Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

new saw - electrical connection question

Posts

new saw - electrical connection question

#1

new saw - electrical connection question

Rob Ring

>I�ll preface my question by acknowledging my electrical ignorance, so I apologize if I�m asking a stupid question. That said, I appreciate any guidance any electrical gurus could offer.

I just bought a used circa-1987 PM66 tablesaw with a 2Hp motor wired for 230v / 15amps. The plug is a NEMA 6-15. My 230v outlet is on a 20amp circuit and has a 6-20 receptacle. The plug will fit in the receptacle, and I know (or I think I know) that a 15amp motor will operate on a 20amp circuit, but I�m not sure if the different amp ratings is problematic. Some of the info I�ve found online suggests that there is potential hazard in doing this � basically I could overload the lower amperage motor without tripping the higher amperage breaker, potentially damaging the motor or causing a fire hazard. Is this a potential problem? Should I have a 230v / 15amp circuit installed, or can I use the 230v / 20amp circuit for the new saw?

Thanks!

Rob

Re: new saw - electrical connection question

#2

Easy.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Plug it in and saw away. The amperage ratings represent the maximum amperage the circuit can handle. Amps aren't "pushed" into lower rated appliances, amps are "drawn" by the appliance—as many as necessary.

Think of it this way—have you ever worried about plugging your clock radio, drawing 750 milliamps, into a 15, or, quelle horror, 20 amp circuit? It's exactly the same thing.

The description of a plug/receptacle as 15 or 20 (or other) amp, does not describe their current carrying capacity—it describes their physical construction and they are designed to prevent plugging a device into a circuit which is not capable of supplying the needed amps. It's more to prevent plugging a 50 amp welder into a 15 amp circuit. 15 and 20 amp plug polarization represent a permitted exception in the NEC—devices corded for 15 amp receptacles may be used on 20 amp circuits. Many (but not all) 20 amp receptacles have dual polarization to accommodate 15 amp polarized plugs. Also, you'll notice, for example, that it's not possible to plug a (properly corded) 20 amp device into a (properly receptacled) 15 amp circuit.

Ignore anything you read on the internet…uh, wait a minute…

Rod
Addy Protocol: experienced amateur electrician

Re: new saw - electrical connection question

#3

One more thing

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>That is usually mentioned at this point, Circut breakers are meant to protect your house wiring, not to protect the electrical load.

Addy protocol

Not an electromagician (electritian)but a building maintenance guy

Re: new saw - electrical connection question

#4

One more thing added

del schisler

>circut breakers are ment to trip when they draw more then the amprage of the breaker Their for saving the wire from melting and causing fire If your saw is 220v and max draw or run amprage is less than 15 amp and you have a 20 amp breaker You will be ok If the motor we say developed a short or you put the saw into a load more than the 20amp breaker It would trip Nothing to worry about You have more of a leaway of triping the breaker If a 15amp breaker were in their Probly a heavey sawing or pushing it hard it could trip faster than if the 20amp were in their Make sure the wire is rated for this

Re: new saw - electrical connection question

#5

Although

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>they can also provide some protection to the machine if properly matched - a machine normally drawing 10 amps plugged into a 100 amp breaker with wiring appropriately sized to the breaker could fry pretty effectively before the breaker tripped.

But - so as not to freak Rob Ring - this really only applies to extreme mismatches. 20 amps is a standard circuit amperage in 110 or 220/230 volt settings, and lots of machines at lower amperage run happily on those circuits.

Re: new saw - electrical connection question

#6

Re: Although

Bill Howatt

>I agree that putting the breaker closer to the size of the motor would offer better protection if the motor didn't have any overloads built into it or its starter but that really isn't the way it is intended to be done. I believe if you look at the rules for a dedicated motor circuit the breaker can actually be much larger than you would normally specify for the wire size. The intent is to better handle starting surges and momentary overloads but don't do this without fulling understanding the rules and it is not necessary for normal shop tools.

If a motor develops a dead short it will pop a 15A or 20A breaker in about the same amount of milliseconds. If the motor is overloaded then the 15A will open faster. This is where a bit of common sense comes into play. The only reason a tool motor will likely be overloaded is because you are causing it to be overloaded by excessive feed rate or some other operator error. Remember, that our tools all run with attended operation - they aren't stuck up in the corner of a dark attic running by themselves.

Bill

Re: new saw - electrical connection question

#7

Re: new saw - electrical connection question

Rob Ring

>very helpful - thanks, guys.

Rob

Re: new saw - electrical connection question

#8

Your good

Jay Lombardo

>plug it in and go!

Jay (Electrician)