Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

random orbit sander

Posts

random orbit sander

#1

random orbit sander

Howard

>Just finished sanding with PC 5" RO sander after dual drum sander left chatter marks. Thought everything was sanded out, until stail went on. Nothing terrible, but I'm pissed. I was thinking of switching to a 6" right angle like the Bosch. Any thoughts?? Also, do the pneumatic sanders perform better than their electric cousins?

thanks for your help.

Re: random orbit sander

#2

Re: random orbit sander

DaleLenz

>Howard,

What I've done in the past is before my final grit of sanding, usually 220, flood the work with paint thinner in full sun light, if available and look at the work in a raking light. Will usually show any scratches. I always miss something, but catch most of the Sritters, : ' ).

Re: random orbit sander

#3

Yeah, it happens

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Howard - for years I struggled with a ROS and the swirl marks left by the machine no matter how hard I tried. Then I saw a video by Andy Rae on how to use the darn thing.

The key is patience, patience and more patience. When Rae uses a ROS he progresses through the grits from 100 to 150 to 220 and then possibly to 320 depending on the finish. He sands carefully in one direction, say side to side on a table top, overlapping the motion each time. Then, and here's the patience part, he goes in the opposite direction, up and down, with the same grit. Then, upward through the grits with the same technique.

I've used his method ever since and gotten excellent results; smooth, no swirl marks and no portion of the surface left unattended.

It becomes sort of a Zen exercise after the first few passes and can almost be (are you sitting down?), fun!

My $.02 worth. Just wait for the numerous opinions you're sure to get.

Have fun with all your woodworking; even the sanding!

Doug

Re: random orbit sander

#4

You don't say which 5" PC you have?

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>But they are not all created equally.

The smaller ones usually only have about a 1/8" circle of motion, while the larger ones have about three times that much.

Also, I like the idea of going on up to 6". The area of 5" is 19.635" and 6" is 28.274". The one inch diameter adds almost a third more surface area.

I don't know if you are a professional weighing the cost of your time over the tool and abrasive supply cost, but this is a no-brainer.

Re: random orbit sander

#5

Re: When I'm done with the ROS

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I give it a going over with the last grit, a fresh piece, in a rubber sanding block. by hand, paying attention to the grain.

And pigment stains are going to make it more difficult, because they accent the swirls, not hide them.

So do what you gotta do, but hand sanding makes a difference.

Re: random orbit sander

#6

Ellis Walentine

ROS technique counts

Ellis Walentine

>As Doug mentioned below, being methodical and going up through the grits in the right increments are important. Random orbit sanders have two kinds of motion -- orbits and pad rotation -- and the different motions produce different scratch patterns on the work. Orbits produce squiggles, tiny round curlicues that arc across the surface of the wood, while pad rotation produces swirls, which are much larger, arcing scratches. The whole idea of the ROS -- and its main advantage over the earlier orbital sanders -- is that the rotation of the pad, which on most models is induced by the orbital action and not driven by the motor, produces a random scuffing pattern that wipes out the curlicues of the orbital action and produces a surface with few visible repetitions of scratch patterns. It isn't that the surface isn't scratched; just that it is deemed less offensive to the eye. As you proceed up through the grits, this randomly scuffed surface becomes clearer and clearer until it is almost impossible to detect swirls or squiggles. The highest grit you need to use depends on the species and density of the wood you're sanding and your projected follow-up, i.e., an oil finish or a film finish. Oil finishes that are rubbed into the wood and wiped off require finer surface preparation than lacquers and varnishes. If you move the sander too quickly across the surface, you risk both kinds of scratch patterns, which is what it sounds like you are describing here.

Ellis

Re: random orbit sander

#7

coming to grips with sanding perfection

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>After some years of experience preparing surfaces for staining I have come to the conclusion that only hand sanding reliably prepares a surface entirely free of machine induced defects. Belt sanders invariably induce a dig here and there, and ROS induce the occasional circular scratch that persists through the next finer grits.

For unforgiving surfaces such as cherry and maple I do the initial surface preparation with a belt and/or ROS air driven sander down to about 120 grit. Then I move to hand sanding, starting with what ever grit I need to remove any problems created by the machine sanding and finishing at 180 or 220 by hand.

Bottom line: If I am dong an acre of surfaces for kitchen cabinets or book shelves I will rely entirely on the ROS. But for a piece of furniture, it will be hand sanded to perfection.

Re: random orbit sander

#8

Missing Step

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>In addition to what has been said, your MUST carefully and fully vacuum off the surface before moving to the next grit. Even if your sander is hooked to a shop-vac, the surface needs to be carefully brushed in the grain direction to dislodge any abrasive grit and then vacuumed off. Random bits of abrasive left on (or in) the surface will screw up the next finer scratch pattern such that you'll have to drop two stages to remove them wasting time and sandpaper.

Re: random orbit sander

#9

Re: random orbit sander

Jim Dillon

>Howard,

Agree with all others, and the need for patience. I have recently started to hand sand after I have finished using the ROS using the same grit that I ended with using the ROS; if I ended with 220 (most often), I hand sand with 220.

Also, don't apply any more downward pressure to the ROS than needed to keep it stable. Too much pressure will slow down the rotation (and I assume "randomness") of the pad. Usually, at least on my PC333(?), it is easy to hear when the motor is laboring or not.

Jim

Re: random orbit sander

#10

random orbit sander

del schisler

>Wouldn't good sand paper be in order here Not all paper is good ? I have a ridgid 6" orbit sander and use Bull Dog It is used for boat's I haven't had any scratch's that i noticed I sand down to 400 grit More that you have to I go from 100 - 200 - 280 - 300 -400 The number may be off Not even #'s but their isn't any scratch's their I use all hard wood's Unless my eye's arn't as good as they used to be? I spray cabnet grade lacqure on most M.L.CAMPBELL and thiner from them also Little more money but i thank it is worth it

Re: random orbit sander

#11

Re: random orbit sander

Jim Dillon

>Del,

I agree that using a quality sandpaper is good advice. What surprised me were the results from a woodworking magazine (FWW ?)test a year or so ago that tested various ROS. The used a clean piece of plexiglass to record the initial scratch marks from the ROS. I was amazed at the difference in scratch patterns between sanders. Several sanders clearly produced a more even pattern than others. So maybe it is a combination of the ROS used AND using a quality sandpaper that makes a difference. As I HATE sanding, I likely will continue to use the ROS to speed things up, but experiment with hand sanding at the end.

Jim