Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Posts

OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#1

OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Tony - Memphis

>Sorry for the OT. I try not to, but you are a helpful bunch beyond the WW wisdom and I appreciate that. Anyhow, our water heater is approaching EOL. It was installed in '98. So far, so good, but...

I have been interested in the tankless. I think I have enough HG capacity and a large enough water line already. Teh water heater is next to the furnace in the attic. The gas line is huge. Not sure how big "huge" is, but it supplies the furnace and the water heater. If it is not big enough, then we'll just have to go conventional. Our gas line is 60' +. The meter is on the other side of the house.

Its just my wife and I. So, our demands are not much. We currently use a 50 gallon tank, which is crazy for two people. I'm sure we waste a lot of gas.

I know there have been postings on the subject, so I was wondering what kind of experiences folks have had so far with them? I realize the ROI would be long, but I'm not so concerned about that. I don't mind spending some extra money to save resource. Its not all about money to me.

Thanks,

Tony

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#2

Possiable New GOV. REG?

Carl Barton

>We do not have one of these tanks but in our next home we buy we want to get one. One of the good things I have heard is that you never have to wait on hot water and there is the energy savings which is always a good thing. The cost is what cause most folks to not go this route.

One of the other things to consider is if you are going to sell your home in the future. If the "CAP & Trade" bill is past by the Senate and comes to be law if you have this water heater you will be on your way to meet the new EPA laws that will be in effect for selling your home.

The House added a small provision to this bill saying you can not sell your home until it is certified by the EPA to be "GREEN". Which includes energy effecient water heater, A/C, windows, heat and a solar reflective roof. There are a number of other items included that you must meet and you can not sell your home until you meet all of them and they give you a certificate. All of these new requirments will be regulated by the state you live in and of course the goverment will not be giving the state any money to administer this program. MMMMMMM I think a new state tax will be coming our way if this passes.

My two cents worth

Carl

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#3

Re: Possiable New GOV. REG?

Alex Grigoriev

>"The House added a small provision to this bill saying you can not sell your home until it is certified by the EPA to be "GREEN"."

Are you sure? I think it only applies to new construction.

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#4

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Alex Grigoriev

>The tankless heater requires regular treating of hard water deposits. It also requires certain minimum flow to turn on. And it requires stainless steel exaust vent.

My tank heater works since 1982 or so. 40 gallons for a family of 4. My montly gas bill is about $30 (with gas range and gas furnace in the winter).

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#5

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Barry Irby

>Tony, There have been a number of posts here about tankless heaters. I gathered that some people had trouble getting them setup right and there were some issues with supply. The heater must be powerful enough to heat water at the maximum demand.

My understanding is that Consumer Reports recently stated that the payback on one of these is over 20 years. Might want to check that out.

The problem is that the unit needs to heat the water almost instantaneously. That means the flue losses are much greater than with a conventional tank unit. So, you waste gas while actually heating the water, but make up for it by not having standby losses.

It is going to be hard to beat a well insulated tank unit. You could put an insulation blanket on it and increase the efficiency even more. Just be careful to keep the jacket away from the burner and the flue/vent. Insulate the heck out of the pipes also.

I would not try to out guess Congress on the new law. If your tank is not leaking, wait and see.

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#6

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Joe Pack

>I checked this out a couple of years ago and found that the payback period was unreasonably high, even higher when the extra cost of retrofitting gas/water lines was included. I love the idea of going tankless, but, until either the cost of the tankless system goes down or the price of gas goes way up, I don't see the economy in going tankless as a replacement system.

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#7

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Nat Robison

>I like the idea of tankless and considered it when I remodeled my basement a few years ago but I too found the recovery of investment to be a long, long time. I replaced the hot water tank and I only spend about $25-30 on my gas bill in the summer. It's hard to imagine a tankless heater cutting that bill in half.

I believe that a 1" supply line is necessary for a tankless unit. They may use less gas overall but use a lot when they're firing.

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#8

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

woodenleg

>In my neck of the woods (NE Oregon), the people I know who have installed those tanks have pulled them out in 10 yrs because of mineral deposit problems. There is a auto parts house that has an eletric one but no problems go figure. Dave

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#9

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Pete in Holland, MI

>Up front cost is high. Heater + special sealed SS exhaust ads a lot of cost to make hot water.

We are staying with the old tank type for now. Yes, you keep your water heated all the time (and your house all winter too, for that matter!), but once heated, provided the water heater is in a warm draft-less location (basement) and not a non-heated garage, it'll hold water temperature for a long time with minimal heat input.

Suggest getting no more than a 40 gallon tank, use water mizer heads in your shower, and set the temperature so you can just barely keep you hands in the flow of pure hot water. The hotter you keep the water, the more energy it takes to maintain it.

We raised 3 boys with a single shower and water mizer shower head. Never ran out of hot water on a Sunday morning (getting ready for church).

Pete

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#10

Re: Possiable New GOV. REG?

Carl Barton

>I did not see anything that mentioned new construction with the provision. Everything I have read and heard lead me to beleive it was all homes.

Carl

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#11

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Barry Irby

>Pete's right. Keep the tank small 40 or maybe even thirty gallons. As I mentioned above, insulate the sides extremely well. Insulate the pipes. Newer tanks will have flow limiters in the pipes. These are designed to prevent thermal-syphoning into the lines. Still not a bad idea to insulate both pipes.

Adjust the temp down until the dishwasher just removes the grease. Turn it down until the DW fails to remove the grease and then back up until it just barely does. Or, if you have a DW with a preheat cycle in it, you can turn the temp down even further.

Then use flow restricter shower heads. there are three or four ways heat is "lost". You use the water. It radiates out of the tank. It circulates out into the pipes and cools down. and It goes up the flue. Tankless heaters have small tank losses. Not none, but some. The machine cools down every time you stop using water and must reheat itself when you use more. Insulating the tank and pipes on the old style heater adrew tank and thermosyphon loses. The flow restricters help with pipe losses. Taking quick showers and using flow restricter shower heads will cut usage.

Someone mentioned not having the heater in the garage. The problem with having it inside a heated or conditioned space is that when it burns (either type) it is sucking up air you have paid to heat with your furnace and burning it for combustion air. And, in summer, you pay to air condition any heat that escapes out of you house. It is probably better to have it in a temperate but unconditioned space such as a garage and insulate it well. Some tankless heaters are now mounted on exterior walls, out side the house. Don't know what they do to protect them from freezing during a power failure.

You might save a thousand dollars by simply replacing the one you have with a similar but smaller heater. Consider suing the savings to improve the energy efficiency of the house. Attic insulation upgrade, weather stripping, caulking and pipe insulation come to mind.

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#12

One great reason for a tankless water heater

wilbur

>When we bought our 60 year old house, we thought that we didn't have much to worry about because we were told that the husband worked at one of the borgs, and that the sellers had put a lot of effort into refurbishing and upgrading the house. Among the new amenities was a Jacuzzi that they put into the bathroom.

I found out a limitation to the Jacuzzi the first time I used it. My guess is that since they got a work discount, they went for the biggest Jacuzzi they could fit in the bathroom.

In a nutshell: 80 gallon bathtub. 40 gallon water heater. :@)

When our water heater goes, we are seriously considering a tankless water heater.

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#13

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

R. Gryder

>Tony,

The one family that I know that have installed a tankless heater is somewhat dissatisfied with it. It takes too long to get hot water even though the unit is near the outlet. It doesn't keep up if there two points of use. I don't know how cost compare because they went from an electric heater to gas. R.

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#14

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

R Payne

>I see a lot of post talking down the tankless systems. I like ours. Some 4 years or so ago our tanked heater went out. It was a propane with a standing pilot light. We replaced it with a propane tankless. No retrofitting was required, the lines and exhaust that worked for the tanked heater worked for the tankless. At that time we also had a propane furnace and it was November. Normally we would have filled the propane tank in late January or February, we didn't have to fill up until May if memory serves. The water heater was the only thing that changed. Based on the price of propane at that time and estimating the propane savinge, I calculated it would take 4 years to recover the costs beyond putting a tanked unit back in and in 10-12 years we would save the entire cost of the unit. The one we got can supply 2 major uses at the same time (i.e. 2 showers or 1 shower and a dishwasher etc). It also has a 7 year warrenty on everything and 15 year on some components if memory serves correctly. We bought a Bosch.

The up sides in addition to the cost savings include never running out of hot water, being "green", it takes up much less space.

The biggest down sides are it does take a bit longer to get hot water to the outlet, some low flow shower heads may restrict flow rate enough the sensor in the heater doesn't turn it on (but a trickle of water in the bathroom sink fixes that), both of these may result in a bit more water usage (and if you like long showers and would run a tank out you may use a lot more since you don't run out of hot water).

So far as the electric models, my brother replaced a tanked unit with a tankless one a year or so ago. At the same time he put in a programmable thermostat and ceiling fan in the living room (he is all electric). He has had no problems with flow rate and has reported a drop in his electric bill of $25-30 a month. Certainly not all of that is from the tankless heater, but if $10 a month is then at $120 a year, the additional upfront cost of a tankless which around here is $4-600 is recovered in about 5 years and 5 to 7 years beyond that recovers the total cost.

Do your research and make sure you are using current numbers, you may be surprised at the savings you'll get switching.

ron

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#15

Re: Possiable New GOV. REG?

Kirk (KC) Constable

>I think that'd be just near impossible, and would require HUGE expenditures on every house built more than maybe 10 years ago.

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#16

Two more great reasons for one. (long)

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>My college kid that likes to take long showers and when we have company. No one has to endure running out of hot water. Ours is the one that can support two showers and a water faucet, so they say. We've only tested it at two showers at the same time. It was the $1100.00 unit from HD, but I got it new, in the box, from two guys, via Craigslist for $675.00. It was a sealed box, transaction in a public place, cash in my pocket, and I ask if the straping can be cut to open the box. Sure, one guy pulls out a large knife and....cuts the straps. I worked on getting my eyes back in my sockets and my heart started again.

So far, knock on wood, the unit has worked real well for about 2 1/2 years. I will say that it was a pain in the neck to plumb in due to the large dia. gas line needed and the discovery of a hidden junction box right smack dab where I was going to cut the vent hole. That led to some wiring rerouting and some extra down time.

I had to use the horizontal vent kit as my venting for our regular water heater was too small to handle the required venting capacity. Spring for the very pricey vent kit as it is all stainless steel and all of the parts fit with no problems or work arounds.

Oh, if you can, rent one of those small portable electric threading units as it makes the installation way easier. I first tried getting cut to size and threaded pieces from the hardware store and I had three cases where the store employee did a bad job of threading the pipes and one precut piece with a scored thread that I didn't catch. All of these resulted in leaks. Lucky for me the hardware store was nearby, but it was a hassle having to go back. Renting the little threading unit helped a lot.

AND....if it's 2:00am, you've promised SWMBO it will be done by the time she needs it, you've finished installing with the water and gas back on, and nothing.... Along with a sinking feeling of "were those really factory sealed straps?" Check the cover interlock lever. It may be out of adjustment enough to keep the unit from turning on. DAMHIKT

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#17

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Jim Dillon

>Tony,

Can't comment on tankless water heaters (but sure liked that instant hot water when I was in Europe), but if you do decide to stay with a regular water heater, I suggest a 30 gallon size, given your usage. We scaled back 12 years ago and the smaller size (electric) has been fine. The only time we run low is when we do a wash, and two showers back-to-back. But the recovery time is quite good. We got a GE from the local Borg and did the new install ourselves. The only problem has been a faulty pressure/temp valve that I replaced for $14.00. Good luck whatever you do.

Jim

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#18

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I personally do not believe the tankless units are cost effective nor are any more energy efficient in most cases. IMHO the only way they are effective in saving energy is when units are installed at the point of use - this means in most homes it would require a separate unit located in the kitchen area and at each bathroom. I think you will find that if you purchase a high efficiency water heater (direct vent with no standby pilot and extra blanket insulation around the tank) and insulate ALL hot water lines throughout the house you may actually use less fuel (and water) than with a single tankless unit. As Barry stated the actual efficiency of the tankless unit is not great as the burners are so large the heat transfer is not as good as a lower btu tank style unit. The major inefficiency in hot water use (with a well insulated tank or tankless unit) is from the heat loss of the piping. When you have to wait for hot water when you turn the tap on, you know the hot water in the pipes has cooled off and you have lost the BTU's required to heat the water. You also increase water usage while the cold water runs down the drain.

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#19

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Jay Lombardo

>I also see a lot of negative comments from people who do not have them. We have had a tankless for 4 years now and love it, as do almost everyone I know who actually have one. The gas line is not huge, it is 3/4". The installation is very simple and straightforward. Ours is a whole house unit that will handle 2 open points at once ( except for when she fills the Jacuzzi tub that has 3/4" supply lines that sucker takes all the hot water). When it's girls taking those showers you ain't getting to church on time. My house is on a crawl and the kitchen closet that the heater was in is not large enough for an 80 gallon unit so this was a perfect solution, plus we gained a closet because the unit is so small. And on top of all the conveniences it saves me money on the gas consumed, win-win

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#20

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Marv

>Tony,

When you are doing the math, remember to base your recovery cost on the basis of subtracting the cost of a tank type heater from the cost of a tankless type.

Marv

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#21

Re: Two more great reasons for one. (long)

Alex Grigoriev

>The guys probably bought it with a stolen CC.

These days, they buy HD gift cards and resell them below nominal.

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#22

Could not find a reference for that

Alex Grigoriev

>

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#23

REEP AMENDMENT

Carl Barton

>If you do a search for Retrofit for Energy and Environmental Performance "REEP" you will find what I have been talking about. This was a 1200 page add on to the "Cap & Trade" bill. Not all of the details are very clear, but as I read more and more I do not like what I read. This amendment was a late add on around 3am.

Carl

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

#24

Re: OT - Tankless Water Heaters

Joe Pack

>I checked this out a couple of years ago and found that the payback period was unreasonably high, even higher when the extra cost of retrofitting gas/water lines was included. I love the idea of going tankless, but, until either the cost of the tankless system goes down or the price of gas goes way up, I don't see the economy in going tankless as a replacement system.