Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

Posts

Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#1

Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

Barry Irby

>My ancient B&D Builders Sawcat is probably on its last legs, Again.

What saw would you replace it with? I want a "real" one.

Was thinking about a worm drive saw. Any suggestions?

Also noticed Porter Cable makes it's magnesium saw in both a left and right version. I have always wondered why the Blade on mine was on the "wrong" side. Apparently, on the east coast most saws are direct drive and the blade is on the right side, making us right handed people lean across the saw to See the blade. Would the PC saw with the blade on the left side be more comfortable for a right handed person? Any disadvantages? I was interested in a worm drive saw because the blade is on the left. Any other comments/suggestions?

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#2

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I have the Bosch worm drive with a top handle. Built my shop with it. Definitely a workhorse that runs true and won't quit.

Clint

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#3

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

Jerry Gibbs

>I have a left sided blade that I like for cutting plywood, holding the saw with my right hand and looking at the blade and cut from the left. When cross cutting 2x, it is cumbersome. Jerry Gibbs

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#4

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

R Payne

>For a right handed person the blade should be on the right side of the saw. You aren't supposed to be watching the blade (or if you must, you can see the cutting part of the blade from the left side if the blade is on the right), you are suppose to be using the guide marks on the base. When you use a saw in your right hand with the blade on the left you will have a lot more chips, splinter and dust thrown into your face than if you have the blade on the right.

ron

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#5

Thanks, I had not thought of the .....

Barry Irby

>Sawdust in the face thing. Does this mean all those worm drive saws do the same?

And why is it cumbersome for cutting 2x stuff?

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#6

Have 2

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Have a big Skill worm-drive (left blade - 7-1/4"); heavy, very stable, able to rip wet 2x and crosscut 4x all day. Handy for deck-building.

The one I use for sheet goods small stuff and framing is a PC Saw Boss; GREAT saw. 6" blade running at 6k does ply and 2x with ease, but won't wear you out hauling it round the jobsite. I prefer the left blade for control, especially when doing stopped cuts. Since I'm ALWAYS wearing safety glasses/goggles, a little saw dust doesn't bother at all.

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#7

Ellis Walentine

I prefer a sidewinder

Ellis Walentine

>... because it is lighter. I like the blade on the right because I'm right-handed and a right-handed saw is more natural for me. I like having the base of the saw resting fully on the workpiece, not the off fall. I can't see why there would be any difference in cut quality,but I haven't tested that theory.

Ellis

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#8

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Barry,

I have the Porter Cable with the left hand blade. Having grown up with cheap saws, I prefer to watch the blade rather than depending on the marks on the base. I agree that the saw is awkward for cutting 2x's. That's why they make miter saws. 8^]

I don't know about comparative accuracy for cutting sheet goods. I always use a straight edge for that task. The left hand blade puts the weight of the saw on the piece that's being cut. You do that with a right-hand saw and you are pushing the saw left-handed.

I can't really tell any difference in the amount of sawdust that's being tossed about. When you lean over a right hand saw to see the blade, you usually get a face full also.

Gary

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Skil 77 for this rightie.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Pros: more mass means less severe kickbacks, left blade for easy view of either the blade or the base marks, narrower--the motor doesn't overhang the base on the side, built like a tank.

Cons: chips/dust do get in your face (you should be wearing protection anyway, right?), it's heavy, it twists a bit on startup--you have to account/prepare for that.

I much prefer this wormdrive over right-blade sidewinders. I find that having the "keeper piece" under the narrow portion of the base doesn't really matter, you just have to think about what you're doing like with any other tool. I think it's great for breaking down sheet goods because you can see what you're doing even after you have to move around to one side when cutting an 8' long sheet lengthwise. With a sidewinder, if you do that and keep the blade on the opposite side, then you can't see the blade and still have parallax error with the base marks, unless you kill your back to lean over the saw.

Jason

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#10

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

Bill Roland (Mt Juliet, TN)

>I love my Porter Cable with blade on the left. I am basically one-eyed, don't see very well out of my left eye, and this saw affords me a better sight of where I am cutting.

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#11

Lefty

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>1. You can always find a way to make a cut without resting the saw on the cutoff on either a right or left bladed saw, just cut from the opposite direction.

2. For a right hander, a left side blade lets you cut using your dominant hand while you can hold the blade guard arm up with your left hand. This is handy because the guards tend to hang up at the beginning of the cut. Not a big deal unless you mar that $120 sheet of plywood you're breaking down.

3. When you are using a straight line cutting guide, it's easier to push the saw against the guide than it is to pull it towards you.

4. I get no chips in the face using my Sawboss, but it's blade is so thin, it may not actually create chips.

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#12

Another vote for the 77

Neal in San Jose

>I've had mine for over 20 years and the only maintenance it has required was a replacement cord (not the saw's fault). You can use the weight to your advantage if you set your stock up so it slopes down away from you at about 45 degrees and you are sawing downhill.

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#13

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

>I prefer the blade on the left side of the saw. I am right handed. I have used both and I don't like looking over the saw to try to see what I am cutting.

My first saw was an original Skill 77 that I inherited from by grandfather. It finally had been rebuilt so many times that it wasn't work repairing any more and after almost 50 years of hard use, was retired. My dad gave me another 77 that had been used and abused in the construction industry for years that I used until one of the casting gave out and I couldn't get a replacement because it was too old.

I replaced it with another 77. It is big and heavy, but doesn't stall at the slightest provocation like some of the sidewinders. I also like that it is quieter than a sidewinder. If the primary use will breaking down plywood, I would look hard at the little PC worm drive.

One thing I like about a worm drive saw is that it doesn't try to pivot in a circle like sidewinders tend to do if you are pushing the cut hard. The longer body of the saw gives you more leverage to keep it straight and the grip is inline with the blade, not off to the side.

Robby Wright

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#14

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

Fred Davis

>I know hundreds of Carpenters including myself who would disagree with you .

If the postere gets a PC with the blade on the left or a Skil Model 77 , you will be good to go .

FredD

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#15

Re: Thanks, I had not thought of the .....

Fred Davis

>It's only cumbersome Barry , if you havn't learned how to cut 2x .

If it is on a saw horse , grip the board with your left hand and tilt it up to a 45 degree slant and cut down.

If you have the lumber on the ground , place the 2x4 across your left instep , tilt it up and cut down.

When your cutting down , gravity gives you a little relief.

If your cutting overhead with a circular saw, you will have the sawdust on you regardless of how the blade is handed on the saw.

FredD

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#16

Re: I prefer a sidewinder

Fred Davis

>Ellis,

you would see right away if you cut wood with a Skilsaw daily, try this operation, standing the top plate of a two story building , reach out and made the 45 degree plumb cut on a hip rafter when the cut is about two feet away from you , good luck.

FredD

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#17

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

R Payne

>Working as a carpenter on many construction sites, I also know many other carpenters who disagree with me. But just because that is how they were taught and how they have been cutting for years doesn't mean they are right.

I still maintain it is easier for a righty to learn to use a circular saw with the blade on the right and it is safer and gives better results.

But I expect carpenters will disagree with me for a long, long time.

ron

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#18

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I started with a right-blade...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...but eventually got the Skil 77 later on. There's no looking back (or over the saw) for me. Just the simple fact that the handle is much closer to being in line with the blade makes the saw much easier to control, and I almost never have kickbacks--I used to get binds and kickbacks all the time with the typical right-blade sidewinder.

I KNOW I'm safer with the left-blade...

Jason

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#19

Re: I started with a right-blade...

R Payne

>I'll agree that a wormdrive with the handle more in-line with the blade is safer than a sidewinder. But if you were having problems with kickback and binding with the blade on the right using the saw right-handed, you were probably leaning over the saw to watch the blade and that is not the correct way to use a saw. And will result in more problems than having the blade on the wrong side. You should be using the marks on the base to guide the saw (that in itself with reduce kickbacks and binding). Unless the base is out of alignment that gives you better results.

I still maintain that properly used, a right blade is safer and easier for a tight hander.

ron

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

#20

Re: Portable Circ. Saw....Righty Vs. Lefty

Fred Davis

>And....you would be right.

On the other hand I guess what your saying is worm drive saws and some that arn't like Makita for instance , were expressly made for left handed people. ;-))

FredD