Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

OT - Furnace Brand Comparisons: Looking for...

Posts

OT - Furnace Brand Comparisons: Looking for...

#1

OT - Furnace Brand Comparisons: Looking for...

Joe Pack

>....facts, opinions or just wild guesses (although I have quite a few of those myself).

I am replacing a natural gas furnace/electric heat pump system. After a couple of months trying to educate myself on internet sites, looking at mfg. brochures and talking with various dealers in my area, I requested proposals from 6 dealers representing 4 brands...Trane, Lennox, Carrier and Bryant (Carrier twin). All dealers and all brands are reputable, have been in business for at least 20 years, and will most likely be in business for the foreseeable future.

I eliminated the Carrier dealer because his price was $1000+ more than the others for supposedly comparable equipment. I also eliminated the "best" pieces of equipment; the economy/payback on investment is just not there because the "better" equipment has efficiency ratings equal to or higher than the "best" equipment. Only the bells and whistles are different.

I am down to 3 dealers and 2 brands, Trane and Lennox. Each offer a 95% efficiency, 2 stage burner, variable speed dc motor package on their furnace. Each offer a single stage, scroll compressor heat pump with a claimed HSPF of 8.9-9.0. Each offer the "generic" MERV 10-11 4" media filter box that I specified (does the same as the brand name, just doesn't have the decal, and the MERV 10 filters are about 1/2 the cost of the proprietary sized 'branded' ones). The price differential between these dealers and systems is less than $80 after all rebates, 10 year parts/labor warranty and filtration are factored in.

The equipment specs are essentially equal (think Ford 500/Chevy Impala). The warranties are the same. The price is essentially the same. I like, and would trust, all of the dealers. So, that leaves the "real world" functioning of the equipment...dependability, how well it does what the ads say it will do, etc. That is where I am looking for your help...do you have any actual experience, either direct or indirect, with these furnaces? If so, I surely would appreciate your input.

The specific comparable furnaces are:

Trane XV95 2 stage/variable speed

Lennox G61V 2 stage/variable speed

As a follow-up, if I choose to go with Lennox, I am also considering the Lennox G71 which is pretty much the same as the G61V, except that, instead of a 2 stage burner (60% or 100% heat), it has a variable input burner (ex. 20% - 100%) depending on the amount of heat called for as determined by outside/inside temperatures. This variable speed furnace will add $500 to the cost. The efficiency numbers are no better than the cheaper model. I am told that "...it's no cheaper to run, it just gives you more comfort." Is the variable input furnace worth the extra money? Will I really notice a difference?

(It was interesting that Trane just now is starting to offer a variable input furnace to their dealers, but, according to the largest residential/commercial installer in our area, they choose not to mess with it because "...it is too new; we don't know what kinds of problems there might be with it yet." They are still recommending their dual stage, variable speed "proven" model.)

Insights are very much appreciated.

Opinions are welcome.

Smart-a** remarks will be smiled at or ignored, depending on the vein in which they are intended! :-)

Thanks,

Joe

Re: OT - Furnace Brand Comparisons: Looking for...

#2

Re: OT - Furnace Brand Comparisons: Looking for...

Barry Irby

>Joe, As a Home Inspector I have very little real information but a few opinions. My understanding is that many of the heat exchangers are made by a few companies and then passed around or shared. One company will make a small one, another a medium one and a third company will make a large one. Then they swap them among themselves so that they all can offer all three sizes. Not to mention that some companies operate under various name. Carrier/ Day Night/ Bryant/Payne and maybe others. American Standard owns Trane. Rheem and Ruud are the same. I don't know if the tuning each company does and the controls they add make any difference in efficiency or life expectancy.

My advice to most people is KISS. Keep it simple. I would tend to stay away from any exotica such as variable firing.

I have only seen seen one variable firing rate furnace on an inspection. Actually four in the same house that was about $1,600,000. It was one of the poorest installations I have ever seen. One unit had a 2" by 16" gap in the duct work. Another was so poorly supported it had collapsed and pulled away from the ducts and flue/vent. Two were vented out the front of the house, one on each side of the front stoop. In cold weather it would have been like standing between two dryer vents. Just goes to show that you can make crap out anything.

The installation may be more important than the equipment. I would buy middle of the road equipment and spend the savings making the house more efficient.

Re: OT - Furnace Brand Comparisons: Looking for...

#3

Re: OT - Furnace Brand Comparisons: Looking for...

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>I went through the same issue two years ago.

I looked at the same companies and went with Carrier, saved 47% on my heating bill in my first winter. I also went with a new Carrier AC at the same time. It was a bit more expensive than the others but reading Consumers Reports and talking with some neighbours who recenty made the same changes it was clear to me. Also with the Canadian Government Energy Rebates I got over $3k back.

Take care,

Jim