Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

Posts

better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#1

better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>In resurrecting my basement shop, I'm trying to do a few things better this time than I did last time.

About half of my fluorescent shop lights have died. It's not the bulbs, but probably the ballast. Two out of three of my T8 bulb fixtures are shot, and I already replaced two older shop lights with the larger size tubes.

Looking at Lowes today, it seemed pretty clear that shoplight to them means cheap. A lot of those lights cost less than their replacement ballasts.

Any thoughts on where to find brighter lighting ideas? Shoplights are nice because they make efficient use of space between the joists overhead (only about 7' up), but even if they're cheap, replacing them all the time isn't fun. And to be fair, my basement is pretty damp, which I doubt helps anything.


Basement shop, 2001

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#2

Re: better-quality shop lights?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>When you say the fixtures are shot, do you mean the bulb sockets, or wiring, or ballasts? If the bulb sockets and wiring is still OK, replacing a ballast should give you a whole new fixture, in essence.

Yes, they mean cheap. Presumably, they've decided that higher quality fixtures wouldn't sell, although the box stores, in my experience, almost always opt for the cheaper choice, because that's their business plan. Contact a local contractor's electrical supply not all of them sell retail, so ask that question first before wasting their time and yours), and ask about commercial T8 fixtures.

I just put a $28 4-foot T8 fixture in my shop, and I must say, the higher efficiency tubes sure make a difference. Even in the middle of the day, with sunlight streaming through the big high windows on the south wall, I can see more brightness in the shop with it on.

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#3

Re: better-quality shop lights?

Michael Bush

>I was taught ages ago that it was unsafe to put florescent lights in a shop, because the strobe effect can make machinery appear to be off when it is on. Is this not really, or no longer, a concern?

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#4

Re: better-quality shop lights?

Dave's Not Here

>For a brighter more natural light check out the "Daylight" type tubes. I switched to those in my shop and the difference between them and the standard type tubes is amazing.

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#5

Re: better-quality shop lights?

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>Seems to be the ballasts, so far as I can tell. The wiring in the one I took apart looks okay, though I'll see what my options look like before deciding between new lights and new ballasts.

It was just a little startling to see that the replacement ballasts cost significantly more than what I'd paid for the fixture!

I'll give my local electrical supply house a call and see what they can do. Definitely a good idea to look beyond the big boxes.

Thanks!

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#6

I hope that's not true

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>but maybe the rapid blinking has me hypnotized?

I suspect that might have been an issue when fluorescents first arrived?

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#7

daylight tubes rock

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>They make my damp basement much more inviting.

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#8

Re: better-quality shop lights?

Dan Donaldson

>There might be a little bit of that with the old t12 fixtures, but not enough to really bother anything. If you check, you will see that most every commercial shop in the country has fluorescent bulbs in it. Would not be allowed if it were really a problem.

It is even less of a problem with the new t-8's with the electronic ballasts. This type of ballast runs at much higher frequencies which should virtually eliminate most any strobing at speeds you find in the shop.

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#9

Shop lights aren't alone in that

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I'm always bemused by power tools on which one or two replacement parts will cost more than the entire tool at retail. Cordless drills are often particularly prone to this.

At one time, Milwaukee was outstanding for having parts that were very reasonably priced in relation to the tool; I don't know if that's still true since they were bought out.

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#10

no longer an issue

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Electronic ballasts don't flicker and all you can buy in a T8 is electronic ballast. I have replaced all the old ballasts in my T12's with electronic ballast becasue I am sensitive to flicker.

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#11

replace ballasts

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>They are cheaper when buying a million than buying one. It is not guaranteed that you will get a better ballast at the lighting store than Lowes.

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#12

One thing to watch

Dan Donaldson

>I changed all of the fixtures in my shop from t-12's with regular ballasts to t-8's with electronic ones. I just changed the ballasts because it was easier than changing the fixtures. I did have to change around the wiring to the sockets because the electronic ballasts connected to them differently. Not a big deal, but it won't work if you don't do it.

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#13

Since your lights are against a dark ceiling, ----

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>i think you would benefit from getting the fixture with the reflector that fits over the top, and bends down and out to each side. This reflects down more light back which would just be absorbed by those dark corners between the joist

The reflector does add a bit to the price of the fixture, but it will give you more light without upping the wattage. You might find another way to reflect it back cheaper if you are creative, like buying a sheet of 1/4" white melamine, and ripping a strip of it to fit over the fixture, and down the sides of the joist. Something with a foil face would also work.

Even white paint would be the cheapest way to get some reflection back down.

------WebKitFormBoundaryVN4knHdLR53+9CCK

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#14

Since your lights are against a dark ceiling, ----

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>i think you would benefit from getting the fixture with the reflector that fits over the top, and bends down and out to each side. This reflects down more light back which would just be absorbed by those dark corners between the joist

The reflector does add a bit to the price of the fixture, but it will give you more light without upping the wattage. You might find another way to reflect it back cheaper if you are creative, like buying a sheet of 1/4" white melamine, and ripping a strip of it to fit over the fixture, and down the sides of the joist. Something with a foil face would also work.

Even white paint would be the cheapest way to get some reflection back down.

------WebKitFormBoundary5ZE17E+xqAbwwMin

Re: better-quality shop lights? *LINK*

#15

Re: better-quality shop lights?

NickB

>I put 'industrial' or 'warehouse' T8 fixtures in my shop (good quality electronic ballast, with reflector). If I remember correctly, they ran about $40/fixture (~ 5yrs. ago), so not "shop lights" from a big box, but not the most expensive fixture either. I mounted them 'semi-recessed' between the floor joists, then mounted chicken wire across the opening between the edges of the reflector to cut down on tube breakage (I think it has saved a number of broken tube incidents around my bench).

I've not had a single problem with them, and I think the reflector helps a lot (I had a quick look on the web, and it appears you can get this style fixture with a polished aluminum reflector for even better performance). Oh, and get good tubes (with high CRI) too.

Hope this helps,

Nick