Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Flattening wide Boards

Posts

Flattening wide Boards

#1

Flattening wide Boards

cse

>I'm sure this question has come up before and been answered but anyway. I�m flattening wide boards (11�) for a project that exceed jointer capacity. I have built a sled to use my planer and have noticed a couple things. 1) the sled has slight bow but under pressure is dead straight 2) once boards go through planer, there is a slight bow in middle of board. I have shimmed the center and the corners so there is no rocking and/or flexing with moderate pressure but still seem to get the bow. Now the bow is about 1/64th inch but curious about what solutions are there to resolve issue and what tolerances would be acceptable. I could see where this bow could be a non-issue with a panel construction but with drawer dividers they might cause some problems. Any thoughts/suggestions would be helpful.

Thanks

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#2

Re: Flattening wide Boards

cse

>1 more thing - the bow is along the length of about a 6' board' width wise is ok

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#3

Re: Flattening wide Boards

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon CSE,

I'd rip the boards to be consistent with the tools' capacity and process them conventionally before edge glueing.

George

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#4

Re: Flattening wide Boards

Brian Anderson

>You did not mention what kind of wood it is.

Nor did you mention any figuration.

I second the rip joint and reglue.

If there is a slight cup, the sled will simply produce a

thinner board, that will most likely never be completely flat.



The Jointer is designed to do two things; make a flat surface and make a flat edge. A surface planer or thickness planer makes the other side of the reference side flat. But the pinch rollers artificially flatten the board. I don't think the jig/sled can really correct for what the pinch rollers do.


Rip the wide stock, face joint, thickness plane, edge joint and reglue. That is what I would do.

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#5

Re: Flattening wide Boards

Ed Mulligan

>Golly, a bow of 1/64th over 6 feet sounds pretty good to me!

Sometimes I flatten wide boards as other posters have suggested: rip and reglue. I also sometimes flatten one side with hand planes and then send it through the planer with the flat side down. Either way, a 1/64 bow would be difficult to detect and of no concern if I could detect it.

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#6

I'd rip, edge joint, glue, plane anyway

Kneale Brownson..Awaiting return to CO snows

>With today's lumber, you'll probably not keep a board that wide flat regardless how flat you plane it. By ripping into four-inch widths or so and reversing sections, you'll be able to make it more stable after gluing back together.

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#7

Re: Flattening wide Boards

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I've used sleds for flattening wide boards and had decent luck. I'd say it's possible that either your sled is bowing a bit at the center, perhaps solid in/outfeed support the 6' length better. If you used shims the power of the feed rollers could still be compressing them a tiny amount.

That being said, as other's have stated, 1/64th of an inch over 6' is probably not even worth worrying about. The wood could be naturally bowing as you remove some of it's tension. Likely difficult to keep a long board dead flat.

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#8

Re: Flattening wide Boards

John in NM

>I suspect your lengthwise bow is coming from flex in the sled, you could try using some kind of support rollers next time, but I wouldn't worry about it. Most lumber won't stay dead flat over the course of a month anyway, assuming you can get it dead flat to begin with. Depending on the application, I don't think the bow you describe is worth worrying about - in most cases you can use the structure of the piece you're building to hold it straight.

I'm a little mystified about all the talk of ripping and re-gluing, this is a lengthwise bow is it not?

You can also easily face joint a 12+ inch board on an 8" jointer and probably 11" or so on a 6" jointer. Process does involve removing the guard, so if you're uncomfortable with that, stick to the sled.

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#9

Re: Flattening wide Boards

Fred Davis

>Ed is perfectly right in thinking a six foot long board with a 1/64" bow or hump is a keeper..

The wood in some instances can move more then that in 34 hours.

No reason to rip a wide board that is presently flat across its width into smaller boards and glue it back togather , unless you just want practice in that operation ;-))

The sled operation on the planer works well on cupped boards , anything beyone it's bed length is beyond it's control lengthwise.

FredD

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#10

Re: Flattening wide Boards

mike from american sycamore

>If you are any were close to Indianapolis and Cloverdale IN I have a 12" jointer that you could use.

Mike

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#11

Re: Flattening wide Boards

cse

>Thanks for all the responses. Just wanted to get some ideas. The thought of ripping the wide boards then re-glueing is not appealing as this would effect the grain flow and it seems that according to most that the slight bow is not that much. I'll try using jointer without the guard or try to to re-create a sled with a torsion box style to see it that helps. I have done flattening with hand planes but I have about 200 bf and the idea of doing that seems alittle tiring and I would like to finish the project this year :)

thanks much to all

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#12

Bit more info, please...

doug f, san clemente, ca

>You haven't mentioned what the project is going to be and if the 6' length will be supported; hopefully it will be. When it is fastened down, a 1/64" bow over 6' will be easily taken care of.

Just a thought.

Doug

Re: Flattening wide Boards

#13

Re: Bit more info, please...

cse

>I am building a chester county tall chest with Glen Huey at Marc Adams in Sep. The primary wood is cherry and the secondary wood is popular. The boards that are 11" are for the rails (9" and 10" wide) and the panels will be made of 8" wide panels edge glued. The top will be made of 2 12" wide cherry planks. The drawers will be from ~ 7 1/2" to 9 1/2" wide. So in the end I'll only have about 10 boards that need to retain the width mentioned earlier. The other boards I can rip (max 3 1/2" wide) and use jointer to flatten - so no problems there. So the idea of ripping the wide boards to flatten on jointer presents problem in terms of grain especially for drawers. this will be my first project this big with all solid wood - pretty pumped as this will be a great experience. I have taken several classes there with Marc and they have all been fantastic.