Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

3hp or 5hp table saw?

Posts

3hp or 5hp table saw?

#1

3hp or 5hp table saw?

Mitch from Canada

>Hey all,

I just bought a new Sawstop with a 5hp 3 phase motor and I had planned to use that motor but my eletrician buddy said that it would be cheaper if I just bought a single phase motor.

Even buying a new motor I'm way ahead on what I paid for everything. The question is, do I get a 5hp single phase unit or 3hp one? As I recall, Sawstop said they are both the same price.

My shop is currently wired to work with the 3hp motor, and I would have to wait about a month before I could get a panel installed in my garage and a bigger amp to use a 5hp motor.

I'm leaning toward the 3hp model, I had owned a Unisaw with a 3hp motor.

Let me know what y'all think. Thanks for your time.

Mitch

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#2

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

Nat Robison

>I'm no expert on saw motors but I think it's the consensus here that if you're not doing heavy production work, 3 hp is all that people need. I guess you have to weigh the electrical upgrades for the 5 hp vs. the addl. outlay for the 3 hp motor.

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#3

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I have a 3hp saw and I cut 12/4 hardwood all the time with no problems. A good blade helps. But if I could put a 5hp on my saw for roughly the same price I would do it. Most of the time I don't need it but when the blade starts to dull a little extra oomph wouldn't hurt.

Tom

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#4

How often did the 3 hp motor fail you?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>If you rarely or never felt the 3 hp motor straining, why buy more hp? You'll just generate more expense, both in upgrading your electrical service and in the amps you draw (and pay for).

The original Unisaws were 1-1/2 hp, and I imagine a lot of lumber went through them successfully over the years.

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#5

I've used both and...

Ralph in Huntington Beach

>...there's no difference. I have a 5hp 66 at home and used a 3 hp Uni at a cabinet shop I worked at, and I can tell you that there was never a time when I needed more then 3hp at the shop. I cut miles of 3/4 ply at the cab shop and if things "got out of hand" you can stall the 3hp motor to save your skin, but I'm not so sure I could stall out the 5hp Baldor motor on my 66. I've moved a couple of times and getting power to the 66 has been a pain.

My advice, should you decide to accept it, is to buy the 3 hp motor. You will NOT regret it.

Ralph

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#6

The 3 HP motor will kick back a

Forrest Addy

>The 3 HP motor will kick back a 4/4 x 6" 10 ft long gnarly maple hard enough to punch through drywall. A 5 HP will launch the same board and punch through the drywall and maybe take out the stud with it.

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#7

Sounds like experience speaking...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#8

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

Hal Smith

>I have a 3hp on my saw and have never stalled it in seven years of use. Has been adequate for some pretty heavy duty sawing. Keep a good sharp blade in your saw. I use a WWII, but change to an old Freud 24 tooth for ripping anything I don't want to run thru the WWII

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#9

5 HP seems overkill for most

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have used a 1 1/2 HP on a Delta and never found it lacking for anything I ever wanted to do and thousands of feet of hardwood have gone across it.

If I was production ripping 8/4 hardwoods I would want a larger motor. A lot of the HP demands depend on the blade.

It could be cheaper to but a VFD converter on the line and stay with the 3 phase.

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#10

A victim's perspective

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>You may recall I was a kickback victim. 5" penetration into my abdomen and hours of emergency trauma surgery. I don't disagree with the point about force but it is sort of like comparing a .32 cal. bullet to a .357 Magnum....either one can kill you just as effectively.

Tom

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: 5 HP is a hell of a load......

Jesper, Denmark

>on a single phase circuit.

My choice would be sticking with either 3 HP or 5 HP three phase as you have the three phase wiring.

Also I do not see why the single ophse motor would be cheaper than 3 phse, except the 3 phase is likely an industrial quality - good in the long run.

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#12

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

Pete in Holland, MI

>If you all ready bought the saw, buying a new motor to save electricity may be true, but the payback will be decades, assuming you use it A LOT.

This decision should have been made prior to pulling the trigger on the saw.

I assume you have 3-phase at your house?

Pete

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#13

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

Chris Friesen

>Hi Mitch...I'm in Saskatoon. Let me guess...you scooped up the one at the House of Tools liquidation?

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#14

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

Chris Friesen

>If it's the saw I'm thinking of, it was a liquidation sale at 50% off and the OP didn't have the option of buying a single-phase.

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#15

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

Fred Davis

>Mitch,

I don't know about the charge rate for 3 phase in Canada , but everywhere I have had a shop in the U.S had a minimum fee monthly for three phase service , which in your case is not needed unless you have a unlimited income.

Especially if you don't already have it.

FredD

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#16

Responses to a few questions on 3hp or 5hp motor

Mitch from Canada

>Hi again all,

Thanks for the response. Chris, I live close to S'toon and yep, it was a House of Tools deal, so the 3 phase just came with the unit.

I had planned on using the 3 phase motor that came with it, but 1) My electrical guy had hoped to snag a used transformer/converter for free and it turns out he can't get it anymore. 2) Buying a 3 phase converter from say Phase O Matic is about $648 US dollars plus shipping for what I'd need. 3) The 3hp or 5 hp single phase motor can be bought from Sawstop for $300.00 plus $40 shipping to where I am right now in the USA. (I'm in the USA on business until Aug 4th.)

After hearing the thoughts so far, the 3hp motor is most likely the one I'll order tomorow morning. My 3hp Unisaw always seemed to work well for me. If I ever need to sell the unit for any reason down the road, I'm thinking a 3hp single phase Sawstop will be alot more compatible with buyers shops than a 5hp single phase.

Since I have no use for the 5hp 3 phase Sawstop motor once it's replaced, I'll no doubt be selling it once I get back home.

If anyone else has something to offer I haven't thought of, or that hasn't been posted, please let me know.

Thanks to all for your thoughts. It's very much appreciated.

Mitch

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

#17

JL

Re: 3hp or 5hp table saw?

JL

>I have a 5 hp motor on my cabinet saw. It is normal phase, not 3 phase.

Have I ever used the 5 hp? Well, the closest I've come to it is sawing a bunch of Brazilian cherry (6/4). I think the 3 hp would have handled it nicely. The only reason I ever got the 5 hp is that it was the same price (or a little less) than the corresponding 3 hp saw. So I bought it.

Whatever, you do, you'll probably be happy.