Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Precision Tree Felling-step 1

Posts

Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#1

Precision Tree Felling-step 1

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There was a recent post questioning taking down a tree. I took photos at today's logging contest showing how it is done.

Show is the "tree" and this cut was for the championship. It is leaning 4' backwards from the target area. The logger is cutting "shelves" for his wedges on each side of the tree in this scene.


img

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#2

Step 2

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The logger has cut a 70 degree notch in the front of the tree toward the target area. Then it made a "boring" cut clean through the center of the tree to cut out its center. This cut prevents the center from splintering as it falls. He left a 1" "hinge" between the center and the forward notch. This hinge will direct the angle it falls at as it will fall orthogonal to the wedge. Then he installed wedges in each side of the bore hole to support the tree as he cut through the back of the tree to free it to fall. He is shown making the cut through the back. At this point all that is holding the tree up are two plastic wedges and a 1" section of the tree comprising the "hinge". It is still leaning 4' backwards.

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#3

Step 2

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The logger has cut a 70 degree notch in the front of the tree toward the target area. Then it made a "boring" cut clean through the center of the tree to cut out its center. This cut prevents the center from splintering as it falls. He left a 1" "hinge" between the center and the forward notch. This hinge will direct the angle it falls at as it will fall orthogonal to the wedge. Then he installed wedges in each side of the bore hole to support the tree as he cut through the back of the tree to free it to fall. He is shown making the cut through the back. At this point all that is holding the tree up are two plastic wedges and a 1" section of the tree comprising the "hinge". It is still leaning 4' backwards.


img

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#4

Step 3

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Here the logger is pounding in the wedges. If he lifts a 60' tree 1" with a wedge at the back of his cut it will tilt the tree forward 6'. Note that at this point the tree has been thrust forward into a vertical position by the wedges and it will soon fall into the target area.


img

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#5

Step 4

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Over she goes. The angular accuracy target is the soda can. If they hit it they get extra points and a $50 bonus. The pre-positioned stake is the length target. They are scored by how many inches the end of the tree is SHORT of the stake after it comes to rest on the ground. If the end of the tree goes past the stake they get zero points.

One contestant dropped the tree about 2' to the side of the can, it bounced about 3' into the air and landed square on the can. It counted as it is scored by where the tree comes to rest.


img

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#6

Ellis Walentine

Nice work, Bill

Ellis Walentine

>Compare this level of expertise to the poor hapless soul in that video a couple weeks ago who dropped a tree right on his house. I've never used the wedge trick. Usually, if I have to drop a tree in the opposite direction from where it's leaning, I rig up a guy rope tied to a pickup truck or pulled by a couple helpers. It's interesting to hear how the pros do it.

Thanks for the report.

Ellis

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#7

JL

Metal wedges or what?

JL

>I see that they are quite orange - but that doesn't tell me the material. I am presuming that they are metal.

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

No!

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>They are plastic. Sooner or later you bump them with your chainsaw. If they were metal...

In a pinch, I've used wood wedges, too, but anytime I cut now, I keep one or two of the plastic ones in my back pocket at the ready.

Jason

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#9

Indeed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Compensate for 4 feet of back lean and drop it on a coke can 30' from the base. 8 out of 12 contestants hit the can. Not bad. But they had a $2000 prize and a trip to the nationals riding on it.

On the top of every professional saw is a black line. This is the "gun sight". With the saw aligned with the hinge, if you get behind the saw this line will point to where the tree will fall, using the technique described.

However, a tree can be pulled, easily +/- 90 degree from orthogonal to the hinge by cutting away the hinge on one side or the other. As the tree comes down, the off center hinge will rotate the trunk in the direction to where the hinge is cut away.

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#10

Pop can accuracy *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

>The techniques that he used have been refined over the years by Sorn Erickson, Tim Ard and a few other skilled trainers. Using a plain old 45 degree pie face is ancient history. An open face notch, bore cuts, wedges and all make for extreme accuracy.

In the competitions that I've been at the score is based on where the log hits. What good is the drop if you smash the house and then it plops into the yard where you planned? Explain that to the insurance company. :)

If anyone want to learn how to fell and handle takedowns a friend of mine has just published a book that will teach you a lot.

'To Fell a Tree'

-Jeff Jepson

ISBN 978-0-9755252-9-6

The illustrations and text are excellent!


To Fell a Tree

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#11

Question

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>It looks like his back cut may be about 1" above the back of the notch. Did other cutters shoot higher, or was that about normal?

As for your remark of the 1" wedge moving the top of a 60' tree 6', I did a little quick estimation and determined that the wedge would need to be ~ 10" back from the hinge for that rule of thumb to be accurate, which looks about right for the example in your photo.

However, I would like to point out that if a tree the same height was a lot larger at the base, and had there been 20" of wood behind the hinge, it would only move the top half that amount.

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#12

Answers

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have another picture showing the "stumps" In all cases the back cut is nearly perfectly aligned with the back of the notch, that is, the top of the stump is nearly flat. There was scoring of the stump which I didn't follow because of the complexity of this scoring, but this alignment could have been included.

This style of cutting is vastly different than when I cut timber 40 years ago. We made a much deeper, smaller angle notch and the back cut was elevated above the notch. We rarely wedged anything, preferring to rotate the tree with blocking in the notch and cutting away part of the hinge.

The new styles of cutting are suppose to be safer and I am sure studies have show them to be. The local hardwood buyers insist that their contract loggers complete a 4 day class taught by the sponsors of this regional contest. Safety was addressed in almost every breath of the announcer for this contest, from whom the example wedge data came from.

Of course cutting a tree with a top is different than this pole. The top would make wedging more difficult and alter the optimum hinge thickness.

The pressure from a tree is amazing. I cut a very large beech once with a long straight trunk and an umbrella top. A puff of wind set it back upright on its stump with the saw trapped in the cut. This was a scary moment. When it finally toppled the thickness of the paint label on the bar embossed the name of the saw in the stump.

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#13

Where is You Tube when I need it??

Barry Irby

>Bill, I have read this over and over and studied the pictures. I still don't understand. What is the advantage of this style of cutting over the old method. In my mind, the old method was to cut a notch in from one side and then cut through to the notch from the other side, leaving a hinge that directed the fall. Three cuts and you were done. This method seems to require several times as many cuts, some of which appear to be made with the tip of the bar, which I thought was a No No. Is this more "accurate" in that you can aim the tree better? If you were out in the woods and did not really care about the accuracy, would you use the old method? Once the wedges are driven into the side notches why are they not int he way of other cuts?

You did not mention the distance stake again. Was the point of that to show that the logger knew where the top of the tree was and how far it would reach when it hit the ground, thus he was confident where to park his truck?

Thanks for posting this, wish I could have seen it in person.

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#14

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Flat stumps...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I think it's interesting that they were leaving the stumps flat. From the extreme logging shows I've caught lately, I noticed that the front notch would be upside-down--presumably so that the log would end up with a flat end and neither the loggers nor the mill would have to cut the notched butt off.

Jason

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#15

this is a contest.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Not cutting logs for sale....However, that said, these notches were much more shallow than what we used to cut. Oak has a lot of but swell. These notches would not have affected the log yield any. I don't see a lot of "upside down" notches in these parts, likely because of the substantial butt swell in our species.

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#16

some answers....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>"What is the advantage of this style of cutting over the old method. ".......... I don't know for sure. But, when you are cutting logs to sell it is imperative that you not pull splinters out of the center (heart) of the tree. To eliminate this possibility the logger will "saw the heart out" of the tree before it goes down, by some means or another. This technique saws the heart out with a boring cut. We used other means of cutting the heart out that would be harder to learn than this technique.

No, there is nothing wrong with an experienced person boring with the bar. In fact three parts of this competition involved precise boring. It is used in many logging situations. It is a potential kick back situation for a novice.

Is this more "accurate" in that you can aim the tree better? Again, I don't know. I have dazzled "spectators" by driving stakes with other methods. It is the hinge that controls the angle of fall and every technique leaves a hinge. With this technique it seems easier to precisely align the hinge.

If you were out in the woods and did not really care about the accuracy, would you use the old method? I don't think everyone uses this method, though they all did in this competition. You ALWAYS care about accuracy. You don't want to drop the tree on younger trees, where it will bust, whee it will lodge, on the skidder or where it is hard to get with the skidder.

Once the wedges are driven into the side notches why are they not in the way of other cuts? There is only one more cut and it is opposite from the notch and behind the wedges. The bar tip reaches in the and severs this remaining part without getting close to the wedges. You wouldn't always use wedges.

You did not mention the distance stake again. Was the point of that to show that the logger knew where the top of the tree was and how far it would reach when it hit the ground, thus he was confident where to park his truck? Yes.

The announcer told a story of a logger who did two tours in Iraq. When he came home his guard unit went to help clear storm damage. He was taking down a damaged tree and realized too late that it could reach the road where a car had turned onto. He ran to stop the car and the tree started over. It killed him in the road flagging the car. One of the steps in felling a tree is to estimate where its top will fall. I dropped one on the dozer driver one day. Fortunately the dozer had a cover but I still took a lot of flak for the mistake.

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#17

Not just a log problem.. :-)

Jim Rahbe

>

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#18

Thanks and......

Barry Irby

>I have cut a few trees in my life time, just enough to know I should leave it to the pro's. I cut one in my back yard. I told my wife to keep the kids in the house. Put a rope and winch on it to be sure it did not go toward the house. I got into it and the wind came up. Stepped away to tighten the winch. At that moment, the wind became gusty and my five year old son walked out from behind the tree and said "Hi Dad, what are you doing?" I raced down and almost tackled him getting him out of the way. I still get an adrenalin rush just thinking about it. It was a poplar about 30" at the stump.

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#19

"Extreme' logging...not accurate

Tom Dunlap

>There are several logging shows on THC and one really bad one about an arborist from Tulsa. The shows are built up like any of the other 'reality' shows for consumer drama and rating appeal.

The open faced notch is becoming more common east of the thin edge of western North American. Felling large butt trees may be easier using trad felling methods. The skill needed to work old-growth trees is fading from the woods.

when trees are smaller, second and third growth, the open face is better. Smaller saws can be used, more accuracy, less waste.

Here's a comparison...

open face=Woodcentral skill and knowledge

Traditional pie face=nailing furniture together

Jepson's book does a great job of explaining the modern methods.

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#20

A thought on the so called reallity shows

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>I have a friend who is a fisherman in Alaska. His claim is that the Fisherman shown on TV, may not be the best in the fleet. Lets face it, the really good guys don't have as many problems as the guys on TV. No problems no Drama, No Drama no show. I expect that extreme logging an others of that ilk are the same.

glc

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#21

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Extreme logging dramas

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I've seen a few, and while there may be a little manufactured drama, much of it comes from three things: one, competition between loggers (number of loads to the mill in a week or two), two, the foibles of greenhorns (new guys), and three, equipment breakdowns/bad weather that cause delays and deadlines to become harder to meet.

To me, the helicopter logging has to be the most intriguing--the top pilots are doing 90-second "turns"--a round trip from the mountain carrying about 2 tons of logs, dump them in a yard or lake, then back up for another load. Eight-plus hours of that has got to be stressful and tedious. Although, my father just told me about the other end of the cable--he was a combat engineer in Vietnam, and he used to have to hook riverboats up to a hovering helicopter. He said the rotor wash was rough, plus you had to get well clear of the load before the helicopter started to lift it.

Jason

Re: Precision Tree Felling-step 1

#22

Chopper pilots

Gary Camp Bend, Oregon

>The guys that fly steel are the ones that really impress. Placing up to 20 chairlift towers, on the bolts. Then coming back and flying the cross arms in and holding them in place while we bolted them on. All in one morning. That is precision flying

glc