Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

I'm Just Curious......

Posts

I'm Just Curious......

#1

I'm Just Curious......

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>There was an article in our local paper yesterday about 4 people who are starting a new business. Since then I have had 2 people ask me what I thought so I thought this would be a good place to get other opinions.

These 4 folks (one married couple and 2 friends) are building a "dream woodshop" (as they call it) The premise of the business is to have "shareholders" buy in and have access to to the workshop. A "for fee" community workshop is not a new idea. But here are the basics of this:

This is a small midwestern college city. I have no idea how many woodworkers there are here but several years ago a group tried to start a woodworking guild and it failed after about 18 months due to low attendance.

The owners of this new business have this outline:

To buy in, each woodworker has to pay $10,000

There is an annual dues of $1,000.

Each member is required to perform 40 hours per year cleaning the shop.

The hours of the shop will be M-F 8:00- 5:00 and Sat. 8:00- Noon.

The owners say they will equip the shop with "state of the art tools".

The owners also plan to have space adjoining the woodshop where they will sell tools and supplies retail. They have affiliated with Rockler as a supplier.

So I'm curious what you folks think. Will it work?

And for the record, my response when asked..."I'll be looking for their tool auction eventually".

Tom

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#2

Re: I'm Just Curious......

Jesse Cloud

>Let us know when the auction is....

Seriously, a few things come to mind:

- the 10K buy in - is the idea to maintain that capital or is it seen as operating expenses for a few years?

- 1K per year dues?? the expenses on the place are going to be way more than 4K per year.

- are they trying to cover rent, taxes, insurance, etc. or is someone chipping that in?

- why establish shop hours? why not let the principals use it whenever they want?

- 40 hours a year to keep the shop clean - yeah, right.

- who will be responsible for equipment maintenance (sharpening, tuning, changing jointer knives, etc.)

Its hard to run a business with friends. Many don't work and break up friendships. Hope they see this as buds sharing expenses to do something they love.

Anyhow, good luck to them!

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#3

Never, ever, ever . . .

steve mackay

>do business or go into ventures involving money (let alone tens of thousands of dollars !) with family OR friends. Eventualy (sooner rather than later) someone is going to get their feelings hurt, go broke or, at the very least, loose said family or friend for a VERY long time. Been there, done that and still stinging from it.

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#4

Re: I'm Just Curious......

Kneale Brownson..Awaiting return to CO snows

>Seems like a pretty high buy-in fee for equipment one would have to share afterward.

That ten grand would go a long way toward outfitting a personal shop where you could own/resell your equipment as you wished. What happens to your share if you move away? I think I'd rather pay someone for use of their expensive widebelt sander or extra large planer and have the less costly gear in my own shop.

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#5

Re: I'm Just Curious......

Thomas S Stockton

>Tom,

I hate to say it but it is not going to work. It's just to much money, the places I've heard about are much more affordable and with various pay as you go type plans. For 10k you can easily outfit a really nice shop especially if you shop around and find some nice used stuff. The other thing is that most people with that type of extra income are probably going to have space for a shop in a garage or basement.

Tom

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#6

Re: I'm Just Curious......

Nat Robison

>I'm assuming to be a "member", you pay $10k and $1k per year? This is aside from the owners' investment? After 10 years, you'd have invested $20k and wouldn't own a thing.

$10k would outfit any shop with a decent table saw, jointer, planer, routers, and hand tools.

Why would anyone sign up for this deal when they can replicate it in their own garage, use it when they feel like it, clean it when they feel like it, and not share the machines if they feel like it??

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#7

Re: I'm Just Curious......

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>They sound like dilettantes who have no actual knowledge of the practice of woodworking or those who do it.

Clint

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#8

more

Thomas S Stockton

>Shouldn't read these things with a stuffed head I totally missed the hours. The hours posted is going to be more of a factor in the business not working out then the money. I assuming they are going after amatuer/hobbiest types, these are the exact hours they are at work unless central Illinios has turned into a retirement mecca in the last week.

Tom

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#9

And for what it's worth....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>....I have a shop that is equipped for my needs and my business. My tools are paid for. I would have no need for that operation, nor would it make any sense business-wise for me.

I'm sure it's geared for the hobbyists. But for a $10K buy-in, one would need to be a pretty serious hobbyist! And one who doesn't have a M-F 8-5 job too.

Tom

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#10

Don't Think So

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I've seen several "Co-op Shop" deals tried. All failed; usually in not a nice way.

Couple of points on your scenario:

"Buy-in" of shares sounds fine until somebody demands to sell back their share because of a) financial hardship b) moving away c) falling out among users d) scheduling and getting work done [one or two guys hogging the machines] with unequal access.

Hours sound like business hours - hobbyists [those likely to use this kind of thing] want evenings and all weekend.

May have serious OSHA issues.

The insurance will be a nightmare for compliance even if OSHA doesn't apply and will be canceled two minutes after the first injury is reported.

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#11

Re: I'm Just Curious......

Michael Bush

>I agree with others that the financial aspects of this don't work.

However, I have heard of people having success with car repair shops set up pretty much like this.

I think you've got to be in NYC or some other very densely populated area, though, where people do not have and cannot get their own workspace.

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#12

Re: I'm Just Curious......

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>The buy in price seems really high and the hour seem really tight. I'm sure there are a lot of details we haven't seen - at least I'm hoping all the details are worked out. Who will man the shop, who will cover maintenance, who will provide training. What happens when someone needs to customize a machine with jigs or other fixtures. What happens when a new machine is needed.

Also not noted here is what if someone is using the shop to make pieces they are selling. Will the shop require some part of the sale price. If the shop doesn't allow people to sell anything made there, then a 10K price is really really high.

I would also want to know what a "dream shop" is? My interpretation could be a lot different from another persons.

Safety/Insurance are big concerns in an undertaking like this.

I have to wish them the best, though. I don't like to be too negative all the time. I simply hope they do their homework and really detail everything about the business before jumping in. There are a ton of very good resources/people/books to help start a new business. Use all of them. The surest way to see a business fail is to start it without a plan.

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#13

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Your two posts...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...were my thoughts exactly.

On top of that, I'd be with Tommy on looking for the tool auction.

Being self-employed, I tend to be a bit pessimistic on new businesses. Sure, there are those who can make it work, but it's a long, hard, road to make it comfortably successful, and I think most who enter into these endeavors underestimate the true costs involved, not all of them monetary.

Several years ago, some brothers for whom I've worked over the years (they own a local buy-here-pay-here car lot) bought a couple buildings. The first was a concrete warehouse that they eventually leased to a heavy duty truck tire/service shop. From the looks of it when I drive by, it's still going strong. Their second building, in a very high traffic area, they leased almost from the get-go to a guy who put in the U.S.'s largest indoor electric go-kart track. The problem was, he was marketing it to families (he put in an arcade, too--skee-ball and the like), but at $7.50 for 5 min of ride time, there was no way it was going to happen, and all of us who worked on it (most of us family-type people) told him so. He would have been better off putting in a bar and marketing to the 21-34 y.o. single male demographic. Unfortunately, that would have meant higher damage and repair costs. He scraped by for about 3 years, but finally closed it down last year. I don't think he ever turned a profit.

Sorry for my rabbit trail.

One thing I didn't see mentioned is that someone who is already into woodworking will likely have their own shop setup, maybe not with the best tools, but serviceable. Someone who is not already woodworking, and just taking up the hobby is going to choke on the $10k buy-in. That's an awful large up-front commitment for just starting in a hobby you don't know if you'll even like. And, what if you take a year or two off? Do you have to re-buy-in, or pay back-dues? Can you sell your share? How much are the owners putting in up front?

Let us know when the tool auction is, Tommy.

Jason

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#14

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: The Insurance premiums

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>The Insurance premiums alone ought to preclude the business getting started. I'd venture a guess that the $10K buy-in wouldn't even cover the insurance, let alone the tools, etc.

That auction will be coming soon!

Maybe the Rockler franchise will work out, though...

When I lived in California, a local entrepreneur tried to start a woodworking club - with attached Woodcraft store - with a reasonably well equipped shop and hours specific memberships. They also 'rented' shop time to non club members. The operation lasted about a year - until somebody got hurt, and the insurance premiums quintupled, and the deductable went to $10,000.00

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#15

When It Doesn't Suceed

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>They can get a bailout from the government-----

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#16

10K? My shop, and all my tools, cost less.

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#17

Re: I'm Just Curious......

Ron in Sterling, CT

>I think the only thing that will work will be the auction at the end.

Ron

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#18

You are asking the wrong People......

Barry Irby

>Everyone here has something that passes for a shop. Google "I wish I had a Wood Shop.ORG" and ask them. Or maybe it should be .NZ or .UK.

Most of us here (I am betting) did not intend to spend 10K on tools. Many of us have, but never really meant to and if we had to do it all at once, probably wouldn't have.

What about the guy that goes in a starts the really big project like an airplane, then realizes it won't fit through the doors and has to fly it out? Or the giant entertainment center that blokes everyone else's access to their project and then abandons it?

Or the guy who decides to dress ten thousand feet of lumber? And crushes the abandoned entertainment center piling lumber on it.

I seldom work in my own shop during those hours. I would want it to be open as all the other hours. I my mind, I don't spend forty hours a year cleaning my own shop. I do, but not in my mind.

I have a friend with what most people would think of as a dream shop. About an hour away. He has a big industrial belt sander, 3' wide. I can use it for free. He doesn't even charge me for the belts. I've used it about twice in twenty years. Bought a Performax to avoid the drive. PITA factor to load up the stuff, drive an hour, do the work, do the obligatory BS with my friend, load it back up and drive home, load it back into my shop. Sure fire method to make it rain.

What I am saying is I would love to have access to a dream shop. But wait, I do. Free. Still don't use it. Perhaps the answer is I should give my friend 10k and I would feel more vested in using his shop.

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#19

Sign me up for the auction mailing

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Your friends better rview their business model. Fo $10K you can get a pretty nice shop at home that works the hours you want. The $1k annual dues buys a lot of materials. Someone will have to track the 40 hours of cleaning per year. I'll schedule mine right after that guy that just cleaned.

I can hear the patron questions now:

* Can I bring in old pallet lumber and railrod ties to clean up on the planer and jointer?

* You mean there were nails in that old barn board!

* I need to make a few more cuts, can I borrow this blade (bit) so I can finish it up at home.

* I just put glue on this 100 piece assembly, I can't leave now, give me another 5 minutes to get it clamped up.

* Friday is a holiday are you going to be open?

I'll take a copy of the auction flyer.

Lee

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#20

Yeah.....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>....For $10,0000 I would feel entitled to beat those tools like a rented mule. Not that I would of course. ;-)

T.

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#21

JL

Ditto on the auction mailing...

JL

>The hours are ridiculous.

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#22

no chance of success

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When you get right down to it not very many "woodworkers" actually build much stuff. We were the only game in town for years selling hardwood lumber so I had a good idea of how much stuff was built. And we had/have an active cub supporting the hobby. In spite of this large potential pool of woodworkers I didn't see evidence that they made much. $10K in and $1000/year is steep price unless you are turning out a lot of stuff. Cheaper to take a class a year and make something in class.

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#23

I get notices from IRS tool auctions

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>I can't help but think that as cheaply as very nice very expensive tools are being auctioned off for every week, that now may be a great time to set up a wonderful shop for about 10� on the dollar.

Also, there may be some pretty good tech-savvy employees desperate to get back to work, and who are motivated to turn out a lot of product.

However, When finished goods are shipped in from the other side of the world, cheaper than I can buy the raw materials, it is still going to be real tough to anything other than custom work.

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#24

Re: I'm Just Curious......

Marv

>Even when there is only two partners in a business, there is potential for eventual, inevitable problems.

To have numerous partners, it is doomed to fail.

My guess is, the people who are wanting to start the venture have not lived very long.

Marv

Re: I'm Just Curious......

#25

Re: I'm Just Curious......

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>It's open only during the hours that those who have regular jobs are at work, plus a few hours on Saturday? Won't work out.

Those who would do it as a hobby couldn't get in.

Those who would use it for professional work need every hour they can get (and don't need others in the way, cluttering them up).

And $10,000????