Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

OK So I am done with DeWalt

Posts

OK So I am done with DeWalt

#1

OK So I am done with DeWalt

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Hi All,

Just a quick post after reading down below about cordless tool batteries and rebuilding and such.I have a DeWalt 14.4 Impact Driver and a 14.4 Drill.My original 2 batteries were sent to Batteries Plus in PA and rebuilt about 2 years ago.They are holding up well.The 2 batteries that came with the impact driver 3 years ago are shot and require a rebuild or replacement.Yesterday while at Home Depot picking up some new door slabs the Makita 18v lithium ion kit with both the cordless drill and the impact driver was marked down to $223 plus tax.Of course I had to jump on it.I had used the Makita set before and was well aware of its performance.I don't know exactly how long a lithium ion battery will last but I think in the long run I will be ahead.Just yesterday while unhanging the old door,due to the limits on the Dewalt I had to remove a charged battery from the drill just to finish with the impact driver,inefficient to say the least.

From an economic stand point a new 14.4 battery from HD was $74 ,last time I had 2 rebuilt it was about that with shipping charges for 2 batteries.I may keep the DeWalt around as a spare but with the 15 min charge on the Makita I can't see needing the DeWalt anytime soon.

Andy

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

#2

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>You Know, I have never owned a cordless drill, so I can not relate, but it just seems to me that battery operated tools are expensive to own over the long term...??

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

#3

I got the same set

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>I thought, how much am I going to use the impact driver? but Lisa wanted the set 'cause "they fit my hand best" (a girl that wants me to spend money on tools, WOW) I can't believe how much I use the impact driver compared to how little I use the drill. Everything from electric fence insulators to changing the timing chain cover gasket on the Jeep. Lisa was SO right about how much I would use the impact tool

Good choice

glc

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

#4

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

Barry Irby

>The Makita Rep standing in Home Depot told me the L-ion batteries are good for 1500 cycles compared to about 500 for the others. If so, that would be great. And why would the Makita Rep standing in Home Depot lie?

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

#5

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

Kneale Brownson..Awaiting return to CO snows

>If you never use a tool outside your shop, cordless certainly makes little sense. But if you're using your drill or whatever other tool more than 100 feet away from an outlet with any frequency, they sure come in handy.

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

#6

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Is it more expensive than a bum shoulder? There are things a cordless tool can do that none of my 19th and early 20th century wonders can accomplish easily and quickly.

My DeWalt 12v batteries are on the downside of their curve. Their owner may be, as well. But for now, the batteries from the yellow tools are all interchangeable. That helps a lot.

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

#7

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

Tony - Memphis

>That sounds like a very high number of cycles to me. My company employs tens of thousands of Li batteries. Our rule of thumb is around 400 cycles. That's a complete cycle. There are so many variables, it is very hard to put a number to it. Li cells are very temperature dependent. You can Google some info and find the curves. They don't like high temps and their capacity drops severely in cold temps. We are still getting used to using them. You can imagine with that many batteries, our replacement costs are significant.

I just had a DeWalt drill battery rebuilt. So far, so good. I've about had it with cordless anything. I have a small cordless hand trimmer (B&D) whose battery just died. I'm picking up a replacement today. Also have a cordless mustache trimmer at home that I have a replacement sub C cell to put in that I need to get to (second one). I hate batteries! Although I have been buying rechargeable AA's and AAA's for all the stuff around the house. Those seem to work well and are easy. Even seem to hold up well outside. Walgreens has had some great deals on them lately.

Tony

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

#8

'Nother thought

Neal in San Jose

>Here in earthquake country, I consider my cordless tools part of my earthquake kit. I try and keep my batteries charged up, 'cuz ya never know when the next one will knock out the power.

I was doing a repair job when one shaker dropped out the power in the neighborhood. I was able to keep going and finish the job, altho by the time the power was restored, the batteries were pretty tired.

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

#9

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>I Bought a Ridgid 14.4v set with drill and impact driver because of the "Lifetime" service agreement with free batteries for life. 4 years and 5 batteries later. I am glad I did. The thing that you have to watch for is, you have to follow the registration instructions to the the letter! Once you receive the the Registration number make sure you keep it safe--it is needed for all service The drill and the impact driver have been exellent!

bu the way, they replaced the outfeed table on my jointer when it cracked after 6 years N/C

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

#10

Glad You Reached Accord, Jim

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: OK So I am done with DeWalt

#11

Oh the irony....

Tony - Memphis

>Got THE call from my wife yesterday..."Honey, the car won't start!" Yup, the battery was dead! After this post, that's what I get! Fortunately, our security folks have a portable starter booster pack and it cranked right up and we drove it to the dealer. I was ready to go to Sears and get one and put it in, but she called the dealer who was two blocks away and they quoted $108 installed, which is what the Sears battery cost. I was a little surprised that the battery only lasted 4 years. I was expecting 5. Oh well. I did learn that you can push start a 350Z. I didn't know if there was something new that would prevent that, but the tech guy said yup, you can. Hope I never have to try!

Tony