Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

DIY carving chisels *LINK*

Posts

DIY carving chisels *LINK*

#1

DIY carving chisels *LINK*

Forrest Addy

>What do you think of this. True they are chinese and possibly of dubious material and heat treatment. However its a fairly cheap way to gather a large assortment for not much. Those styles most used can be replaced with the quality goods.

They come unsharpened and the handles separate for the purchaser to DIY or for another $15 the seller will do it. I'd rather DIY so I can fine tune a few and maybe doctor the heat treatment.

I took a chance. I'll post a review.


30 pcs set wood carving chisel

Re: DIY carving chisels *LINK*

#2

A testimonial of sorts

Neal in San Jose

>About a decade ago, I took a carving class from world class carver Ian Agrell (agrellcarving.com). He was selling a small selection of Chinese chisels that looked identical to the ones you are referencing on ebay. I bought a few for about $10 each IIRC and sharpened them up. If anything, they are too hard, but with patience I can get an edge that holds just about forever. You might need to be a bit open minded about the shapes, as two of mine change curve from one side to the other, but I've gotten used to it and find that kind of handy as I can change shape by just rolling the chisel a little.

Mine have proven to be useful tools for a very reasonable price. YMMV since we can't be sure they are the same animal.

Re: DIY carving chisels *LINK*

#3

And another... *LINK*

David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast

>I have a set, too, from Ian Agrell by way of Nora Hall, and they are nothing short of superb.

Their temper and geometries are unusually well-suited to softer woods; very thin and flat with long bevels, but with appropriate technique, they'll do quite nicely in domestic hardwoods and the more well-mannered tropicals. One smaller gouge was a bit softer than the rest so I retempered it hit-and-miss a couple times and its fine now.

Sweeps, sizes and shapes differ from Western gouges, which works out nicely for me, and the fishtails make for elegant serifs when lettering. I became so enamored of these flaring gouges I bought two Henry Taylor allongees for hogging chair arms and legs to shape before going to the finer gouges.

The handles are nothing special but suffice well enough to keep me from making all new ones.

There is also a 'detailing' set with some interesting non-Western shapes (bottoming gouges, etc.) which I've threatened to buy for years, but I've made a few of these on my own to get by.


allongee gouge

Re: DIY carving chisels *LINK*

#4

Re: Don't waste your money

Brian in Brighton

>Took a close look and I see that there are only a few shapes, just wider versions of them.

I bought Pfiel chisels and bought them as I needed them. They are top notch and pricey, but they come completely ready to go. Then it's easier to keep them sharp. It's quite challenging to get a complete new edge on a veiner or #12 curve. Also keep in mind the size of what you will be doing. I have about 25 chisels and only occasionally wish I had more.

Get a few essential sizes to start with. Most carving books give advice on what the starter should have, but your projects will dictate it.

Now, if you are working on cleaning up chainsaw bears, by all means get this set and plan on tossing them as the break.

Brian in Brighton, buy the good stuff and it should last longer than you.