Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

OT: Weird ceiling fan problem

Posts

OT: Weird ceiling fan problem

#1

OT: Weird ceiling fan problem

wilbur

>I just installed a pair of ceiling fans in our two boy's bedrooms today. They are your basic ceiling fans, with 3 fan speeds, lights that take CFL bulbs, and I got the remote controller so that they can be controlled from the wall switch. One got installed without a hitch. WIth the second, there's a weird problem.

The remote controller has buttons for fan speeds and a "fan off" button. There's another button that turns the light on and off. There's also a master switch that completely cuts power to the ceiling fan. The master switch needs to be on for the remote control to work, so although the fan and lights may be off, there is power to the ceiling fan (actually, to the remote control receiver) if the master switch is on.

Here's the weirdness: When the master switch is on, and the light button has the lights turned off, there is flickering with the lights. The flicker occurs about once every 1-2 seconds. Once I turn off the master switch, the flickering stops. The fan and remote controls work perfectly otherwise, and when the lights are on, they work fine.

Any idea what is going on? The only theory that I have is that when hooking up the ceiling fan to the electric wires, I might have reversed the neutral and hot connections, and somehow that's causing the flickering, but that's a bit of a stretch. I would imagine more things would go wrong if I did that.

Re: OT: Weird ceiling fan problem

#2

Re: OT: Weird ceiling fan problem

GalenV in Iowa

>I assume the two fans are identical. If you switch the remote transmitters does the problem occur in the "good" fan light that had worked and the "bad" fan light now work correctly? May be in the transmitter light switch on that one unit.

I imagine the problem is in the reciever but at least this will check out the transmitters. You may not have done anything wrong there just may be a defect in the reciever. If they use a traic for the light switch the gate may just be getting a pulse high or low and about halfcycle of the AC power. May be easier to return the one for another unless you find you pinch a wire when you put the unit together.

Just my two cents worth from afar

Galen

Re: OT: Weird ceiling fan problem

#3

Re: OT: Weird ceiling fan problem

Jay Lombardo

>Did the bulbs come with the fixtures? Do they specifically say they are designed for CFL's? Most CFL bulbs are not dimmable (some of the new ones are but very pricey) and what happens with dimmers is a very small amount of voltage basically leaks to the bulb trying to ignite the exciter in the bulb, hence the small flicker. The bulb typically burns out in about a day. By the way this is also true with electronic timers, the kind to turn on your porch lights or coach lighting if you put in CFL they will flicker when not on and burn out. We found this out the hard way and then did the research to find out it is true. The bulb manufacturers say it is the timer company's problem to fix, and it is. The older timers with mechanical contacts are OK it is just the electronic ones. I learned all this when I was trying to do right by a customer by installing a CFL in a very difficult to reach outdoor porch light, only have to change the bulb once every 5 years right, wrong! I was back the next day doing it again, and the day after that again. Check your information on what bulbs to use.

Good Luck,

Jay

Re: OT: Weird ceiling fan problem

#4

Re: OT: Weird ceiling fan problem

del schisler

>If one work's With CFL bulb And the other one doesn't I don't belive it is the bulb If you thank something is wrong with bulb exchange with the one that is working and see if that fix's ? May be a reverse neg and pos on the hook up That is what i would check for May be a voltage leekage trying to find a ground Which if reverse wire It may not be looking for ground ? cant see it from here good luck

Re: OT: Weird ceiling fan problem

#5

Answer

wilbur

>Well, an answer, but not really a solution.

Apparently the issue is with the combination of the remote and the CFL bulbs. When the remote is in standby mode, a little power is going to the lamps in the ceiling fans, which causes flickering in the CFL bulbs. It turns out that the ceiling fan that I thought was okay also has flickering, but less than the other one that I initially noticed.

It looks like my options are to either use incandescent bulbs, or remove the remote. Supposedly dimmable CFLs will work, but various people have said that it didn't solve the problem. Also, replacing one of the CFLs with an incandescent bulb is said to work, but I haven't found that to be the case in my ceiling fans.

Re: OT: Weird ceiling fan problem

#6

Re: Answer

Jay Lombardo

>Dimmable CFL's will not work either they will flicker and burn out also. Go with the incandescent.

Jay