Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

Posts

Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#1

Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

Pete Austin

>-- This is a follow-up from yesterday's urgent request for help --

First, thank you all for the help. I really appreciated the fast information and numerous opinions. It was enormously helpful and it was great to have old masters to turn to.

I went out to take a look at the saw this evening. I walked away - should I have? Should I go back?

Motor started easily. I cut a couple light pieces, and it ran through it like butter and with no hesitation. Felt balanced and smooth, and made me wish I had a nickle.

Based on the recommendations I got here, I let the motor run for 10 mins, turned it off, and felt for heat. The part of the motor furthest to the outside was cold. The housing deepest into the cabinet was warm, but not hot.

I talked him down to $275. I figured I could buy a new fence, salvage the miter and have a G1023 for under $500 and some elbow grease.

Then I turned the saw on one last time. While holding in the green power button, the motor jumped to life. When I released it, the motor quite. Press, start. Let go, stop. Not good. I tried this a couple more times, then it quit responding altogether. I waited a couple mins and tried again. Again the motor started while the green button was held down, and quit on release.

Owner said that this had never happened...but then he never found a need to let it run under no load for 10 minutes, then horse around with the switch.

I would have considered this to be the over-heating mechanism, and possibly a sign of a failing motor. It would be a bit odd since the motor housing only felt warm, not hot.

What do you think? What is the problem? Should I go back? I mean, $275 for a 3hp G1023 seems a darn good starting point. However, adding $300 for a new motor is not. Any ideas or suggestions would be appreciated.

A bit more information.

The rust on the pics was light surface rust. He has it in an oversized shed/barn. Very safe from the elements, but not the humidity. The inside of the cabinet looked fine - the only rust I could see was on the underside of the table, and on the exposed part of the top pulley.

The fence was shot and the miter will require work. Blade moved up/down/tilted easily. Light rust on the blade also.

Thank again in advance,

Pete


Here is the original post, with pictures.

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#2

Going back usually doesn't work in buyer's favor.

Eddie Pacheco; Antioch, Ca.

>You both have had time to think about it and you tipped him off to any bad points. He may spend some time removing the oxidation on his own now. The switch problem could have been sawdust in the contacts.

Give it a shot, but I'll be surprised if he doesn't get a few more bucks out of you.

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#3

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Q

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>It sounds more like switch problem than a motor problem. Price a switch from the local electric supply house and go from there.

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#4

Ellis Walentine

I agree

Ellis Walentine

>I don't think the motor is the problem. Tablesaw switches are pretty sensitive to dust and/or oxidation in the contacts. I recall having frequent problems with my Unisaw switch over the years. The one switch problem you don't want is with the magnetic starter though. If the motor starts when you push the on button and then stops, I'm a little concerned that it could be something going on with the magnetic switch. I don't know how you would figure this out without first trying to fix the push button. It might not hurt to find out what a new magnetic switch module costs.

This is all very speculative. I don't want to rain on the parade here.

Ellis

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#5

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Q

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Pete,

I agree that it sounds like a switch problem. If I had the money and I wanted the saw, I'd go back and get it. Since everything seems to work well from the way you describe it, $275 for a $1000 saw is a good deal. Even if you have to put a new switch on it.

Gary

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#6

$witch

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>A new mag switch for a 220 3hp 1ph saw should be less than $100. I rebuilt a friend's 1940's Unisaw and put a complete JET mag switch on it for $80.00 + shipping several years ago. Haven't shopped for one since, however.

Switch might just need to be blown out and cleaned.

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#7

If it's the switch, here's the fix

Walt Smith

>and it does sound like the switch, here is the exact switch for that saw--

http://www.grizzly.com/products/Magnetic-Switch-Single-Phase-220V-Only-3-HP/G4573

$69.95+shipping

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#8

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Q

Howard Norman

>The problem is most likely the mag switch. Not a major item. I would go back and get the saw today if it was me.

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#9

I'd buy it...

John E in SC

>Sounds like a pretty darn good deal for a nice saw. I'd buy it. Worse case scenario, even if you had to replace the motor, you've still got a nice saw for half what a new one would cost. (And it doesn't sound like the motor is the problem.) You might even be able to talk him down a little more due to the potentially bad switch.

Good luck, and let us know what you decide.

John

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#10

- Another Update -

Pete

>Another quick update. I called him back to say that I would take the saw for $275, and I asked him to check to see if the saw was continuing to have the same problem (to see if it stopped when the motor cooled down). The problem persists. One last quick check with you folks - still think I should get it, right?

Note that I am very handy - I wont have any problem cleaning or replacing the switch. Just want to be sure that this is what it is.

Thanks to all!

Pete

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#11

Buy It

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#12

Another vote for buying it

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

>Buy it. Worst case: You have to replace the mag starter, which is a 20 minute job and you can buy the parts from Grizzly for about $70. I would be willing to bet it just needs a cleaning.

Add a new fence and a good miter gauge and you have a slick saw.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, CA

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#13

Re: Another thought

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

>The probable reason for the motor not staying on is that the holding contacts in the mag starter aren't connecting correctly. The holding contacts make a connection across the pushbutton, holding the contacts in after you release the pushbutton. The stop button breaks the holding circuit and causes the contacts to open.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, CA

Re: Help Fast!--Should I buy Griz 1023--Followup Quest *LINK*

#14

Re: Another thought

Pete

>Ah, so that is how it works. Maybe something as simple as compressed air.... I'll try to locate the owner's manual.