Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

Posts

OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#1

OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

Tom Rex in TX

>They tell me to change oil ever x number of miles OR y number of months.

Does oil go bad over time?

If you don't run the motor why would it go bad?

Thanks,

Tom

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#2

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>One thing that happens is that, without some heat generated, water condenses in the pan, and bad stuff happens when water and oil are applied to machine surfaces. Somewhat regular running of your engine, to temperatures that would completely warm the oil would help evaporate that condensate.

Now, every 6 months? On a vehicle that gets run regularly, but not far? I'm not all that certain. I'm not a mechanic, though.

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#3

I agree

Nat Robison

>I don't think it's necessarily that oil goes bad as much as it gets dirty. I personally change my own every 6k miles regardless of months. A lot of manufacturers will honor warranty as long as it's changed every 7500 miles and some (I think) as high as 10k miles.

I agrees that you have to get it hot on a regular basis to help "burn" off the water that might get in the oil pan. Also, the longer between runnings is longer for all the oil to completely drain back into the pan.

I figure that regular oil changes are really cheap insurance against problems. Cheaper still if you do it yourself.

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#4

Oh, you are so wrong.......

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"... figure that regular oil changes are really cheap insurance against problems. Cheaper still if you do it yourself...."

Oh, you are so wrong:

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/messages3.pl?read=393084

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#5

Don't you ever tire of being a smart-ass??

Nat Robison

>Of course, my wife asks me that regularly too. Hey, it's 30 minutes in the garage with no one bothering me. I can stretch it to an hour if I rotate the tires.

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#6

Ha, ha, ha......

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I can change the oil in my Odyssey in 15 minutes.... (if I'm lucky).

But my average time is probably 45 minutes. And to achieve an AVERAGE like that you know there's been plenty of 1-2 hour fiascos involving tons of woodshavings and dust from the dust collector to mop up the mess.

Hey, we protect wood furniture with oil, don't we? Well..... so..... my concrete garage floor is well protected, LOL

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#7

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>For the past 40+yrs I have been changing my oil filter at 3,000 miles and the oil and filter both at 6,000 miles on several vehicles.

Never have had any problems. But the new oils seem to last longer with their additives not breaking down as soon. The main reason I change my oil so often is that engine wear happens and the sludge is where the filter cleans it out of the oil.

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#8

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

Bill Howatt

>Thy used to say the lubricating property of the oil itself never wears out but it does get loaded up with dirt and the inhibitors they put in the oil to prevent certain things and aid other things does wear out. Seems reasonable but I don't know for sure.

My vehicles do most of their mileage in what would be called highway driving, very little start/stop city driving. Highway driving is probably easiest on the engine since it gets hot enough to burn off the moisture and the engine isn't idling a lot which can let extra fuel into the oil. I imagine a good fuel-injected engine these days is better than the carb engines of old in this regard. Since I do mostly highway driving I don't get overly excited about the exact oil change time. In the winter, I do pay more attention because it gets very cold and it does take the engine longer to warm up and it means that it might not ever get good and warm on a short drive.

What is surprising is that engines getting very seriously "sludged" is a concern these days. This is something that had virtually disappeared years ago but for some reason is a problem now.

Bill

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#9

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

Fred Davis

>Glenn,

the best answer for that question I got from a article on that subject from Yellow Cab company in San Jose in the late seventies.

They determined that the acid build up in oil was the culprit, not the oil .

Since they had all stop and go driving as a rule , they decided to change oil on their fleet at 1,500 miles and after a year the stats showed 50% fewer overhauls and engine breakdowns.

This I took as gospel ,along with every mechanic I have used over they years and change oil and filter at three thousand, regardless of the owners manual suggests.

Not changing filters at the oil change gives you a quart of dirty oil to blend into the new, not good.

The last three pickups have been Diesels and they hold anywhere from 10 to 16 quarts, of oil depending on the engine manufacturer.

FredD

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#10

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

Barry Irby

>This is not an answer to your question, but I heard Pat Goss on the radio talking about oil. (He does a radio talk show or won of the TV Shows on one of the motor head channels. I have no relationship with him and barely know who he is, but apparently he knows his stuff and is respected.) He was a total advocate for synthetic motor oil. Claimed it essentially arrested engine wear at the point you put it in. That is, if you put it in at 50k miles, it stayed at that state of wear. There was call after call asking what brand he recommended and he insisted it did not matter what brand, just use synthetic. This went on and on. I have used it in all my vehicles since then and have had no repairs I could relate to the oil. Probably 300K miles. I change the oil at double the recommended distance. I have a friend running four cars (his, wife's, two daughters) on synthetic oil and he changes it once a year. His vehicle is getting 35K a year. He's been doing it for years with no problems.

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#11

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>My only response is that the OP was asking about a seldom used vehicle.

Where the vehicle, as a taxi would be, is used in stop and go driving, and almost all the time, MUCH shorter change intervals would be indicated. 1500 miles seems cheap, because the mechanic gets to see the car before something else bad happens.

I don't think that some one driving irregularly, and infrequently, would have the same challenges.

Six months change interval, and a good, long, healthy drive once a month should do it.

My last diesel was an '81 VW Rabbit. It quit when the teenager driving it finally killed it at about 340k miles... Not my son, but a good friend of his.

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#12

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

Jim Dillon

>Tom,

In a word, yes the oil will degrade over time. In the case of motor oil, degradation occurs mainly by two mechanisms: chemical and mechanical. With respect to chemical degradation, the culprit is heat. The heat in the crankcase will cause oxidation of the long chain polymers that make up the oil. This oxidation will result in an oil that has less and less viscosity over time, which leads to less protection for the metal moving parts.

Mechanical degradation likely occurs, starting with the longest polymer (oil) chains first. The longest chains are mechanically torn apart due to extreme shear forces between the mobile oil and the moving metal parts, say between the cylinder and the cylinder wall. The degradation of the longest chains broadens the molecular weight distribution (MWD) even further, again reducing the viscosity of the oil.

Complex additive packages are added to the oils to both slow down the rate of oil degradation, and to protect the surfaces of the metal parts. They likely do this by scavenging free radicals, as well as sequestering (capturing) metal ions abraded from the moving metal parts; these ions may accelerate the degradation of the oil, so rendering them inactive will prolong the service life of the oil. But sooner or later, the additives are used up, then the oil goes downhill faster.

Synthetic oils are not immune to chemical or mechanical degradation, but the polymer backbone contains more thermally stable aromatic groups (rather than long chain hydrocarbons), and perhaps non-carbon linking atoms like silicon. Hence, they will last longer, but are more expensive.

As far as I know, while the non-synthetic oils per se haven�t changed much, the additive packages have so modern motor oils retain their initial properties longer. Plus, I would imagine, tolerances on moving parts (as well as engine design) have improved as well, thus reducing metal ion content in the oil.

Regarding water, I would speculate that as the properties of the oil change over time, absorption of water by the oil will increase, which will further reduce the viscosity of the oil, and lead to increased engine wear.

Fred�s concern about acid buildup may have merit, as that would be one of the likely chemical mechanisms for oil degradation.

You asked if one doesn�t run the motor over time, does the oil wear out. Well, I would guess that the oil doesn�t wear out, but the car may disintegrate in the meantime 8-).

Well, that exhausts my knowledge of motor oil chemistry. Who knows, some of the above might even be true 8-) 8-).

Jim,

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#13

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

Victor Parisian

>I agree with Jim Dillon here. I can add this to the conversation; If your engine just sits all day for day after day the oil will draw moisture from the atmosphere. Run the engine periodically bringing the engine up to operating temp before shutting it down.

Victor - in Hot and Humid Houston

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

#14

Re: OT. Does Motor Oil Breakdown Over Time

Tony - Memphis

>That's what I do. I change mine once a year (or every 15 months depending on if I remember). I've never in my life heard of anybody having a problem due to dirty oil. My truck has 103k on it and is running fine and still getting the exact same mileage it got when I bought it new. I think most of the oil change ideas are myths. Its a shame we are wasting all that oil for nothing.

Tony