Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Semi OT - new truck preference?

Posts

Semi OT - new truck preference?

#1

JL

Semi OT - new truck preference?

JL

>I have a 1988 F250. It has a 5.8 L engine, heavy duty towing package, etc. I originally bought it to haul a horse trailer and the end products of horses. It will haul full sheets of plywood.

I got to thinking about the Cash for Clunkers. I am not familiar with any of the trucks currently on the market - but I figure most (if not all) have better mileage ratings than my F250.

I do haul lumber, plywood sheets and finished goods now along with the occasional load of mulch. Anyone have any recommendations? My niece and her fiancee want me to get a Toyota Tacoma or Tundra.

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#2

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Pickup trucks can be the subject of fierce loyalty. I myself however have owned Chevy, Ford and now Toyota. I have nothing bad to say about Ford or Chevy trucks. But a few years ago I bought a Tundra and loved it. So much that I recently traded it for a newer Tundra.

I haul a lot of lumber hundreds of mile per trip, no problems. Aside from its utility, it is a very comfortable and easy to drive truck.

Just 2 cents

Tom

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#3

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

steve mackay

>As above I've no real loyalty to any brand but I can say I've (seemingly) been trying to kill my Nissan for almost eleven years. But it's a mule. I'm also not a car guy. Its a hauler and transporter. nothing more to me. I only change the oil 'cause I feel guilty if I don't. Its pretty beat up but just won't die. I suppose when it does I'd get another.

Don't want to start politics but I saw the other post about "cash for clunkers". I was under the impression that pickups were now evil, wicked, mean & nasty according to the powers that be. Are they including pickups in the program ?

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#4

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

Thomas S Stockton------WebKitFormBoundaryRU4sWQOIA

>I have a Toyota tacoma with the 4 cylinder engine, it replaced a Ford f-150 that had 230,000 miles on it. I really liked the fact that the ford would hold almost anything I wanted and could tow a fair sized trailer nicely. 2 years ago I replaced it with the tacoma, it doesn't carry as much and it will only tow 3k pounds (6k if you hacve a tow package) but it gets great gas mileage and is much nicer to drive and park in cities. Plywood doesn't sit flat but the new ones have pockets in the side of the bed to hold boards that will suport sheets above the wheel wells. I end up renting u-haul trailers a couple of times a year for larger deliveries which works really well.

So my advice if you still need to haul horses get something bigger than a tacoma and test drive a hole bunch of trucks een ones you might not be interested in.

The other thing is if you live where it snows put 300lbs of sand bags in the back makes a huge difference, these things are pretty light in the rear.

Tom

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#5

Alan Young

Might Not be any Cash for Your Cluncker

Alan Young

>This program is basically designed to get products such as your F250 off the road and replaced with much smaller vehicles with high MPG ratings. You'd better read the fine print in any deal you are inclined to make on a new Truck no matter the brand. Our house hold is hanging on to dear life with these charmers

1.1996 Taurus

2.1993 F150

3.1992 Buick Century

4.1996 Doge Neon

Alan

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#6

Ram 2500 Cummins

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#7

2 MPH or better should be easy

Dustmaker Mike

>with that truck, that is all that is required for the cash to clunkers. My 2004 F150 will get me a new 2010 F150 with that deal.

Now with that said if you are hauling then an F150 or dare I say the Chevy or GMC version or the Dodge 1500 would be a better choice. I have seen the "Full" size Toyota pulling a large load and it is scary how low the back end was sitting and bouncing around. YES the trailer was loaded correctly. It was pulling a trailer with a 49 Chevy 3/4 ton pick up on it. The trailer was a dual axle and the truck was in the middle almost to close to the back of the trailer.

If you have a 1988 Ford and are happy with it then I would say take a ride in the 2010 F 150 and be impressed with the new ride.

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#8

JL

Re: Might Not be any Cash for Your Cluncker

JL

>I have to get at least 2 mpg or better. I currently get 10/12 mpg. I think I can find something better :). Even if I got a full size F150.

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#9

JL

Trucks qualify - see image. 

JL

>


img

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#10

Alan Young

What's your source JL?? *LINK*

Alan Young

>That image looks like a press release. For kicks I googled CfC and found this Ford link at the top of the list. I entered the information you gave about your truck- 1988 Ford F250 5.8 liter engine.

The Clunker Calculator will allow a $4500 trade in but I don't see a full sized pick up available as one of your trade in options. Perhaps there are differences in zip codes although I doubt it. I think you can trade in your truck- but I still have my reservations that you'll qualify for a truck of equal size....

Let us know if find out differently.

Alan


Ford Clunker Calculator

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#11

JL

Hence my question...

JL

>I can get at least $3500 on an F150 or $4500 on a Ranger. If the Ranger will work, I may go for it.

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#12

You can trade up trucks

Dustmaker Mike

>if you go to www.ford.com the link is hidden but you will see you can trade up. I can trade my 04 for a 2010 if I wanted and get the $4500 always it has to do is get 2 miles per gallon better then the truck you are trading in.

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#14

Go to

Dustmaker Mike

>the middle instead of putting in your truck info look at the yellow button that says trucks SUV click here.

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#15

Ford only???

Ralph in Huntington Beach

>You seem to be only considering a Ford from your later posts, but I would trust your relatives...you can not go wrong with a Toyota. Whoever said that the Tundra they saw was sitting too low with the trailer was using empirical evidence and not facts. I could say the same exact thing about every Dodge, Ford and Chevy I've seen. The reason you see Tundra's everywhere, is because they're Toyota's and will run for a very long time without breaking the bank with maintenance. I have a Tacoma because I didn't have room for a Tundra where I live, but would have bought one if I needed the extra hauling ability. Don't discount the Toyota out of hand, at least test drive one before you decide.

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#16

JL

Re: Ford only???

JL

>I am considering a Tundra or a Tacoma - but there are NO Toyota dealers around here. I have to go to the big city for those. So that will be a later trip. I can go over to the neighboring town to look at Fords (25 miles).

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#17

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

Barry Irby

>JL, Check this out carefully. My Mazda 6 cylinder is listed as getting 17 mpg. There fore, it qualifies because that is below 18. I looked at trading it for a tacoma that was a 4 cylinder rated at 21 mpg. The dealer said they could give me $3500, but that if the new pickup had been rated at 22, it would have been $4500. So, I don't know if it is based on the difference r that the new one must get over 22.

I like my Mazda and it is identical to the Ford Ranger. They are essentially interchangeable. My son had two tacomas and liked them both, but wrecked them so soon that his opinion is not founded on any sort of endurance. I like the extended cab, but not the short bed. I used to have a full sized pickup (Chevy) and really liked the full sized bed.

I did not see enough advantage to trading the Mazda for a new tacoma to warrant paying the $17,000 difference they wanted. I actually think my truck is really worth $3500 and plan to drive it several more years. With 128K on it, I am planning on 200K. Its a beater, but I am beating it to death, which is what it is for.

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#18

Parts comparison at Ford dealer

Joe Pack

>I had a bit of time to kill while sitting in a Ford dealership waiting area a couple of months ago. To pass the time, I took a long look at a display showing comparable parts of Ford, Chevrolet and Toyota pickups, particularly suspension, frame, brakes... They showed a Ford frame cross-section compared to Chevrolet; Ford was much sturdier. The showed Ford sheet metal compared to Toyata; Ford was much thicker. They showed Ford springs compared to Chevrolet; Ford was much sturdier...You get the idea. Sometimes they showed just Chevy, sometimes they showed just Toyota, sometimes they showed both. In every example shown, the Ford part was much more substantial. It was easy to see, according to their display, that Ford was by far the better choice.

Funny, though, that they never ONCE compared a Ford part to a Dodge part! Wonder why?

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#19

Re: Parts comparison at Ford dealer

Ralph in Huntington Beach

>Just so I know I read this correctly. All this happened at a Ford dealer...right?

What were the chances that they would have compared the parts in their trucks that were inferior to the others trucks???

When I was waiting for my new Toyota to be readied for me, I was looking at a display that was much the same as the one you saw at the Ford dealer and it was quite different. What were the chances.

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#20

Re: Parts comparison at Ford dealer

mdclor

>When I was researching replacing my Dodge Dakota, my very trusted independent mechanic told me to get another Dakota if I wanted to keep it for 5 years or to get a Toyota if I wanted to keep it for 25 years. I went with the Toyota Tundra.

FWIW,

Merle

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#21

Not that I am biased or anything, but...

Dan Donaldson

>If you were to buy a Ford, it would help make sure that I continue to get my retirement ;-)

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#22

Re: Not that I am biased or anything, but...

DaleLenz

>The things my Ford mechanic son tells me about Ford's parts price, you don't nothing to worry about. Two hundred for a pair of U-Joints, that for parts only, that's nuts! Parts house price: $36 for the pair. No wonder Ford does not need bailed out, : ' >.

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#23

Re: Ford only???

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>We each probably have a favorite brand, but I'll still take issue with your statements in the interest of some sort of balance.

"Whoever said that the Tundra they saw was sitting too low with the trailer was using empirical evidence and not facts."

Empirical evidence IS facts.

"The reason you see Tundra's everywhere, is because they're Toyota's and will run for a very long time without breaking the bank with maintenance."

They are uncommon here, and the Tundra hasn't been around for long enough to compare it's longevity to other full-size trucks. And, based on my 2000 Silverado's service schedule, breaking the bank on maintenance is not a problem. How about 7,500 miles between oil changes; 30,000 miles between fuel filter changes; 100,000 miles between plugs, transmission fluid and filter changes; and 150,000 miles between radiator flushes and fluid changes? Does Toyota's service schedule beat Chevy's?

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#24

Is it worn out? If not use it up.

Victor Parisian

>I'll take a old truck any day over a payment coupon book. Gasoline and maintenance is far cheaper than payments that seem to go on for ever.

Victor - life is too short to live in Houston.

Re: Semi OT - new truck preference?

#25

"using empirical evidence and not facts"------WebK

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI------WebKitFormBoundar

>First, empirical evidence IS facts.

As for "Toyota's and will run for a very long time without breaking the bank with maintenance". My 2000 Chevy Silverado calls for 150,000 miles between coolant changes; 100,000 miles between plugs, tranny filter and fluid changes; fuel filter at 60,000 and 7,500 between oil and filter changes. THAT ain't breaking the bank as far as I can see. And how can anyone comment on the longevity of the Tundra when it hasn't been around long enough to make a comparison to other full-size trucks?

------WebKitFormBoundaryA6Tr+USRYAFT+pQd