Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

What's in a name?

Posts

What's in a name?

#1

What's in a name?

Joe Hurst-Wajszczuk

>Guys-

For those looking for some flavor reminiscent of the old AW, I'd encourage you to give Woodcraft a look-see (that's a word that crept into my vocab during my brief stint in MN...I couldn't handle the cold).

The old regulars, many of whom have spent the last decade teaching, writing books, and spending time in their shop, have been encouraged to revisit their magazine roots. As their editor, I'm working to treat them fairly, knowing that good things will come to all. (Take a close look at #30's "4 Step Antique Finish," and "Bandsaw Tune-Up.")

AW's old formula worked for a number of reasons. I'm integrating some, but I know that attempting to relive by-gone days is a recipe for disaster. Jim's the same with his experience.

If nothing else, I think Woodcraft's WOOD/AW amalgam makes it one of the most interesting reads on the newstand.

'Nuf said,

Joe

Re: What's in a name?

#2

JL

Re: What's in a name?

JL

>I got the magazine as part of a "free subscription package". I think that it is relatively worthwhile. I was a bit skeptical at first. I wondered if it could be that objective.

Yes, it is slanted towards Woodcraft products. Generally I find the articles informative and the reviews unbiased. I will probably renew.

Re: What's in a name?

#3

Re: Contructive critcism welcome?

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Submitted with respect:

Guys- (Gals (females) aren't welcome? How about "folks?"

For those looking for some flavor reminiscent of the old AW (What does this acronym represent? A&W Root Beer? American Woodworker? Assuming it is Amercican Woodworker, should not the acronym be italicized?), I'd encourage you to give Woodcraft (Which Woodcraft? The franchise woodworkers-supply retail store? The magazine? I have to assume, since it is not italicized, that reference is made to the retail store.) a look-see (that's a word that crept into my vocab (Hmmm. What is this shorthand? Vocational Ability? Aha, must be "vocabulary." My head is beginning to hurt working this hard at reading this post.) during my brief stint in MN...I couldn't handle the cold).

The old regulars, many of whom have spent the last decade teaching, writing books, and spending time in their shop, have been encouraged to revisit their magazine roots. As their editor (Wow! Editor? Hope there is a strong-willed proofreader on the payroll.), I'm working to treat them fairly, knowing that good things will come to all. (Take a close look at #30's "4 Step Antique Finish," and "Bandsaw Tune-Up.")

AW's old formula worked for a number of reasons. I'm integrating some, but I know that attempting to relive by-gone days is a recipe for disaster. Jim's (Jim? Whos' Jim?) the same with his experience.

If nothing else, I think Woodcraft's WOOD/AW amalgam makes it one of the most interesting reads on the newstand. (Finally, a connection making everything connect. It's a darn shame my head is pounding and I don't think I have the will power to re-read the foregoing information in context.)

'Nuf said,

Joe

I read WoodCentral for education and entertainment. I can accept an occasional advertisement such as your post but, I certainly do want to spend my time trying to figure out what the poster is saying. In spite of the crytic nature of your posting here, perhaps I'll one day buy an issue of Amercian Woodworker and see if I like it but, if the magazine forces me to work as hard as this post, I'll not purchase a second and most assuredly won't become a subscriber.

Respectfully,

Al

Re: What's in a name?

#4

As an aside,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>a long time ago I read an interview with the head of General Mills, located in Mpls. He was asked about the difficulty of retaining good managers given the reputation of Minnesota winters. He responded that if they couldn't handle the winters, they probably couldn't handle his company, either.

:-)

Bruce, who thinks the southern MN winters aren't bad at all. Ask someone from Ely or Grand Forks.

Re: What's in a name?

#5

Lee Grindinger

Was this blatant ad approved by Ellis?

Lee Grindinger

>I wonder..., Ellis usually chimes in with his approval.

But, I'm sure no editor would just rush into WoodCentral with an advertisement without the owner's approval..., now would he? After all, those ads are considered spam and deleted right away.

Lee

Re: What's in a name?

#6

Lee Grindinger

Joe's advertisement. Not yours, Bruce

Lee Grindinger

>

Re: What's in a name?

#7

not taking the bait

joe_hw@yahoo.com

>Al-

"Submitted with respect" does not make it respectful.

I'm sorry if you had a difficult time with my shorthand and industry lingo, but abbreviations are commonplace in most email messages.

Not everyone is as interested in the magazine business. But for those who are, I thought they might appreciate a hint of what's happening at the masthead level.

Perhaps Ellis will weigh in. If my invitation is seen by him as a blatant ad, then I encourage him to drop the thread.

Best,

Joe Hurst-Wajszczuk

Re: What's in a name?

#8

Alan Young

A man from Ely went South for the Winter

Alan Young

>to Minneapolis.

Re: What's in a name?

#9

Re: A man from Ely went South for the Winter

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I was sitting at a conference with a friend of mine. A lady presenting something or other talked about how she used to live in Cedar Rapids, IA, but now lived in Nashville and got the chills when she saw the weather channel talking about the temps in Cedar Rapids. My friend laughed out loud. I asked him where he was from. He said "Ely." Pretty much 'nuff said.

Bruce

Re: What's in a name?

#10

Ellis Walentine

Messageboard protocol

Ellis Walentine

>I have no trouble with your posting a plug for the magazine in the context of my "brief history" post below. Unsolicited commercial posts are not allowed, according to our longstanding policy. It's fair enough to let people know that a lot of our old editors and contributors are now freelancing for Woodcraft Magazine.

Regarding Al's reply, I thought it was unnecessarily hostile-sounding, whether he intended it that way or not. I'm glad you didn't take the bait, as you say. We'd be in bad shape if every post had to pass that kind of editorial scrutiny. I talk in jargon and sentence fragments myself here a lot of the time. The important thing is to get your point across. I understood you, but it doesn't hurt to be very clear when you're talking to a varied audience as you are here.

Thanks for the update on Woodcraft Magazine. Keep up the good work.

Ellis

Re: What's in a name?

#11

Or What's Not?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Perhaps its just the lack of vowels.

Good luck with the mag [that's short for either a publication, wheels, or larger caliber somethings]

Re: What's in a name?

#12

Re: What's in a name?

jan derr

>send me a copy.

I like technical reading and have learned my craft from it, but I now need design books to keep my business going. Here's what I love of the tech stuff: I have read nearly every artitcle published on hand cut dovetails and my cuts are as rugged as ever. What the articles do is keep me hand cutting.

I LOVE IT!!!

thanks

jan

Re: What's in a name?

#13

Re: A man from Ely went South for the Winter

john tenhundfeld

>Bruce, I changed jobs back in the mid '90s and moved from Cedar Rapids to Minneapolis. After a year or two I got a chance to move back to CR and jumped at the chance. I could not take the winters in "southern MN" and really could not take the MN state bird--the mosquito.

Re: What's in a name?

#14

Re: not taking the bait

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Joe,

Believe what you will. My earlier post was sincere. I was attempting to make the point that to a reader unfamiliar with Woodcraft your post was confusing. Twice, while reading it, I nearly closed it without finishing it. My impression of your post was that you 1) Wanted to invite WoodCentral readers to buy the magazine, and 2) Wanted to advise that the magazine has changed.

Now, I didn't complain about the advertising...Ellis will take care of that if it's a problem. My point was that your post was unclear and a non-reader of your magazine will, likely, be as confused as I was. Acronyms and shorthand are counterproductive when communicating with folks unfamiliar with the shortcuts. That is, precisely, why I titled my post "Constructive criticism..." If you want to label the post "baiting" and reject the observations...

Al