Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

OT AC vs Dehumidifier question

Posts

OT AC vs Dehumidifier question

#1

OT AC vs Dehumidifier question

Barry Irby

>I beard a home improvement guru on the radio tell somebody that the central AC uses 30 to 40% of its energy to dehumidify the air. (I think that's about right). Then he tells the people they can save energy by buying a fifty pint dehumidifier and a "vornado" fan and running the Dehumidifier at 50% RH, letting it do the "work" of dehumidifying as the fan stirred the air. Something about a super low temp dehumidifier.

Does this make sense to anyone? Could you possibly save enough money to justify the new machine and the fan? WE are not discussing a damp[ basement here, this was for a house with a crawl space.

Re: OT AC vs Dehumidifier question

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT AC vs Dehumidifier question

Jesper, Denmark

>It sounds like a lot of bunk to me. The principle of operation of the dehumidifier is the same as the airconditioner, the only difference is that the cold dehumidified air is used to cool the refrigerant in the dehumidifier, where the aircon dumps it outside. The resulting discharge air from the DEH is actually higher than the room temperature by a few degrees.

I suppose the idea is that you accept a higher temperature at lower RH with the proposed system and still stay in the comfort zone. If you just run the aircon at a higher temperature, you would probably get the same effect with no additional energy cost.

Re: OT AC vs Dehumidifier question

#3

Start With Wrong Assumption

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Condensation in an A/C unit's refrigeration coil (the one in the furnace plenum) is the consequence of passing warm/moist air over the cold coil. Almost ALL of an A/C's energy is used to run the compressor and evaporator fan which sit in the "hot" coil outside. The balance of energy used is for the air handler (furnace fan) and the small condensate pump). The guy is pushing hokum. The A/C compressor, based on Boyle's law, removes heat from the internal air stream and the pumps it outside tothe heat exchanger. That it also operates as a dehumidifier is incidental to its function of chilling the warm/moist air stream.

A dehumidifier, being a "spot" unit, uses the same principal, but returns the warm air to the same space; needing another fan to circulate the drier air in that same space to bring moist air back to the unit. To get the same amount of reduced humidity in an entire structure, you'd need a dehumidifier and fan in most of the rooms. Then you can spend your time running around emptying the #@$!! buckets. I have two 60-pint dehumidifiers running in my basement office/shop area from April through October. While they dry the air, removing 16-20 gallons of water each day, they also warm the space beyond what I'd call the comfort zone. More simple physics here, the heat generated in the units' exhaust coils together with that from the compressors and running motors is more than the chilling effect of the condensing coils.

We also have and use central air.

Re: OT AC vs Dehumidifier question

#4

Re: OT AC vs Dehumidifier question

Tony - Memphis

>I'd have to run some numbers to get a good idea of how much energy would be used either way. I don't think the whole issue is simple enough to guess at. It is subjective too. How much humidity do you need to remove to be comfortable at a given temperature? There are some tables out there that show some typical values, but again, those are subjective. Our AC is way oversized, so we run it at a cooler temp or else our house feels muggy. I run a dehumidifier in my shop and I can't tell that it does much to raise the temp in the shop at all. It doesn't run much. It can't be free, heat in is heat in. I feel like it would cost me a lot more to run the ac low enough to remove the same amount of moisture as the dehumidifier. After all, teh dehumidifier was designed for that purpose. Another thing to consider is an inline dehumidifier. There are some available that use desacant wheels and such. Using that with your fan running now and then would probably be failry efficient. Again, you'd have to run some numbers. I'm a mechanical eng and studied HVAC in school, but I never practiced it. Next time we build, I'll probbaly hire a real life HVAC engineer to model the house and figure out what sized system it needs. I hate that they sized ours so big. I'm sure they picked the "next size up" based on their rule of thumb for tons/sq ft. Did the same thing in my shop which is why I need the dehumidifier. Its a small well insulated and tight space. The ac doesn't run much. Except for the last week! Anyway, I don't think its a simple thing to figure out. Another thing I am always wondering about is what is the best temp so set my thermostat during the day when we are at work. We want to take advantage of not being there and keeping it a little warm, but we want to be comfortable when we get home. It takes a lot of energy to cool back down. So, where is the happy medium? Its easy in the winter. The house warms up in a few minutes. Not so much in the summer. Sometimes, the unit runs for hours. Not as muggy in the house during those times though!

Tony - who decided race car parts were more fun than AC systems upon leaving school and is now trying to decide what will be more fun than shipping boxes!