We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Yesterday, while at Lowe's, I was looking through the tool section. I was looking at a Porter Cable impact driver, and just happened to notice it was "made in China". I thought PC was made in Tennessee. I started looking at all the PC tools. All made in China. Next, I looked at DeWalt. Most made in Mexico, some in China.
Then I got compulsive and looked at every hand tool in the place. Most made in China, some in Tiawan. Finally, I found something made in the USA...a Lincoln Stick Welder.
>i think you have answered your own question. it's a matter of staying cost competitive and moving manufacturing keeps these tool companies in business. otherwise tools would be so expensive they would not sell easily.
>I was buying a Bosch SDS drill at Lowes. Some said Made in Germany and some said China. Seemed to be what size it was determined where it was made. Apparently the Germans are doing the same thing. I bought one made in Germany. I suppose the next shipment will all be made in China.
I also think that Made In China will be like Made in Japan. When I was a kid, (1950's) Japan equated to the cheapest possible junk. Toys were often made out of beer cans turned inside out. You could still see the original label inside. Now, one on associates Japan with cheap crap. So I suspect China will follow the same path and there will be a rise in quality. I suspect they will be able to manufacture at whatever level the customer wants to pay for. On the Turning forum there has been discussion of chucks and some feel the quality of the some is equal to the quality of those made in New Zealand, but the company insisted on the quality. There are others that are cheap copies.
>Delta's new table saw and their new mini lathe are built in Tennessee. Their bandsaw used to be made in America but I haven't checked any of the new models.
Pretty much all of Powermatic and Jet are made overseas. Powermatic used to be made 30 miles from me and I was really dissappointed when my contractors saw came dropped shipped from Taiwan.
>After retiering from the ARMY I did four years shooting plastic auto parts. At first the die / mold blanks were being shipped in from China. By the time I'd had enough of the manufacturing world the finnished tools were done entierly in China to specifications and precision equal to and cheaper than US made. I know this because Dad was the tool & die maker / tooling supervisor for Woods Brothers highway mowers. Why ? Because US tooling manufacture has pretty much sat on it's laurels plus demanded higher prices. Now China offers equal or better precision at lower prices, even with the price of shipping the tooling to the US. Tooling made in China is no longer being made in a grass hut or prison. They hire outside expertise to set up their operations and are learning precision at a faster rate surpasing US companies in price and quality. Like the auto industry, US companies are priceing themselves out of a job. While I'm the kind of guy who DOES look for "Made in USA", about the only place to find it is in the Collectables / tools section of Ebay.
>Is assembled from imported components. They might do the casting in China and machine the castings here, or do all the machine work overseas too and just assemble the parts here. My air compressor is assembled in the US but the compressor unit itself is made in Italy. This is just the nature of a global economy, many Baldwin hardware products are made in China, but I've not seen the quality drop. Its less a matter of where something is made, and more a matter of the standards the manufacturer insists on.
>I grew up in a car family (my dad sold Chrysler corporation cars until he and his partner opened the East SF Bay Borgward/Goliath/Lloyd dealership in the late 1950's; he held on selling niche market imports, then used cars, for a few years after Borgward/Goliath/Lloyd went under, then worked for International Harvester until his retirement), and was fascinated by how long the automotive press made the artificial distinction between "American" and "foreign" cars, when a lot of "American" cars from the 1970s on (and maybe earlier) had many major components made in Canada, Mexico, and other countries; and a lot of the large "foreign" car companies opened factories in the U.S.
Which one is an American car: 1) a Toyota much of whose design emanates from a design center in LA and that is made in an American factory, or a 2) a Ford originally designed in Europe then modified slightly for the American market with an engine made in Canada and many body parts made in Mexico?
I agree with Steve Mackay: "Chinese made" does NOT have to equal "low quality," just as Japanese made no longer equals that. Before I inherited my uncle's Baldor bench grinder, I owned two Taiwan-made bench grinders. One cost me $29, and was worth every penny of the sales tax I paid on it - the danged thing vibrated so much that I couldn't keep a tool on the toolrest (which appeared, by the way, to have been made from tin can stock) and, unless bolted down, walked off the bench in about three seconds. The other, which said "Delta" on the front, was and is a lovely tool, on which I was able to grind without even bolting it down; once I got the Baldor, I passed it along to my son. The issue is the number of corporations, many of them with fine old American names, that are lowballing the engineering and quality control and passing the resulting cr*p off as real tools.
As a far too avid garage sale shopper, I've picked up some American made tools from the 1950s and 1960s that, similarly, should have been strangled, or recycled, at birth. I even bought, new, when I was young, dumb, and broke, an American made Rockwell (think: Porter Cable) circular saw, offered when Rockwell was first trying to penetrate the consumer (think: very occasional tool using) market, that tended to faint when it saw a 2x4.
Rant time (the preceding being "rant prologue"): A lot of the consumer-grade stuff visible in the borgs and other places now is made in China because that's where the corporations can get the best price for a low-ticket item. But I think the distinction to be made is high/low quality, not where the tool is made.
The problem for me is that there was a time when a set of brand names represented high quality; and the corporations that own many of those names have chosen to put them on low quality tools, so it's not so easy to tell by looking at a tool how good it is likely to be (though I note that I own an old Ryobi laminate trimmer, made when Ryobi was the third professional handheld power tool maker in Japan, after Makita and Hitachi, that can hold its head up in competition with any new laminate trimmer except maybe the Bosch Colt; not something I'd say of the modern Ryobi tools I've seen in the stores, because Ryobi chose to compete in a consumer rather than a professional market).
Yes, a lot of manufacturing has left American soil. I'm not clear whether that's a product of American workers having priced themselves out of competition or whether it's poor management, but that's a conversation that could get way too political for this forum.
>Some of the "import" auto makers - if I recall correctly, this is true of BMW, Honda, and Toyota, but my memory's not always accurate - are making cars in the U.S. factories for sale in their home markets, because it's cost effective to make them here and ship them over there.
>I received an email over the weekend (don't know if it is true, but it seemed plausible) that said you can tell where any item is made by looking at the bar code. Specifically, the series of numbers at the bottom of the bar code. Apparently if the first number is a "0", the item was made in the U.S. or Canada.
There was a chart that showed what other numbers represent which countries, but I don't remember those details.
This is similar to the system used in VIN numbers on vehicles. That's how you can tell if your Japanese car was made in the U.S. or Japan.
>Sad to say.....won't be long until we will look at a USA made tool and gag just as we did when we did the same with Japanese made tools.
Unions and corporate greed has already brought the manufacturing process in America to that inevitable point of no return. We will not recover from our stupidity for the same reasons that got us where we are.
The handwriting was clearly on the wall at least 30 years ago when it was declared that America was on it's way to becoming a communications producing country. I felt at the time that it was crazy and could never happen. Boy was I wrong!
Any country who cannot compete in the world of manufacturing saleable useful products will not be a world leader. Our country is on that proverbial slippery slope and losing traction as the hours go by.
>I am not so sure that the US companies have priced themselves out of their respective markets. I believe that our government and labor have set standards that have made us uncompetitive in the global economy.
Consider:
Factory wages in China average $1.26/hour. The Federally established minimum wage will be $7.25/hour effective in July 2009. A number of states have set even higher minimums. In April 2007, the average hourly rate in US manufacturing was $17.20.
There is no EPA, FDA, OSHA or any of the myriad of other regulatory agencies in China that we enjoy in the US, at least, not to the same extent. Otherwise, there would not be lead paint on toys or melamine in infant formula.
Chinese employers do not pay for their employees' health care or retirement.
I do not mean this to be political and I am certainly not bashing China, but I do think that we should be aware of the manufacturing disadvantages faced by US companies.
>The so called "Cap and Trade" is going to accelerate the demise of the USA by driving the cost of electricity so high that the factories that are left will have to shut down.
>How many people here have ever had a Borgward, Goliath, or Lloyd? I had a 1958 Lloyd Alexander station wagon for about a year and a half. 35mpg in town! I sold it because I didn't want to go through another winter scraping my breath off the inside of the windshield while driving to work. 592 cc of raw power - well 22 hp anyway.
>Too much to explain here, but that's not true. EAN-13 barcodes do list a country code in the prefix, but not UPC, which is what most products in the US currently use. And even then, its the country in which the company registered, not the country of manufacture.
>Dad held onto a 1958 wagon after he sold the lot (the new owner, in 1966, "didn't want any of those foreign cars," so we wound up with about seven cars, including two late 1950s blue VWs*). When we came back to California from some time in the Midwest, he loaned it to me, and I used it as a truck.
Dad had a Borgward sports coupe that was his pride and joy until someone tailgated him at a stoplight. Sigh. That would be mine now, if that hadn't happened. One of the prettiest cars of the 50s, in my opinion, and they were very advanced cars for the period.
*my brother and I once got into an argument over whether one had more power than the other - a VERY relative term for the VWs of that vintage - and tested the question by racing each other around the streets of Oakland, CA. He agreed after we finished, not quite killing ourselves, that I was right, and one DID have more power. Lordy, was I dumb then.
Usually it is a cop out - looking for the next quarter's results rather than planning and MANAGING an efficient production, which takes a longer term view and investment than the next report to he stock market.
As an example, Germany has higher hourly wages than the USA and a much more restrictive labor law, making it very difficult to fire people. Still they are the Worlds second largest exporter of goods - mostly high quality manufactured stuff.
>I recall fondly playing Parnelli Jones rodding around North Beach, including Lombard St, in a 1960 VW bug. Yeah, it was dumb, but I doubt I ever had a better time.
>Japan stuff was toys for us kids, usually 2 to 5 cents, some a quarter (the "good" ones). Prior to about 1938 there was no Made in Japan either. Congress got legislation forcing the Japs and all countries to mark the toys as to country or place of origin. To get around it at least one Jap toymaker apparently changed the city/location name. Their toys became "made in USA" with no periods to indicate U.S.A. Then the was started and it all became moot. I think I still have one of those toys.
>The Cap&Trade bill that I barely understand is making my eyes bleed. IF I understand it correctly, companies are allowed to pollute if they buy a license to do so. No big deal, they'll just buy the licenses and pass the extra cost onto the consumer. That would be us! That only makes them less competitive. I'm sure it can't be that simple, maybe that's the gist of it. The C&T bill they just passed was not read by any of them, it was too big. Sooo, what the hell, just get it passed so we can get back to the news of Michael Jackson and that idiot Governor of NC.
Unbelievable what's go'n on!
I'm just glad I'm retired and coming to the end of my experience here but I feel sorry for my kids and grandkids. Most of them have no idea what it's like to earn a buck and think the world owes them a living. Besides, there's always drugs and sports and drugs and twittering and drugs and Facebook and drugs and MySpace and having fun with more drugs that's more important.
>You make it sound like all of those things are bad. I've worked in China. I would not want to live there - where I've been in China is basically a polluted hell hole. The air is so thick with smoke and pollution you can't breathe and the sun barely peeks through. The riverbanks are green, blue, and orange. The workers are either a) slaves or b) underemployed, unemployed, and/or uneducated. The bosses and management are corrupt. The people are unhappy with the situation, but short of revolution (against a system that has massive power and control over their lives), they don't know what to do - they have to survive.
I'll take a bit of government regulation over that situation any day.
We have not priced ourselves out of work, China is just at the stage where they have capability and skill, but are still underpricing their work.
>your description of China sounds EXACTLY like a description of THIS country around the turn of the century on it's way to becoming the world manufacturing super-power that it once was. Of course this was before we got sensitive, responsible and careing.