Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

Posts

Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

#1

Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>They are/were the parent company of American Woodworker Magazine as Ellis knows all to well. But we now have Wood Central which is better than the magazine anyway.

Re: Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

#2

Re: Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Why does this seem like a good day to me. :) Karma is a beautiful thing.

Dave

Re: Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

#3

That's terrible news

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I just received my Readers Digest Clearing House Sweepstakes Notice in the mail and discovered I just won $15,000,000.00

Does this mean I might not get all the money?

;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

#4

Re: Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>They weren't the parent company, but the step-parent company. If I recall correctly, AW was originally a publication of Rodale Press (Organic Gardening, Prevention magazines), later bought by Reader's Digest. Ellis was involved in the Rodale days, not the Reader's Digress days. AW wasn't worth much in the Reader's Digest days, in my opinion.

Reader's Digest was also one of the major donors to my first college (Macalester, in St. Paul), which I found ironic when I attended it, since Mac was among the more leftie campuses in the Twin Cities in 1966, not exactly the image of Reader's Digest then.

Re: Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

#5

Legal papers filled in LARGE FONT?

Dick Coers

>

Re: Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

#6

Condensed____________

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>

Re: Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

#7

It's all in a days work

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>

Re: Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

#8

Ellis Walentine

A brief history of AW

Ellis Walentine

>AW was originally started up by a fellow named Jim Jennings from the back room of a laundromat in Hendersonville, TN. That was in early 1985. It was a darn good magazine -- large format, all black & white -- with my old pal Ernie Conover on the masthead as the Q&A guy, and authors the likes of George Frank, Chris Becksvoort, Dona Meilach, Frank Gottshall and Carlyle Lynch, among others. Gottshall's work and drawings in particular were superb. Jennings published eight quarterly issues under his own aegis.

Then, in 1987, Rodale Press Book Division came along and bought AW for its mailing list, intending to bury the magazine. Not so fast, said David Sloan, who had been working for Rodale's New Shelter magazine before *it* went South. David had been an associate editor at Fine Woodworking in the early 80s and was excited at the prospect of publishing AW in the same vein.

Rodale started publishing AW bi-monthly in March/April '88, with David holding down the editorial duties almost singlehandedly for the next couple years, borrowing copyediting help from his wife, Ann Michael, and editorial and production assistance from elsewhere in Rodale's Book Division and Magazine Division. Later, David brought in Fiona Wilson, a former Krenov student, as his managing editor. Shortly after that, he began tempting me with an offer of an editorial job. I was too involved in my contract furniture career at the time (while running a custom woodworking business as well) and was underwhelmed with the magnitude or promise of AW. For the next few years, I kept up with David's efforts and watched AW's circulation grow, spurred on by Rodale's mighty direct mail machine. Finally, in 1992, having achieved what I wanted in the contract business, I signed on as an assistant editor.

During the early and mid-90s we expanded the staff, took on a lot of bold new initiatives -- such as the Woodworking in America Shows, the Woodworking in America Reader Surveys, the Excellence in Craftsmanship Awards, the first (exclusive) woodworking website on AOL, and an aggressive tool testing schedule -- that established us as major players in the woodworking publishing field, which was crowded then and continues to be crowded to this day. Our paid circulation soared to almost 380,000 on a rate base of 325,000, eclipsing all but WOOD magazine in circulation, and we were well into the black by 1997.

Our success turned out to be our demise, as Rodale saw the chance to recoup the relatively large investment they had in AW. More that that, they saw an opportunity to package the magazine with the woodworking books department and divest them both at once, so they could concentrate on their core demographic of fitness fanatics and health-conscious twenty-and-thirty-somethings. The decision to sell the two as a package left only about three players in the industry who could justify such a purchase. Our staff wanted dearly to stick together and continue under a new owner, but that hope faded as Reader's Digest emerged as the prime contender. The deal went through in September 1998, and AW shuttered its doors in Emmaus on October 23, 1998, putting our 22-member staff out of work, as nobody wanted to move to Minneapolis to stay with the magazine. Coincidentally, that very same day, a little one-page web site called WoodCentral.com said "hello world." We haven't looked back.

I won't criticize RD for its stewardship of AW, except to say that all my predictions came true. They changed the flavor of the magazine to shoot for a larger bulls-eye, a broader market that had made its sister publication Family Handyman a highly profitable magazine, with circulation in the 1.2MM range. They weren't so fortunate applying the FH formula to AW, though, and the magazine lost a lot of its faithful followers. The woodworking shows also went south, and a couple years ago, RD decided to sell AW to its current owners, New Track Media LLC.

New Track Media angered a lot of people recently by buying Woodwork magazine, a hip, glossy West Coast magazine published by Ross Periodicals, and then sinking it after one issue, fulfilling existing WW subscriptions with AW subscriptions. I, too, miss Woodwork, but it was never a profitable or widely circulated book, and at least now I can remember it just the way it was under the intelligent and tasteful editorial hand of John Lavine. Also, I think that this sequence of events may have been good for AW. They just sent me a bunch of recent issues and I was pleasantly surprised by the look and the content of the magazine -- good projects and techniques, nice drawings, tasty layouts... Maybe there is a new life around the corner for a brand that is still dear to my heart.

On the other hand, competition in woodworking magazines is stiffer than ever, with Pop Wood, WW Journal, Fine Woodworking and Woodcraft --- not to mention WOOD, Woodsmith, Shop Notes, WSN and others (including our friends at Woodworker West) -- all continuing to put out good product. Frankly, I don't know where they get the energy to compete at this pace. You'd think it can't last forever, but, looking back at how few players have dropped out in the past twenty years or more, you might want to think again. WoodCentral is in the fortunate position of being a neutral island in this sea of woodworking ink. Regardless of which magazines you read, I'm glad you've chosen to join us as well.

Onward,


Re: Readers Digest Files for Chapter Eleven

#9

Thanks, Ellis.

Hank Knight

>That's the first time I've seen the whole story. Like most of us, I miss the good old days of AWW when you were there, and I'll miss Woodwork as well. It's nice to have the contxt in which all that went down. Thank you for it. Most of all, thank you for Wood Central.

Hank