Mix Yer Own
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>I use a number of dye stains, both as NGR "stains" and as toner-finish components. I also use some oil to get a better "pop" out of the grain. Dyes will tend to even out the color and [IMO] kill the wood's grain character unless used judiciously (no pun there, George). I use dye on cherry to balance out the different colors and refractive issues in different parts of the workpiece. Yes, it takes some time, but I think it's the final expression of the craft (rather than just making something shiney) so I look on it as a challenge.
Personally I prefer pushing cherry into the red zone, so my stains will combine a medium brown with some amber and then kick it with a drop or two of Bordeaux (not the wine, George). I apply dyes by spray and wipe rather than flooding, and even mix a little shellac into the stain to control absorption. I will do 2 or three applications of a weaker mix to sneak up on the color that I want.
I next apply the oil in 2 coats, also wiped dry, then seal/tone with a lacquer ore shellac sanding sealer, and lastly topcoat with the final film-former. I use no pigments to stain closed pore woods like cherry as I think it produces muddy looking wood and kills the pop depth. I've tried oil-soluble dyes, but haven't had much success with them.
I approach each step as a different stage and opportunity to further bring out the wood's character. I think that if you go at a wood with as much character and variation as cherry with a 2-step "stain and finish" approach you'll risk missing some of the real beauty under your finger tips.
But, hey, that's just how I do it, YMMV |;-}}}