Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

To stain or not to stain...cherry

Posts

To stain or not to stain...cherry

#1

To stain or not to stain...cherry

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I always stain cherry pieces. I think they look richer. The secret to successful staining is meticulous sanding. There must be no sanding defects or deficiencies or they will take stain and show up as a dreaded blotch.

I have not been successful in staining hand planed cherry with a pigmented stain as the open pores take stain to readily and gets too dark. One can control darkness by what grit one stops at or by diluting the stain with linseed oil. In the example I went to 220 grit and diluted the stain 3 parts stain and one part oil.

Shown is a table top and leaf with the top stained with some very old (30-40 years) Sherwin William mineral pigmented stain. I am not fond of the modern dye stains. Some are god-awful colors.


img

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#2

PS: the leaf is back side, unstained

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#3

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>IMO, the touch of amber in NC lacquer is all that cherry needs to start with. Its natural darkening over time just adds to the richness.

Clint

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#4

Cherry double tansu 

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>


img

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#5

Sideboard 

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>


img

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#6

Mix Yer Own

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I use a number of dye stains, both as NGR "stains" and as toner-finish components. I also use some oil to get a better "pop" out of the grain. Dyes will tend to even out the color and [IMO] kill the wood's grain character unless used judiciously (no pun there, George). I use dye on cherry to balance out the different colors and refractive issues in different parts of the workpiece. Yes, it takes some time, but I think it's the final expression of the craft (rather than just making something shiney) so I look on it as a challenge.

Personally I prefer pushing cherry into the red zone, so my stains will combine a medium brown with some amber and then kick it with a drop or two of Bordeaux (not the wine, George). I apply dyes by spray and wipe rather than flooding, and even mix a little shellac into the stain to control absorption. I will do 2 or three applications of a weaker mix to sneak up on the color that I want.

I next apply the oil in 2 coats, also wiped dry, then seal/tone with a lacquer ore shellac sanding sealer, and lastly topcoat with the final film-former. I use no pigments to stain closed pore woods like cherry as I think it produces muddy looking wood and kills the pop depth. I've tried oil-soluble dyes, but haven't had much success with them.

I approach each step as a different stage and opportunity to further bring out the wood's character. I think that if you go at a wood with as much character and variation as cherry with a 2-step "stain and finish" approach you'll risk missing some of the real beauty under your finger tips.

But, hey, that's just how I do it, YMMV |;-}}}

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#7

Cherry table top 

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>


img

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#8

Opposite tack

paul in AZ------WebKitFormBoundary+isMX5X2paiDYC5e

>"I always stain cherry pieces. I think they look richer."

I never stain cherry. All I do is wipe on some boiled linseed to pop the grain and bring out some color then put the piece out in the sun for several days to accelerate the color change. From there finishing varies depending on use. Given some more time the wood gets a depth of color that I prefer.

Different tastes, different approach.

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#9

Example

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>This is the top of a Stickly sofa table I did in PA waterfall cherry. Top is in 3 pieces. Finish is a mix of Transtint dye stain with 1/4lb cut shellac added, one application Watco, sealed with several coats of dark garnet shellac then 6 coats of Target USL waterborne acrylic lacquer rubbed out with Meguire's. Knobs are dogwood


img

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#10

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening BILL,

I almost never stain/dye cherry. I like the effect of a few days worth of sunlight to bring out the natural reddish flavor. It doesn't bother me that the color and tone are not totally unified in even larger pieces. The pix shows the last cradle I built, then occupied by my youngest grand daughter, Eva. HARD TO IMPROVE ON PERFECTION. :<) A couple spit coats of shellac, and then wiping poly/naptha mixed 50/50.

George


img

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#11

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

Jesse Cloud

>I lean toward the simpler approach. Just shellac and wax on this wall cabinet. It is already considerably darker just two years later.


img

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#12

Nice Example of When NOT

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>to "blend" the wood's natural tone. The light and dark differentials lend a 3-D effect to the doors.

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#13

Plans?

Martin from Texas

>Colonel,

I really like your cradle, did you use plans? Or make it up on the fly?

Thanks,

Martin, who met you once, several years ago, at Grumbine's.

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#14

Re: Plans?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Martin,

I started out with plans/Measured "drawerings" from New Yankee Workshop. I made a few changes from the plans in initial and subsequent iterations. Joinery varied: the one pictured was box jointed. Others were butt jointed/screwed/plugged. In all cases I milled the carcase to 1/2" thickness because NYW version looked a little clunky to me. I re-designed the rockers to minimize the chance of tipping, but kept their thickness at 3/4".

George

Re: To stain or not to stain...cherry

#15

Thanks, Colonel!

Martin from Texas

>and thanks for the email with the extra pics!

V/R

Martin