Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Shelving cleats sticking to wall

Posts

Shelving cleats sticking to wall

#1

A.J. Hamler

Shelving cleats sticking to wall

A.J. Hamler

>While in the process of updating my shop, I removed several sets of shelving to either move or replace with something else. The shelves are plain pine boards attached to cleats on the underside, which are in turn screwed to wall studs. No other adhesives used.

The thing of it is, is that when I took down the shelves and then unscrewed the cleats, they were stuck fast to the wall. Pulling them off also pulled of paint and numerous smallish sections of the drywall paper (although not all the way down to the plaster in most cases). While the repairs will be minor, there will be a LOT of them to smooth out those tears before repainting.

Is there any way to prevent this, or is this just something you gotta live with? I should note that those shelf cleats were not applied to fresh paint; in fact, the paint on the walls to which I screwed the cleats was about four years dry.

A.J.

Re: Shelving cleats sticking to wall

#2

Ellis Walentine

It had to be either....

Ellis Walentine

>.... the cleats or the paint, and my money is on the paint. Latex stays kinda rubbery even when it's dry. Maybe the pressure of the screws or nails holding the cleats to the drywall was enough to embed the cleats into the paint. (Theorizing madly here.)

I wonder if wax paper is the answer.

Ellis

Re: Shelving cleats sticking to wall

#3

Concur

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The less expensive the paint, in my experience, the longer it stays soft - you can probably imagine how I know this (there used to be a paint company called "Standard Brands." Their paint stayed soft forever).

When putting up things on painted walls that I might want to take down in future, I've gotten in the habit of taping plastic wrap to the back. Waxed paper, as Ellis suggests, would work similarly and perhaps is a more ecologically positive solution.

Re: Shelving cleats sticking to wall

#4

A.J. Hamler

Makes sense

A.J. Hamler

>I think we can rule out the wood, as other things have stuck to the walls in there, too -- fire extinquisher mount, switch plates, coat hooks and tool hangers, you name it.

Yeah, the paint in the garage was the original paint the contractors used when the house was built four years earlier when the original owners bought it. And in the five years that I've lived here since then, I've discovered that if there was a cheapest possible material to use or way of doing things, that's the way the builder went. This is a great house and generally well-built, but if there was a corner to be cut, he cut it.

You guys' idea about putting a barrier between the cleat and the wall is a good one. I have plenty of waxed paper, but if plastic wrap works, why not just apply a strip of glossy packing tape to the back of the cleats? Talk about quick.

A.J.

Re: Shelving cleats sticking to wall

#5

Re: Shelving cleats sticking to wall

Fred Davis

>Length of time doesn't seem to make any difference with acrylic Latex paint A. J.

Those plywood panels my wife paints holiday scenes on and I screw to the side of a six year old chicken house will peel paint off the chicken house every time.

FredD

Re: Shelving cleats sticking to wall

#6

Re: Shelving cleats sticking to wall

Victor Parisian

>Six year old chickens??? Those be hardly fit to stew.

Victor - Running for cover

Re: Shelving cleats sticking to wall

#7

Re: Makes sense

AZ in Colorado Springs

>I'd go with waxed paper. The tape sounds easy, but why introduce a layer of adhesive? Who knows where it'll end up over the interval until you re-decorate again? Probably nowhere, but why take a chance?

Re: Shelving cleats sticking to wall

#8

Re: Shelving cleats sticking to wall

Fred Davis

>and Guineas and Pea Fowl, very communal menagerie ;-))

FredD