Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

Posts

Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

#1

Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>I am sure everyone here has broken some scrap after ripping, which broke in two places, sending the middle part flying across the room. This is more likely in woods with short cell structure, or brash characteristics.

I have never run across a scientific term for this trait. Any of you got a name for it?

------WebKitFormBoundary7u+fgTbgZjwnytH5

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

#2

Ellis Walentine

No help here

Ellis Walentine

>Brittle comes to mind. I wouldn't call it scientific, though, and I don't know of any technical term in common usage for this type of tendency to fracture. Brash is a term usually reserved for people who stick photos of people on their bird baths. :-)

Ellis

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

#3

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebK

Sgian Dubh

>Here's a bit of slightly edited text from something I've written on the subject Keith. The first two sentences provides a list of alternative names I am aware of that might answer your question, but I'm not sure. Slainte.

********************************************************************

Brash wood has a variety of related names including brashy, brashness and brashiness. Additionally this condition is called brittle heart, carrot heart, spongy heart, brash heart, soft heart. Natural brashness or brittleness develops in the living tree caused by the way a tree grows and the stresses it experiences in life. In every case brash wood is weak wood and it unexpectedly snaps across the grain under a load that normal wood of the same species would carry with ease.

Brashness is also caused artificially when wooden artefacts are subjected over time to high heat such as wood ladders used in boiler rooms.

************************************************************

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

#4

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebK

john lucas

>Don't know either but I did an interview with a guitar maker one time and he made a point to show me that the wood they used when bent would break with a chunk flying out separately. Just like you described. He said that type of wood made their guitars sound better.

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

#5

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebK *LINK*

Bob Lemon - Sacramento, CA

>Keith, this site might help.....


Case Hardened Wood

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

#6

Re: No help here

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Maybe you should show Tom a photo of a switch, one which has the opposite properties of Brash, and see if he gets the message.

I don't guess many parents switch their kids anymore, but writing that reminded me of Mom sending me out to get my own switch to be used on me. She would specify from the old peach tree, which had the toughest branches in the neighborhood. Trying to break off the friendliest looking branch took a lot of work, which extended the dread and was worse than the whoopin. ha

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

#7

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebK

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Hey Richard, I don't have any disagreement with what you stated, but more specifically, just the name for the Y shape break, resulting in the area in between the arms of the Y exploding out across the shop perpendicular to the a chord of the arc.

I guess what I find baffling is how and why it happens so frequently, when it seems like it should break along the weakest line of cell structure. As I try to ponder this, I suspect that the first failure must start along the grain of the neutral axis between the compression / tension wood, then out both ways from there.

To this I might add or in hot attics.

But also, I think you could also add that it happens rapidly under more intense heat while wood burns. If you notice when a big spark shoots out from a burning log, it most commonly shoots out perpendicular to the surface, like described above, only due to steam pockets here.

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

#8

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebK

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Bob, I don't think that is what is at play here. It is not uncommon to do with MDF.

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

#9

OK John Lucas, you can answer this question.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>All you need to do, is pull out the heavy equipment from your photo arsenal. If you used your video which can shoot about 1000 fps. you could draw lines across the test piece, then see the sequence of events. But maybe we need to add a couple of zero's to the fps to break it down more. You can do that can't you? 8>)

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

#10

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebK

Sgian Dubh

>Keith, I didn't think what I posted really answered your question.

I hadn't thought to mention hot attics as being a possible cause of brashness. But of course I live in the UK nowadays, so I'd not really considered that even though I did live in Houston for a good number of years where attics do get hot. My text does mention other hot spaces as potentially brash inducing, eg, commercial kitchens.

I've seen texts that mention fire being a cause of brashiness. I'm not fully convinced with the arguments that support the assertion. I've witnessed the phenomenom you described, but how much of that is brashness induced by high rapid heat, how likely is the splintering out due to a pocket of water, and how much is it due to weakness due simply to the surrounding and supporting wood being burnt away? Certainly blackened and charred poles, sticks, limbs, etc are much weaker than those that haven't been burnt that are of the same dimension, so I suspect there some evidence to back the brashiness through fire argument.

Anyway, I'm afraid I don't have an answer for the two breaks in a stick question you asked. Sorry. Slainte.

Re: Searching for a term, beyond "Brash"------WebKitFo

#11

It may be time to name it myself.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>I wonder if this is like naming new plant or animal species where it contains the last name of the definer. I don't think Keith Newton Failure sounds right, too many people would think of too many of my other life adventures. %\____√_____))

So how does" Abrupt Projectile Rupture, Newtonii "sound? I think it has potential for a game to compete in at woodworking roundup's. All you need is a trash-can of sticks, a target, and a case of good beer for the winner of course.