We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
My woodworking has taken several steps up on my priority list since I have retired from coaching High School soccer. So now that I have more time for wood working I would to upgrade some of my toys.
I am looking at investing in a mortise and tenon jig of some type. Currently I have the drill press attachment and it works ok. I have looked at several versions from the dedicated machine, portable router clamp on jigs, to the multi router. The multi router looks very nice but has a price tag to along with it. The Leigh FMT jig looks very promising with its versatility and the price isn�t completely out of sight. The dedicated machine looks to be just a step up from the drill attachment.
Any comments and recommendations are welcome from all.
>I've used the Multi-Router. Yes, it's expensive, but it does both mortises and tenons beautifully. The other expense are the template you have to buy for the various shapes.
I use a tenoning jig on my table saw. And, I made a platform to hold my stock as I cut the mortises with a router and a guide fence. Works very good. If you take your time with the router, so as not to flex the bit, you can get some great mortises. With a little practice on the table saw, you can get great tenons.
There are all sorts of bells and whistles out there, and they all carry a price, while variable in capabilities. I've used the router for tenon work.. I prefer to rely mostly on the table saw with either tenoning jig, or with dado blade. and either the router table OR a dedicated morticing machine for the mortices. I lean towards the dado arrangement in the table saw for tenons. To each: his own. Whatever floats your boat.
>I have the Steel City Tool Works Bench Mortiser.. Works great. No problems with it.
On the table saw I use a Delta tenoning jig, or whatever it's called.
Sometimes I use jigs I made along with my router(s).
Sometimes I use hand saws...
I think if I had a project that was going to require lots of M/T joints, I would prefer to use the router setup especially if it was lots of the same size.
>I've got them all 'cept the JDS (Benchtop Mortiser, Horizontal Mortiser, FMT, Handsaw & Chisel) and each of them have their place. The FMT is easiest to use if you have shop space and a router to leave it set up. Short stuff works real well on all systems - long stuff only seems to work well horizontally. I'm with George on this one - lots of different ways to skin this cat (and different price points). Nobody mentions the handsaw/shoulder plane/mortise chisel method - sometimes its the fastest way.
>I have the Powermatic benchtop mortiser (model???). I really like it. The mortises aren't near as clean as using a rotary tool, but they seem to work fine. I do my tenons on the ts using a delta tenoning jig. It works pretty well. I always do my final fit with a plane though. Its easier to me than trying to get it right on the ts. If I had the money, I'd look into the fancy mortiser. I've never heard anything but good about it by folks that use it.
I have always cut the Tenons on the table saw using the crosscut fence and Dado head, while setting the rip fence to the length of tenon needed as a stop.
This if done to a mark on a scrap of similar thickness will fit like a glove and you have the advantage if your cutting shouldered Tenons to just cut all the way around the piece and there you go , Tenon and shoulder all at once .
I have a FMT that I will be selling. Probably less than 2 hours use, still in original box. I'll get a list of the templates and let you know a price if you are interested. I live in Central IL. I am at the point in my hobby that I need to get rid of some duplication. I have had a multi-router for at least 20 years and I still go to it most often. Let me know if you would be interested.
>How about some more info. What types of pieces have you in mind that require mortise and tenon joinery (OR - loose tenon mortise and tenon joinery)?
Router based mortising, including the MultiRouter and LEIGH FMT, have limits to the depth of cut - about an inch and a quarter tomaybe 1 1/2", determined by the router bit being used. Chisel and bit mortisers will do to about 2 1/2", maybe three inches - for the larger sets, less for smaller chisels and bits. Horizontal boring/mortising machines can handle special mortising bits that can cut mortises 4 1/2" to 5" - in multiple passes of course.
If you need THROUGH mortise and teon joinery you CAN double the depth of cut for the router and chisel and bit mortising jigs and machines by cutting from both sides of the stock. BUT - any misalignment will take some hand work to fix - and adjustment to the tenon.
Note than for almost all furniture sized mortise and tenon joinery needs, Loose Tenon M&Ts will do the job - and eliminate the need for cutting tenons - with or without shoulders. And loose tenon joinery means ALL part lengths are their VISIBLE length - not their visible length PLUS the tenon length. AND - if you blow the location of the mortise -in either a side or end grain part - or both - the mortise can be filled with a loose tenon and recut - hopefully in the right location.
If you go with loose tenon mortise and tenon joinery the chisel and bit mortising machines are out since they won't cut mortises in end grain- even if you could get the part under the chisel and bit. Router based jigs like the LEIGH FMT and the Trend M&T Jig will allow you to cut mortises in end grain - IF - the part isn't too long (you could put these jigs up on a ladder to cut mortises into the end grain of a bed's sides - or a long table apron - but I don't think I'd want to operate a router spinning a bit at 20K to 30K rpms while standing on a ladder.
The Multi-Router, because parts can be cut while layiing horizontal on the XY table, can cut mortises into the end of a long part - but the table isn't that big so the other end of the long part should probably also be supported. And THAT can be a little problem since the part will be moving on two axis - and a roller stand is only meant to allow movement on one axis.
All of the methods in the list also require that at least one of each mortise be layed out - or at least the centerline and ends be layed out. THAT takes time - to do the layout AND to align the tool or jig to those layout lines.
Now if you don't care about which face of a table leg is the "show face", you only need one mortise layout and one set up (if the mortise is centered on the side of each leg - and the leg is square). But if the mortises aren't centered on the width of the leg - each leg may need TWO layouts and TWO set ups. More time and effort - and more opportunities for errors.
Notice, at the next WWing show demonstration of the M&T jigs - and maybe the video of the Multi-Router, that they only do ONE joint - one mortise and one tenon, or two mortises and a loose tenon. Ask the demonstrator to do a real world application - like four legs with two mortises on each, and four apron parts with a mortise or tenon on each end of each one. Bring a stop watch and time how long it takes to layout and cut this real world example - and note the number of set ups.
Which brings me to the overlooked Festool DOMINO. I mentored an absolute newbie to furniture making do a floor to ceiling linen cabinets - with raised panels and four doors - with well over a hundred mortises since it needed to be assembled on site (you can't stand a 94 inch tall by 20" deep by 32" wide cabinet upright when the ceiling height is 95 1/2" +/- a quarter inch.)
EVERY mortise was cut with the piece laying flat on my workbench and most didn't even require clamping the part.
Look into the DOMINO before deciding on your purchase. And if you can have someone who owns and has used one that would be even better since you really can't easily understand or appreciate the DOMINO 'til you've used one on a real world piece.
>Thanks everyone. This the type of info that I was looking for. Like many on you said there are a lot of options out there and all depends on what type of work you will be doing.
>I LOVE my FMT. I was a believer when I built my first large tool chest with it. It had 20 45 degree mortice and tennons and 30 90 degree ones. It took me a total of about two hours to do the lot. I spent more time trying to figure you exactly how to position the 45 degree tennon to get it to locate where I wanted but I was amazed at how fast it all went. I don't use it often but when I do, I'm really glad I spent the bucks.