Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT - Deck Replacement Advice

Posts

OT - Deck Replacement Advice

#1

Bart Goldberg

OT - Deck Replacement Advice

Bart Goldberg

>Hi All,

I am getting ready to replace my 16 year old PT lumber deck. I am considering using one of the non-wood types of decking material and am looking for any experience you may have.

1) I have been looking at the newer TREX products as well as Timbertech. My local lumber store was steering me more towards the TREX as a better buy, but I can't say they are an unbiased source of info.

2) Has anyone used the newer PVC based decking? If so, what brand did you use? How long has it bee installed and how do you like it?

2) My current deck is 16" oc, and I was concerned that composite decking material would not be properly supported with this spacing. I have heard that the earlier forms of composites would start to get pliable and feel very bouncy after a few years. Even though all the manufacturers say that 16" oc is sufficient, I have heard some folks in the past say that this was inadequate support. Note that the floor boards will be perpendicular to the joists, not on a 45 degree angle.

3) I'm not overly concerned about hiding the fasteners. I plan to use the color matched ss screws made for this type of application.

Any advice is greatly appreciated.

Thanks in Advance

Bart

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice

#2

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice

Barry Irby

>Bart, I have no personal experience with the materials, but as a home inspector I have seen a lot of it. Still can not give much advice, because most of the time I have no idea which brand I am looking at. I have seen several that failed completely, but I don't know what the brand was.

From what I see, I think 16" oc is adequate with the decking perpendicular.

And, Pay strong attention to the screws. Do some practice pieces to be sure you are satisfied. I have seen a lot of decks seriously marred by the mushroom that forms over the screws. Where the hidden fasteners were sued, the stuff looked great. Where the screws did not mushroom, it looked good, where they mushroomed, looked like crap. Just my opinion, but it would be a shame to pay big money and put forth the effort and hurt the appearance by taking a half step on the screws. There are screws they clam don't mushroom and you could predrill.

I mentioned in another post that Fine Home Building just ran and article on Deck Boards Done Right. April 09. Might be worth going to Taunton Press and checking it out. I like the idea of putting "flashing" on top of the joists. 30 Pound felt or one of the tapes available now. I will be doing that when I redeck.

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice

#3

Bart Goldberg

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice

Bart Goldberg

>Hi Barry - why the need for the flashing?

Bart

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice

#4

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice

Barry Irby

>The idea is you apply about a 3 or 4" wide strip on top of each joist. The sides droop down and cause the water to drip off, keeping the joists much dryer, reducing the rot. Even treated joists rot after a while. This is "old school" from the days before treated lumber, but it will help with both. The point it that the joists tend to get soggy under the deck boards and that encourages rot. Anything that keeps them dryer would be good. At worst, it couldn't hurt. If you use the rolls of flashing tape made of Vicor or butyl rubber, or cut strips of Ice and Water shield, it will seal round the screws or nails. Just seems obvious to me, a little "roof" over each joist.

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice

#5

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice

Bill Howatt

>You don't have to wait a few years for it to get bouncy. Composite decking has minimal stiffness when it is new, especially when it is hot. On a hot day I could put the center of a 20' 6" wide 1"+ thick Trex board on my sholder and each end would be on the ground.

Since I was startng new I build my deck with 12" centers since the extra cost is nothing compared to the whole job but Trex says 16 is OK. Very little bounce but it is there and my wife actually likes it. Funny, we all say it is better to stand on a floor that has a little give yet we want decks to be like a concrete slab.

IMO, underdeck fasteners are the way to go since it does make a nice job. One of my two decks was too close to the ground so I had to do it from above. I used SS trim-head screws which have much smaller heads than regular screws. I did let it mushroom as per the Trex instructions and then hammered it down. You don't see them unless the deck is wet and then it isn't real obcious. However, this method is best for lower-traffic areas - presumably the hammered down Trex over teh screw will wear off. I don't think I'd do this method with regular #8 decking screw heads.

Trex is solid so you can have exposed ends if you wish.

I do find that the shady deck gets mold spots on it but this is a minor issue. I just use an old garden sprayer to spray bleach on it, let it stand a couple minutes and then hose it off. Do it 2 or 3 times a year.

I believe my deck is about 5 years old now and looks like the day it was installed. No cracks, splits, loose knots, warps and apart from a couple hosings as described above, no maintenance. It cooks in the summer and gets the snow shovelled off it in the winter. If I were to build another one it would be composite and very likely Trex.

Bill

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice

#6

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice *LINK*

DizD

>I saw a new product at a local dealer several months ago. It is thermally modified wood. It's impressive looking and the dealer says it will compete favorably on price with composites from the borg. I have no connection or knowledge about performance - just thought you might be interested in an alternative.


http://www.radiancewood.com

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice

#7

Re: OT - Deck Replacement Advice

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Bart,

We did a really big deck on our cabin using the Trex, and it is holding up extremely well. Our joists were 16"oc, and it is a very firm deck. Yes, carrying a 16 foot Trex board is kind of like a wet noodle, but once you fasten it down it is pretty sturdy. We used a screw that was designed to eliminate the mushroom. It had a fairly steep thread on the bottom two-thirds of the screw, and then a less steep thread on the upper third, so that as you're driving it in the screw is being pulled down at the rate of the steep thread, and the shallower thread actually pulls the fibers that would be the "mushroom" down into the board with the screw. No pre-drilling needed. It was kind of cool to watch as you drove the screw in - the fiber would begin to mushroom up around the screw, and then when you hit that shallower thread, it would pull it all back down with the screw. Of course, after a couple thousand screws, the novelty wore off! I wish I could remember the brand name - I may still have a partial bucket at home and could look if you're interested.

I hope this helps!

Scott.