Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

JB Welded toilet tank, what are my chances?

Posts

JB Welded toilet tank, what are my chances?

#1

JB Welded toilet tank, what are my chances?

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Okay, so here is my dilemma�..

Simple job this morning, the upstairs toilet fill valve needed to be replaced, picked up parts, added a flush valve to the mix as I figured I�d have one big toilet rebuilding party and not have to worry about it for 5 or 10 years.

Removed the tank from the bowl, and proceeded to remove the fill valve and flush valve, tank was kind�a grungy, so I set it in the bath tub and proceeded to clean it out. Though I don�t recall it happening, I must have bumped it or set it down on the flush lever, anyway the result is a hairline crack across the flush valve and down the left side of the tank. RATS!

So while I know the final solution to this problem is going to be � If I�m lucky (NOT) I�ll find a replacement tank, otherwise a whole new toilet.

Being the optimistic type, I cleaned out and dried out the cracked tank and applied a large quantity of JB weld to the inside of the tank over the crack etc.

So what are the chances of the JB WELDed tank surviving to flush again???????

Re: JB Welded toilet tank, what are my chances?

#2

Re: JB Welded toilet tank, what are my chances?

Jesse Cloud

>My guess would be that if you cleaned it well, the fix will last a longgg time. I have a few "temporary" JB Weld fixes that are now about ten years old, maybe some day I'll get around to doing it 'right', heh heh.

Re: JB Welded toilet tank, what are my chances?

#3

Re: JB Welded toilet tank, what are my chances?

Marv

>Bob,

I'm a dedicated fan of JB Weld. It gets hard and maybe even brittle in some situations. I think I might have gone with some kind of bonding epoxy that doesn't set up hard for your fix. Epoxy adheres super well as does JB Weld, which is a type of epoxy, but a bit of flex would be less risk.

An argument could be made in favor of the JB Weld in that it is hard enough to prevent the crack from growing.

Marv

Re: JB Welded toilet tank, what are my chances?

#4

Zero. Use aquarium grade silicone.

Forrest Addy

>Chances of success in using JB weld to repair vitrious china to retian a water hed? Jb weld is not a good repair for wet conditions and itss brittle. My prefiction you r chances of long term succes in this repair is zero.

Consider failure consequences. Gallns of water on the floor immediately plus 5 GPM from failure to discovery. So my answer is not only no but hell no.

A better choice is aquarium grade silicone. It's been used for glass to glass bonding for generations and it has a little give. A failure may result in a leak but not a deluge.see[age or maybe a

Why mickey mouse around. Buy a new toilet. You can get a cheap one ofr $100 or a used but servicable one from the thrift store for $10.

Re: JB Welded toilet tank, what are my chances?

#5

Forrest is Correct

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hello Bob,

As the father of 10, I have vast experience in these matters. Get a new jon.

George

Re: JB Welded toilet tank, what are my chances?

#6

Gorilla Glue

IEW

>I had a birdbath that cracked and was told that Gorilla Glue would do the job. It's kind of messy, but it has done the job.