Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

I need to build a replacement screen door

Posts

I need to build a replacement screen door

#1

I need to build a replacement screen door

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>and wonder if I can use poplar instead of pine. It's simply a matter of cost, since the 5/4 poplar is significantly cheaper than pine. It will be painted in any case.

Thanks

Bruce, screen door-less in MN

Re: I need to build a replacement screen door

#2

How protected is it?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>A local high end door manufacturer uses poplar in some doors that sure look, from the size and weight, like exterior doors.

Re: I need to build a replacement screen door

#3

Re: How protected is it?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Not protect at all, Bill. It'll be on the east side of the with virtually no eaves, since they are a full story higher than the door.

bh

Re: I need to build a replacement screen door

#4

Re: How protected is it?

Kneale Brownson..Awaiting return to CO snows

>Unless you're going to take it off and repaint every time there's a scratch or other break in the paint, I'd go with the pine. Poplar that gets wet rots pretty quickly.

Re: I need to build a replacement screen door

#5

That's what I needed to know,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>thanks, Kneale. The door is not protected from anything. Furthermore, the building is likely to sit unused for long periods, so there won't be anyone around to monitor its condition. Pine it is.

bh

Re: I need to build a replacement screen door

#6

Re: I need to build a replacement screen door

Fred Davis

>Softwood even though it's Poplar, is sized to 1 1/8 th inch thick, that's the thickness the locks and hinges are made for.

FredD

Re: I need to build a replacement screen door

#7

Re: That's what I needed to know,

RobV

>Why not use pressure treated wood?

I've built a couple of wood gates from pressure treated wood and they have held up over 15-years of weather without anything on them - I think a screen door probably would last even longer because it sits somewhat protected in a frame.

Re: I need to build a replacement screen door

#8

Re: That's what I needed to know,

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I think PT used on a screen door would be ugly. that, and the stock used for PT lumber tends to be umm, well..crap ('least it is in my neck of the woods).

What about red cedar? Sure, it may cost you 50% more, or even 100% more for the materials. But it's not like you're using a lot of wood.

I guess what I'm saying is there's places to save $$, and places you shouldn't save $$. This - being the entrance to your house, in my mind would qualify as a place you should not save $$.

Re: I need to build a replacement screen door

#9

Re: That's what I needed to know,

RobV

>>> the stock used for PT lumber tends to be umm,

>> well..crap ('least it is in my neck of the woods).

Must be just your neck of the woods, unless you're getting your PT from the borgs. :) Around here all the PT wood is clear pine and kiln dried. The last time I looked at the PT wood in the borgs it was filled with knots and dripping wet!