar.

Re: Decisions Decisions

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Decisions Decisions

Moses Yoder

>If I bought a new saw it would definitely be a Saw Stop. Especially when learning how to use a saw, my fingers are just too valuable to me to use any other saw if I had a choice. A sliding table on a saw may be nice for some operations but the safety of the saw stop beats everything in my opinion.

Re: Decisions Decisions

#5

Re: You suffer from

Dwain

>I really like your response Addy. You know I am pretty good at self monitoring, and I was aware of everything you mentioned but you gave me the terminology to go with it.

Normally I do go with the gusto, but the situation of actually saving up to make the purchase is what is allowing me to peruse the smorgesborg before digging in so to speak.

However, once I reach my savings goal I will make the decision, make the purchase and live with it. Ultimately I think it will be between the Saw stop and the Delta with the Delta weighing a few ounces more.

It will be hard because I know deep down in my gut that Delta will eventually implement some kind of blade stop technology in the next couple to few years. It is the next logical step to putting everyone back on the same plane. Plus I have no doubt that customers are asking for it.

Thank you,

Dwain

Re: Decisions Decisions

#6

What can I say

Forrest Addy

>What can I say? I posted late and I was tired I do regred the asperive tone of my desponse. as a ditherer myself, naturally I can't stand the trait in other. Anyway, you're holding out for good choices. Personally, I'd go for the Delta more because I'm familiar with it. I am attracted by the say stop. I have several little scars that could have been amputations had I been less lucky (skill, experiencre, and awareness had nothing to do with saving me from my own stupidity - it was pure luck.)

Shop wisely.

Re: Decisions Decisions

#7

I have to agree with Moses

Neal in San Jose

>I've had my Saw Stop for several years now, and don't ever rethink that decision. I upgraded from a Jet cabinet saw, which was no slouch, but the "hot dog trick" sold me the first time I saw it in person.

Having that saw in my shop is like having the proverbial 500 pound gorilla constantly reminding me to be careful. I now always point the chisel away from my body, keep my hands away from the bandsaw blade, etc, etc, etc. I consider it the best money I ever spent out in my shop.

Re: Decisions Decisions

#8

Re: Decisions Decisions *LINK*

Tony - Memphis

>I admire your financial planning and patience and using your head! I did something similar about a year ago. I had been using a Delta 10" contractor's saw for around ten years. I was ready to step up for several reasons. After all my research, I bought the Powermatic PM2000. I've been very happy with it. No complaints really. Woodcraft had a 10% off sale and I got a bonus at work at that time, so it all worked out timing wise. Had it been a few months later, I would not have bitten the bullet. Our bonuses are gone now and I'm just thrilled to be employed at the moment! Anyway, good luck with your decision and enjoy the new saw. Getting mine into the shop was quite an adventure! Unlike the present August, last August was very hot here and it was 100�+ the Saturday I decided to move the saw from the garage to the workshop. I had to take breaks to cool off. Long story, but the saw was on two pallets and I had to build a ramp to slide it off and then roll it to the shop and build more ramps up and down the threshold, etc.

Here is a page I did to show the adventure of moving the beast into the shop...

Tony


The PM2000 Adventure...

Re: Decisions Decisions

#9

Re: Decisions Decisions

Jim Dillon

>Dwain,

I really admire your restraint (some would say maturity) in saving for and making an informed decision. I'm 66, and wish sometimes I could muster a similar attitude. I'm getting better though; maybe by the time I'm 100 I'll have it down 8-). Anyway, if I were shopping today, I sure would look seriously at the SawStop. OTOH, the new Delta looks nice too. Good luck, and let us know what you decide on and how the new saw measures up to your expectations.

Jim

Re: Decisions Decisions

#10

Just nosey . . .

steve mackay

>but, what ya' run'n now ?

Re: Decisions Decisions

#11

buy a used Unisaw or Powermatic

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Nothing serious wears out on these saws and they can be found, at least here, for well under $1000.

Re: Decisions Decisions

#12

Re: buy a used Unisaw or Powermatic

Barry Irby

>I see two choices

Bill is right, buy a used unisaw or powermatic. They are beasts and never wear out. I was going to say they never go out ow style, but just maybe....

I have been using a Delta/Rockwell 10" contractors saw for almost forty years. Added a 2 hp motor when the original 1 1/2 failed. And a Biesemeyer fence when Lowes sold them for $80. Great saw. Does everything I ask. But.....

SawStop may have raised the bar. Styles may have changed. Like Mr. Addy said, how long can you be lucky? Stupid mistakes go on forever. If business picks up for me or I hit a wind fall, there is a Sawstop in my future. All my major tools are Delta, but I like being attached to all my fingers. I have mangled a few and it's time for a Sawstop.

Re: Decisions Decisions

#13

Re: buy a used Unisaw or Powermatic

jan derr

>right on

Re: Decisions Decisions

#14

One consideration

Dan Donaldson

>The newest Unisaw has the addition of a riving knife that you would not get on a used saw. That could be a safety device worth buying a new saw for rather than a used one.

Re: Decisions Decisions

#15

Re: Just nosey . . .

Jim Dillon

>Steve,

Not sure if your question was directed to me, but if it was I'll be happy to tell you I got my General 10 incher (Model 350?) roughly 13 years ago. It has been wonderful, except for the dust collection which is awful. I was eyeing the suggested changes to the saw to improve dust collection that was in FWW two issues ago I think. But they must have changed the location of the dust collection port on mine so I would have to punch a hole out the back of the saw, which I hate to do. Other than poor dust collection, it has been a joy to use.

Jim

Re: Decisions Decisions

#16

Wow . . .

steve mackay

>13 years faithfull service. But I'll bet this next one is the "last one" !

Re: Decisions Decisions

#17

Re: Decisions Decisions *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Dwain,

You do not say which part of the country you are in but this ad was posted on my local(Detroit) Craigslist today.I looked up theh model # and it leads to an '02 Platinum Edition Unisaw.

http://detroit.craigslist.org/wyn/tls/1334634555.html

Usual disclaimers apply

Andy


http://detroit.craigslist.org/wyn/tls/1334634555.html

Re: Decisions Decisions

#18

Re: Wow . . .

Jim Dillon

>Steve,

I seriously doubt there will be another saw in my life. While I am envious of the new safety features on recent saws, I am happy with mine. Plus, it is paid for 8-). Also, over the years, I have made quite a few jigs, sleds, and other stuff to enhance the capabilities of the saw. While they might fit, I doubt they would fit as well, and I sure don't want to make them all again. Thirteen years ago the choice IIRC was Delta, Powermatic, and General - all with excellent reps. The dollar was strong at the time, so I purchased directly from Canada and it has worked out fine.

Jim

Re: Decisions Decisions

#19

Good point

Tony - Memphis

>I have that on the PM2000 and I really like having it there. Very easy too. You can buy an aftermarket splitter, but its not the same as the riving knife. I cut some very narrow molding against the fence the other day using a technique I read about by Steve Latta and it felt much more comfortable doing it with the knife there. Splitter would have worked, but mayba have been more cumbersome. Anyway, good luck with your decision and enjoy the new saw!

Tony