Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

Posts

Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#1

Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

Mark Valsi from Pasadena CA------WebKitFormBoundar

>last night I watched a PBS show on Sam. It was very interesting and enjoyable.

But I got to wondering . . . . most of us thought Sam was THE number one woodworker in the States/World (take your pick), and now, who will we look up to in the same manner?

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#2

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

mike from american sycamore

>Of all the instructors and woodworkers I know IMHO the best set of hands belong to Randall O'Donnell Nashville IN.

The Gentleman of woodworking would have to go to Frank Klausz.

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#3

No One Can Be #1

Dave's Not Here

>There are just way too many talented woodworkers out there for anyone to hold the title of #1. I suppose the media/marketing people will bring someone to prominence but quite honestly exposure doesn't necessarily equate to "king of the hill".

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#4

Somewhat Academic Now

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>That is an interesting question but perhaps a little bit academic at this point. The "greats" of woodworking are (or were) pioneers of design and craftsmanship. They were the craftsman who challenged the concept of mainstream decor and design and showed the world how to see furniture and turning as an art form.

Now that they have paved the way there are fewer uncharted waters for woodwork. Not to say that there isn't room for innovation, there certainly is. But now that a lot of the pioneering has been done the "stars" will be the many folks who advance their work through great design and craftsmanship. They may not not be known as well nationally but will be stars in their own markets.

Tom

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#5

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

Thomas S Stockton

>It's not like furnituremakers go on a TV show and find out the secret material is bubinga and then compete to be the greatest in the land. Their really is no #1, the truth is that furnituremakers really don't care. They might discuss what they like and dislike about someone's work and sling a little trash every so often that's just human nature. I personally can think of a dozen people that influenced me heavily when I first started out. Some were teachers, some were from books or articles and some that influenced me the most were furnituremakers who gave me a couple of hours of their time to just discuss the craft and business. Most in the last category are not well known on are national level but I'm really grateful for meeting and helping me along.

Tom

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#6

Concur, for another reason, too

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>There are too many different ways to make wood into a good design, and too many good ideas out there for there to be a #1 - there is no single answer to a question.

One of my idols has been Judy Kensley McKie, for instance, because of her creativity in the use of animal references in her furniture.

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#7

Ellis Walentine

Celebrity vs. ???

Ellis Walentine

>Skill? Innate ability? Knowledge? Design sensibility? Engineering ability? Influence and reach? Visibility? I'd say that all these and more are components of a person's stature in the world of woodworking. I suspect it's impossible to compare different craftsmen along all these lines in any meaningful way. How, for example, could you structure a competition and pick a clear winner? Everyone is somewhere on each of these continuua, and where they are isn't necessarily better or worse, right or wrong. It's all pretty subjective, really.

Celebrity is a cultural phenomenon that doesn't necessarily correlate with ability or results. Sam Maloof came up with an iconic design that propelled him to great recognition, but there are no doubt many other designers and craftsmen who are more skilled -- or at least differently skilled -- in many areas who may never achieve this level of visibility, whether because of marketing or luck or circumstance. I think each of them/us should be judged as individuals by others.

Ellis

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#8

Re: Celebrity vs. ???

Fred Davis

>The number one Woodworker for me has always been and will be always , Eugene Carlile, my wood shop instructor and teacher in Abilene's Highschool Industrial Arts course.

It wasn't just his skill in furniture making and refinishing that he did , but his ability to Teach that craft and make those of us kids that were really interested want to know more.

He wasn't a national name or nor did he have work in Galleries, but he did have hundreds of former students that have excelled in some form of woodcraft or another.

His reputation was really validated as a Teacher who was the one of all of the teachers of that time who was repeatedly invited to Class reunions for years and years , until about one year before he died at the age of ninety one.

A great guy who is still talked about in the Abilene area.

FredD

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#9

not my number one

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There are loads of people making period reproductions that are vastly more talented, if talent is measured by difficulty of execution. Its not that damn hard to make a chair after you have made a few compared to the skill necessary to do a reproduction of any of the classic pieces which involve complex design, complex joinery and carving. Just consider the number of people doing look alike chairs. Heck, amateurs do them in classes. Perhaps Sam was the most popular recent woodworker, I don't know. But even in that category I would put Krenov nearer the top. He did invent the design, but Krenov and others have invented unique and novel designs. In terms of influence I would still put Krenov nearer the top. In terms of output I would put the person whose name I can't spell ( begins with N and makes artsy natural edged stuff I don't like, in PA I think) way nearer the top.

Most modern furniture is much like my view of modern art. I could do the execution, as it is not that difficult. Only the original design or idea is worthy of admiration. The N guy's stuff in some cases looks like a shop class project. Not so with classic furniture or art. The technique required is simply not accessible to mortals and hence I have grater admiration of their work.

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#10

Re: not my number one

Art Liebeskind

>The "N" guy is George Nakashima. If you have ever seen his work up close you would not think of it as "school shop" output. His understanding ofwood was maybe the greatest of all.

Art Liebeskind

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#11

Not doubt it'd be

North of the Border

>Norm ... if the criterion was on how much a person popularized the hobby of woodworking. If it is something else, it might be somebody else,too. Sam was a great woodworker but I suspect as many people don't think he was #1 as there are who think he was, because it all depends on what criteria we use.

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#12

Nakashima

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Bill,

I think your comments are very interesting. They remind us that studio furniture is an art form. And like any art, each person who sees it will either like it or not. To one person a piece of art might be ugly and to the next person the same piece will be a master piece. With studio furniture, like art, beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

I am a great admirer of Nakashima's work. I have read his book "The Soul of a Tree" and loved it. I not only love his aesthetic but his woodworking philosophy.

This is one thing I love about art. It is highly personal. There is no right or wrong. It either speaks to us or it doesn't.

Tom

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#13

Chicken or Egg Thing *LINK*

charlie belden

>It's interesting that Sam Maloof is credited with the California Round Over style. But a somewhat reclusive Art Espenet Carpenter, of Bolinas (Northern California) also came up with rounded corners on parts - not for aesthetic reasons - but for quite practical reasons - square corners a) aren't Hands Friendly and b) get dinged easily and eventually rounded with years of use and wear. Like Maloof, Carpenter's designs were functional - if it isn't comfortable to use . . . and different from anything that had gone before.

I think Sam Maloof's gregarious, outgoing personality is what propelled him to prominence in the woodworking and collector community (if taking 20 years to get there can be called "propelled"). He was wonderful at promoting this new style of furniture whereas Carpenter was more reclusive and abrassive.

Both men left their mark on furniture making and influenced many who will pass on their influence to the next generation.

As for who will be next to come to prominence - I'd keep an eye on David Marks.


Jeff Greef on Carpenter

Re: Sam Maloof. Who will be the next Number one?

#14

Re: Chicken or Egg Thing

Thomas S Stockton

>I wouldn't necessarily classify Art Carpenter as abrasive, I would say direct and doesn't mince words would be better. When I was accepted into the Baulines Crafts Guild apprenticeship program Art was one of the people I talked to ,Spent an amazing afternoon at his place and found him very open and encouraging. I ended up not apprenticing with him but consider his no BS style of work extremely refreshing. I also got to make him margaritas at a party a couple of years later which was fun

Tom