Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT: Hot water heater rant

Posts

OT: Hot water heater rant

#1

OT: Hot water heater rant

Brian in Brighton

>So a week ago our HWH sprung a leak. Lucky the wife noticed a little water on the floor Sunday night. We shut it all off and drained it. On Monday I called the builder, 5 year old house, Contractor only HWH (Bradford White). Builder said too bad, the unit should be in warranty, but they would not help since the plumber on the house is not in business.

Made a few phone calls. The mfg said that they would warranty the unit and I "just" had to pay labor. Since the unit is in warranty, I figure it's got to be cheaper than buying a new unit.

Quote #1 (recommended by state Distributor) $375 plus the difference in the cost of the units from then to now. I said that the mfg said labor only. He argued. Didn't like the guy. No way.

Quote #2 Highly recommended plumbing company. Can't quote over the phone as too many unknowns. Alright, come out with a new unit and we can talk. He actually sat there with a straight face and quoted $691.14! I told him to call the boss. I told his boss that there was NO way I would pay that. I sent the guy home. 10 minutes later a knock on the door. He agreed to beat the other guys price by $5. I had everything ready for the guy and it would take him about an hour to do it. So he went from $691.14 to $370. Where did the .14 come from???

So I spent $370 to get the dumb thing replaced. At least I got the 2 year work warranty and another 6 year tank warranty. FYI, the 10 year warranty unit is NO different than the 6 year unit according to the manufacturer. :-o

Apparently the plumbing industry has now locked into the auto repair billing method of fixed pricing (over pricing).

Brian in Brighton........Arrrrrrggggggghhhhh!

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#2

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I just replaced an electric 40 gal WH with a new Whirlpool that I just happened to have in reserve in anticipation. Couldn't find my tubing cutter and soldering supplies, so I had to spend $40 on new stuff, which included braided stainless hookups.

Clint

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#3

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Brian,

I feel for you, man. I think you got ripped off bigtime.

Did any of these so-called plumbers even look to see where the old water heater was leaking? 5 years is way too early for a tank leak, we've had ours for nearly 30 years and the tank is still solid. I'm guessing an element gasket or one of the fittings, which should have been an easy (and cheap) fix.

$370 an hour. Must be nice.

Gary

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#4

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

Scott in Montana

>If the builder chose the HVAC subcontractor, he should stand behind the labor as well. He is the general contractor and is paid to be responsible for his underlings, sub-contractors.

Laws vary state to state, but I would investigate the consumer protection laws in your state.

Best of luck,

Scott in Montana

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#5

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

GalenV in Iowa

>Brian

So you feel a little better.

We had to replace the hot water heater just a little over a year ago as the old busted out at the seam. (Not the first time either) Both quotes were just under $600 for a 40 gallon gas unit. Like you found our Rheem/Ruud is a 5 year but for 10 year you are just paying for insurance on the same unit. They will put in a new anode to insure it will last for the 10 year.

The overall price includes disposal of the old unit and for the city to inspec when completed.

By the way, the city inspector filled out the sticker while upstairs and then just went down and put it on the unit. Looked at nothing!

The way some smaller communities maintain the water supply a hot water heater may only last 8 years if you are lucky. They do little to stabilize the water. Eats out the water mains and they wonder why!

The disposal fee is high enough the DIYers dump the old in the ditches outside of town. I know as I lived in

the rural area for years before needing to move to town.

You got by pretty well from my point of view.

Galen

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#6

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

Alex Grigoriev

>I suggest you:

1) check your water pressure;

2) make sure you don't set the temperature too high;

3) if you have water softener, the water will eat the piping and the heater pretty fast.

My WH works since like 1982 or so. I don't know.

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#7

And I'm feeling bad...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>because I met with an attorney today whose hourly rate is $300. He should have gone into plumbing.

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#8

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

Fred Davis

>Brian,

you just learned what few outside the building trades know.

Regarding a W.H , the only difference between a five year warranty and ten year warrabty is the price.

So , that makes the five year warranty the best deal.

Fredd

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#9

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

Fred Davis

>Gary,

before you count your blessings , just because your unit hasn't hemorrhaged doesn't meant it hasn't lost about fifty % of it's original efficiency.

If you haven't drained it annually , it also could have six inches of mud in the bottom , which cuts down the amount of hot water it will hold.

Gas fired W.H. and gas fired furnaces are subject to lost efficiency with ageing.

Glass lined , Electric W.H. keep their original efficiency longer , but it's like setting money on fire to heat water that way.

Most people are conscientious about maintaining their vehicles and never give a thought to the Furnace or W.H which invariably develop a problem on weekends, nights and Holidays, in the Winter ;-))

FredD

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#10

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

Brian in Brighton

>Pressure is at 50psi, which I consider low as the old house was at 65.

The temp is 1 notch above middle, so about 130.

Softener is required because the water supply has been run thru an osmosis system and has lots added afterward the water company. The water company tested our water as some of the best, although they are not happy that we use a softener with Potassium instead of salt to help remove the salt they put in. But we are not happy that they add all the crap they ad.

Brian

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#11

Re: Remember the first bid was $500 an hour

Brian in Brighton

>

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#12

Re: OT: rub it in

Brian in Brighton

>Sure, just rub it in. The only reason I went with it is because it's still cheaper than buying a new 50 gallon gas unit and dealing with it myself.

My butt still hurts :-(

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

#13

Re: OT: Hot water heater rant

Fred Davis

>Brian,

if your water treatment plant is using Reverse Osmosis , then you will most likely be really unhappy when you discover that that type of water treatment wastes two gallons of water for every one used , when you get your next water bill .

The powers that be talked the voters in Abilene , to go that route with a new water treatment plant and for a long time , the waste factor was a well kept secret at City Hall, long after people were asking questions about where was the water running down 7th st. and flowing into the creek coming from.

FredD