Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

CAP & TRADE-OT

Posts

CAP & TRADE-OT

#1

CAP & TRADE-OT

Carl Barton

>A few posts back someone mentioned about getting a new water tank. I mentioned that any energy effencient item you can get now might be the best way to go because the House just past the CAP & Trade bill and at the last minute they added a 1200 page amendment which will effect every home owner in the country if it becomes law. This will require anyone selling the home to meet the guidlines of the EPA for a "GREEN" home. Amoung the items would be a solor reflective roof,energy effecient windows, a/c, 3 min shower heads, clean air testing in the home and a number of other items. If you meet the requirments the EPA will give you a certificate that allows you to sell your home, if you do not then you can not sell your home until you meet the requirments.

There are still a number of items to be worked out with this section of the bill and of course the wording is very interpitive, but still it does mention residential homes, goverment buildings and new homes. It does not appear to have any "gradfather" clause in the bill.

If you are intrested to read more you call do a search for this section of the bill under: Retrofit for Energy and Envionmental Performance (REEP).

I do not see how a goverment can impose this sort of thing on a country, but one never knows.

Carl

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#2

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Carl,

Have you read the entire measure? Are your sure that the requirements you mention are not just applicable only if the home is to be "advertised and sold" as a "green" home? If you have a link to the provisions, please post it. I note from a beginning Google search that there is a lot of interpretive rhetoric being thrown around.

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#3

Here It Is

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Carl,

I think you've either misunderstood or have been mislead regarding the proposed program. The provisions you're referring to [see the link] have to do with the Federal "green buildings" programs, NOT every home in the country that's for sale. If you want to sell your house under the H.U.D. Program, it will have to meet certain standards for energy efficiency, just as houses that are sold under HUD mortgage programs have had to meet structural and condition standards for decades.

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#4

Re: Here's The Retrofit Provision

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You will see that there is no prohibition on selling your home. Somebody's pulling your chain, Carl.

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#5

Links????

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I'll try again.

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#7

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

IEW

>I heard Stewart Varney on Fox Financial read Section 202 and it said that you will have to meet the EPA requirements. This will make selling a house thats already hard to sell impossible. What are they thinking????

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#8

H.U.D. Green Buildings Program  *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>


HUD Section

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#9

Cost of Audit?

IEW

>Wonder what this little gem is gonna cost? Insanity Rules!!!!!

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#10

Read it yourself

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>at the links above. Fox News, eh?

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#11

$200 (in the statute)

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Want to sell you house as a certified "green" home and therefore get (you hope) thousands more for it? Spend the few hundred. Otherwise . . |;-}}

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#12

Problem with Links

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Mark - thanks for injecting a little light on some of the misinterpretations of the not-yet-passed Cap and Trade bill. However, I'm having some trouble getting your links to produce a search. Too may hits from WC'ers perhaps?

Doug

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#13

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

Marv

>Lets wait to see if the bill passes the Senate before we get too excited about it. No one in the house of representitives who passed the bill has even read the damn thing. Hopefully, someone in the senate will. I have never seen so much insanity going on in our government. I'll guess that they'll load it up with all kinds of pork before they pass it. With all the printed money they're throwing around, they should pay us to retofit our homes.

Marv

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#14

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Who ever accused them of thinking? That is why they are politicians.

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#15

MORE INFO *LINK*

Carl Barton

>I was out picking up some wood and missed allot of the posts until now.

There are a number of articles I have read on this subject, but none of them mentioned anything to do with selling a HUD home or if you want to sell your home as a "GREEN" home you had to meet the standard as set forth in the CAP and Trade bill. The only thing that is mentioned is current buildings and residential homes. The wording of the bill seems to be very vague to me and when the goverment does this it always will be open to interpitation.

There are MANY articles on this portion of the bill, just do a search for "Retrofit for Energy and Environmental Performance" and you can read all sides.

Here is just one article I read on the subject.

Carl


http://Freedomeden.blog.com/2009/07/cap-and-trade-retrofit-for-energy-and.html

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#16

Re: MORE INFO

Carl Barton

>Not sure why this site gets you to the article, but I know it is correct.

Carl

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#17

Re: MORE INFO *LINK*

john T

>I just read through the actual bill, and though I'm no lawyer, I don't see any verbage that prevents you from selling your home or other property. It appears they're trying to develop guidelines for measuring the relative energy efficiency of each building. So, it looks like if you're building new, or doing additional construction, or, yes, selling your home, you will need to have an inspection done, which will generate a designation of how energy-efficient your home (or new construction/addition) is. Nothing to keep you from selling it, if it leaks heat like a sieve, or is made of solid asbestos. You just won't have a very good grade on your inspection.

Looks more like a boon to home inspectors and energy audit companies than any sort of restriction on joe homeowner.

By my reading, the relevant section is H.R. 2454, Section 204.h.3.

-John-


http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/F?c111:3:./temp/~c111ye1I5P:e433679:

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#18

link isn't working

john T

>but search on H.R. 2454, and you should get there.

Cheers.

-John-

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#19

Links - Alternative Directions *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I thought I was linking to the Library of Congress 'Thomas" pages for the actual provisions. Appears it's just to a search engine page.

Thus try to click on the link below, then click on the page link to

"H.R.2454.EH" That should take you to the version of the bill that passed. You can then scroll down to Section 202 for the Retrofit portion of the proposed law and further down the list to Subsection H for the Energy Efficient Neighborhood provisions under the H.U.D. portion in Section 281 onwards.

Hope this helps


THOMAS

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#20

You're absolutely right, John

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>There is no such BS in the actual bill.

All this is hoopla is a prime example of what happens when people take some biased comments by ["Right" or "Left"] advocates and run with them at THE TRUTH without exercising their personal freedom and ability to go to the source, in this case the actual bill's language, read it for themselves, and then gauge not only the law but also the BS artists pounding the table. The actual text of 2454 makes these people distortionists at best and liars at worst.

You don't have to be a lawyer to do this. There's absolutely no Latin and very few Big Words in the sections of 2454 being discussed.

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#21

Re: You're absolutely right, John

Carl Barton

>John,

You are correct, HR 2454 does not really cover the subject well, but HR 1778 as presented by Representive Peter Welch, and attached to HR 2454 in the wee hours before HR 2454 was past, does cover the subject I was talkining about. From what I have read (many articles on both sides).

Granted when I looked at the site that was attched in the above posts it did not mention or go into detail to the subject I was takling about. But if you google or do a yahoo search for "Retrofit for Energy and Enviromental Performance" you can read allot more on the subject from both sides.

Granted some are taking this subject to extreames and others are not, but the wording I have read in the articles leaves allot of interpataion. And after 33 years in the Navy when ever someone never gave me details on how somethings was to work or what needed to be done, I always looked at the worst case in my mind. I always try to get every thing I can to read on a subject before I make up my mind. My entent was to put out what I had heard and read so far on the subject. Since I am a bit isolated after my retirment ( no adult converstation) I thought I would see what others thought about the subject since in my mind it seems the goverment is trying to pull a fast one.

Anyway that is my thoughts, not trying to get anyone upset or cause hate and discontent with others. What is that old saying? Never talk politics and religion? :)

Carl

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#22

1778

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Carl,

I just read through 1778 by Mr. Welsch, and while it does lay out a multi-Billion dollar program of retrofit incentives along with accounting provisions and limitations, it doesn't prohibit, or place any conditions on, any homeowner from selling their home. Man, it's just not there. What is there, (IMHO correctly so) is the setting up on verification procedures so that if John or I take advantage of the incentives, we'd better make sure that we're putting the money where we say we are, and we are therefore subject to being audited on the results. If I don't want the Federales poking around my attic or putting cameras down my toilets, I simply don't ask for some of the money in the first place. If I'm not prepared to prove what I say to a prospective home buyer about my alleged energy upgrades, I should just shut up about it.

You are quite right to be concerned about these things, but I think you need to rely less on what somebody says about the provisions and more about what the bill actually says. There are way too many crackpots and ax-grinders pumping huge amounts of misleading and alarmist statements and rants out on the Internet these days. It's their right to speak, off course, but that doesn't mean they have to be taken at their word; especially when its so easy to debunk them with a few clicks and a few minutes reading.

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#23

Re: 1778

Carl Barton

>Mark,

You are correct, there is allot read into this bill by others, I guess even by me. But I can not help but think, if this sort of thing becomes a law then while it does not come out and say "You will do this in order to sell your house" it does not say that the goverment can not tell you this either. It just seems to be way too much lead way for the government to say you "will do this". I just do not like the way it is written. Of course it still has to get to the Senate and passed by them.

I heard about this from someone else and then on the radio. So I started searching to see what it said. Just like allot of other bills, there is allot of room for interpitation.

Carl

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#24

Laws

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Carl, we can all easily "read in" stuff in a law that's not actually there, especially when we distrust the lawmakers and the "what-if's" happen to strike one of our pet peeves. Demagoguery thrives in an atmosphere of mistrust and misinformation.

The words of Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. on how to understand what a particular law is about still ring true today. He said, simply, "Just tell me what the statute SAYS, not what you think Congress meant." What this energy bill does say is pretty complex and, I don't doubt, is largely over the heads of some on both sides of the "isle" who voted for or against it. Lets watch it as it proceeds in the Senate. You can be sure that there will be some changes made, but I'm fairly confident that Congress is not nearly stupid enough to try to interfere with your ability to sell your house simply based on your water heater choice.

Happy 4th

Re: CAP & TRADE-OT

#25

Congress

John t

>Mark - I agree - there's any number of ways to read things into the law, as its written, but nothing that directly prohibits transfer of property. Just alot of cash being thrown at a perceived problem. Plenty to get angry about there, but not as far as selling your property.

As for Congress, well...


img