Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

OT - Compass (magnetic)

Posts

OT - Compass (magnetic)

#1

JL

OT - Compass (magnetic)

JL

>The LOML and I are trying to hike more (and on a regular basis). We would like to get a compass - something more advanced than the old metal cased one that we currently have.

From my research, I've found out about Brunton and Suunto. I don't really have a preference - though I do have a gift card for LL Bean (which carries Suunto). My BIL has a fancy Brunton. Anyone have any recommendations.

I have found that GPS does NOT work in some of the places that we hike - the mountains and trees evidently block enough of the satellite signals. That is why I am looking for a compass.

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

#2

Can you be more specific?

John in NM

>Brunton has several models, some of which are more than you need for hiking - I can't say as a pocket transit would really be money well spent. Most Suunto's I've seen are nice compasses and I'd think any would be good for a hiker, but I wasn't pleased with the lack of a waranty on a KB model I got from my father - I guess I'm too used to companies like Lee Valley and Lie Neilsen....

I'd look at any of the models comparable to a Silva Ranger, even those are more of a mapping compass than hiking, but if you ever get into orienteering or the like you'd want something like that and all three makers should be well under $100 (I haven't priced these things in about 15 years).

Which models were you looking at?

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

#3

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

DaleLenz

>For 25+ years I've used a silva ranger compass, azmuith. Purchase ours at Forestry Suppliers in Jackson, MS. I'm on my second one, not bad for 20+ years tossing around in a pick-up and busting brush.

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

#4

Whichever one you get,

Winnemucca Lynn

>make sure that you can change the declination. What the declinatioon is, depends on where you are.

Lynn

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

#5

Re: Whichever one you get,

Bill Earl

>Many have declination correcton scales. This requires you to manually add in the declination offset. Better ones have a declination adjustment that once set, allows you to read true north directly.

Brunton, Suunto and Silva all make a range of excellent devices. Some of the newer Bruntons have a tool-less declinaton adjustment. I just bought a pair of Bruntin 8010G's for my sons.

P.S. If you hike in different parts of the globe, be sure to pay attention to the local declination. I can say from experience that there is a big difference between +6 and -7.

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

#6

JL

Re: Can you be more specific?

JL

>I was looking at the Suunto MC-2D or the Brunton 15TDCL.

I am not going orienteering - but I may go up on parts of the Appalachian Trail.

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

#7

Either one looks good....

John in NM

>I know thats not much of an answer :)

Either model should fit your needs well, I think you'd be fairly hard pressed to find much difference between them. I find a quadrant scale more intuitive than azimuth, but one gets used to either, and I'd be surprised if both manufacturers didn't give you a choice.

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

#8

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I've carried and used a Silva Boy Scout Compass for years. I would recommend that you also get a pedometer so you can track how far you walk and get some training on actually using a compass to navigate. Make sure you have a lanyard for your compass as they tend to get lost otherwise.

I wouldn't give up on the GPS completely as if you get in the open or stop for a while it will generally find enough satellites to fix your location. SInce teh satellites move, it will work better during certain times of the day than others.

Lee


img

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

#9

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

Brian in Brighton

>I have a Garmin unit with the map software. One thing I have to say. Learn to use it, learn to use it, learn to use it. It has a tracking feature that makes a little dotted trail where I use it. I use that, along with the occasional waypoint, to be able to hike back. I used it hunting last year and did not have a problem with signals, and that's in the Rocky Mountains. I leave it off until I get to where we leave the truck. Turn in on, make a waypoint, start hiking. I have hiked in some pretty remote areas and have not had any issues with signals. The trackback is great, as long as you can understand when and where you might have crossed your own path. I don't see how great a gps would be without the maps.

Always keep a topo map and compass in addition to the gps. The map is easier to see the overall picture than the little gps screen. I use a compass like the one in the pic. It's easy enough to use it. If you need training keep an eye out for the local sports or hunting store classes, sometime the local CC might have one.

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

#10

why the precise need?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have hiked and hunted all my life and never needed to know where I was going to better than +/- 10 degrees. Its not hard to hit a road, creek or ridge and then know which way to turn. I carry, when needed, something small and durable. Maybe for hiking in the TX panhandle something more precise would be desirable so that one could hit Oklahoma if needed. Only for amateur surveying have I ever needed something more precise.

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

#11

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

Ken Kimura

>The brand is not a critical as the features. You want to get one that has an adjustable declination mechanism. It should have a clear base with meridian lines clearly visible through the dial and a nice optional feature is a hinged cover with sighting mirror. You will be looking at a price of $30 and more. Try and find a navigation class in the area. Hikers usually use the compass, altimiter and topo map together.

Re: OT - Compass (magnetic)

#12

M-2 ! . . .

steve mackay

>NOT a repro, but a REAL MIL M-2. Its going to do MUCH MORE than you need it to but worth it for it's ruggedness.