Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

Posts

Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#1

Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

wilbur

>I was thinking of using pocket screw joinery to make a quick and dirty TV and audio equipment stand out of plywood. Of course, I plan on replacing it eventually with a fine piece of furniture, but realistically, I know that such a project is going to be on hold for quite a while, as I won't start it until I actually finally get an flat screen HDTV, which I could still hold off on for a few years.

I've never built anything with pocket screw joinery. Can anyone share their experience with how these joints hold up over the long haul, with or without glue? I'm asking about pocket screw joinery made without glue as the Kreg website has lots of video footage demonstrating the Kreg jig and not using glue in a lot of their demo joints.

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#2

Re: My thoughts on the matter...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I was in the consumer audio business at the front end of my career, and saw what was use regularly then. It's changed radically since. And I assume that change will continue unabated.

Anything you build now will last a good twenty years, and then be functionally obsolete, because what you use won't fit easily.

Building with screws is easily strong enough for that kind of furniture.

Now, dining room furniture, or for the master bedroom, changes much more slowly. TV cabinets, pretty quickly.

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#3

Ellis Walentine

Butt joints

Ellis Walentine

>Wilbur, I am a strong advocate for appropriate design. To me this means setting a design problem and then solving it. Your basic conditions here are quick and dirty -- no joinery, no fancy materials, no huge time investment. That's a legitimate design problem and pocket screws can certainly do the job for you if the rest of the execution is proportionate and appropriate.

If you think about the difference between pocket-screw joinery and traditional joinery (besides speed), you realize that with pocket screws, you're primarily dealing with butt joints, with or without glue to reinforce them. Plywood joints are half endgrain, so glue doesn't lend as much strength to them as it does to long-grain, solid wood joints, or even cross-grain tenon cheeks. So the ultimate strength of the joinery comes down largely to the holding power of the screws, which is considerable and directly proportional to the number of screws used. There is no interpenetration of parts to add strength and rack resistance to the construction, so you're relying on the edge joints and the screws to provide that strength. This is fine, too, as long as you provide the additional rack resistance needed for the function of the piece. This might involve a glued-in back panel, or gussets or additional cross members or x-bracing or whatever it takes to provide the stiffness that the screws can't.

There's no set length of time that pocket-screw joinery will last, any more than there is an intrinsic longevity to traditional furniture. It's all about how it is designed and built.

Ellis

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#4

Re: Butt joints

Bill White

>A qoute from the White Book of Barnyard Philosophy:

"If yer gonna screw it, glue it"

Bill

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#5

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

Nat Robison

>When I was getting interested in woodworking a few years ago, one of first things I came across was a pocket screw jig. I really like them for their ease and speed. I've built all sorts of things with pocket screws and never had one fail. I've used them to attach face frames, build drawers, etc.

Now, no one is going to mistake furniture made with pocket screws for truly fine furniture but if you look around, you'll see lots of mass-produced pieces that use them. A few years ago, I know that Norm Abram used them to put together a very complex face frame for a piece he built for NYW. I think he uses them fairly often in places they won't be seen.

For what you've described, they're absolutely fine for a temp. entertainment unit. Buy the Kreg set-up that goes for about $40. You will definitely get your money's worth in the future.

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#6

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Wilbur,

I use them regularly, and have used them in some furniture items I've made nearly 15 years ago. The joints are plenty strong. However, I do not use them as a matter of routine in most joinery applications. They are especially useful in face frames and dust frames/drawer seperaters. Also very good for attaching furniture tops to frames. Mortise and tenons are my preferred method for carcase construction.

George

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#7

Interesting way to look at it

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Thanks Ellis. I like that take on how to design projects.

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#8

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

Fred Davis

>Eilis's take on joint design is well noting if your going to turn out pieces that look good inside and out.

The time it takes me to repair the drawer rail between the bottom of the drawer and the top of a cabinet door or between drawers that used a pocket screw would have been well spent using traditional joinery.

This is a problem in joinery that never seems to go away, speed of assembly taking the place of strength.

That being said , if your in a hurry , cross your fingers, the worst strain is a steady one , load wise. ;-))

FredD

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#9

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

Jesse Cloud

>I heard Marc Adams give a talk on cabinet making at one of the wood shows. He was debating what kind of joinery to use on face frames. After comparing several options, he concluded that given the relatively short average lifespan of a kitchen cabinet, pocket screws where the best solution.

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#10

Ellis Walentine

I agree

Ellis Walentine

>We've made a lot of cabinets with face frames over the years, and pocket screws are the hands-down winners for speed of assembly. Once you glue them to the cabinets, rack resistance isn't an issue.

Ellis

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#11

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

wilbur

>Thanks! I got the answer that I needed. I think that I will proceed with pocket screws for this semi-temporary TV stand. I only need it to hold up for a few years, and if it falls apart sooner than that, that will give me the excuse I need to get a HDTV, finally.

I hope that this plan doesn't subconsciously make me do a crappy job. :@)

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

#12

Re: Longevity of pocket screw joinery?

Bart Leetch

>Wilbur

Just don't SCREW it up. Smiley