Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

About a maple countertop...

Posts

About a maple countertop...

#1

About a maple countertop...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I'm making a maple counter top for my daughter in law's baking center. 51" long, 24" deep, attached maple back splash. The rough maple is sitting on my saw table waiting for me to start.

Do I want to make a drip edge? One that keeps liquids on the counter, rather than running down the maple and cherry drawer fronts...

And if so, how? Apply a moulded edge as the last/front lamination in the glue up? After finishing the rest of the leveling process, that is. Or some other process?

Perhaps a 'gutter', routed into the surface would be better. I've got the tools to do most anything that makes sense, but I'm a bit brain locked on this one.

Thanks in advance for your suggestions.

Re: About a maple countertop...

#2

Re: About a maple countertop...

Bill White

>I would not bother with a drip edge. If used as a baking center, it will mostly be used dry (as in BISCUITS-I love biscuits).

Bill

Re: About a maple countertop...

#3

Re: About a maple countertop...

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Glenn,

Presuming the table will not be used for juicy items lke roasts, a shallow round bottomed groove would be easy to clean and effectively contain the baking ingredients. You'd need something deeper to contain meat juices. Either way, I'd personally favor a groove routed inside the perimeter of the top. To me, a drip edge belongs outside in the rain. Will you "finish" the top?

George

Re: About a maple countertop...

#4

Re: About a maple countertop...

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>For a B-A-K-I-N-G center? No. It will be nothing but a hassle for the baker. Only reason for a gutter is to catch seepage such as occurs in a "carving stand"; carving stand needs a gutter and a catch basin. A baker wants an even, flat surface, edge-to-edge, to manipulate dough (as opposed to slicing a doe . . or a buck for that matter). Your drawer and door fronts are best "protected" with a nice overhang (1" or more) and good finish like lacquer or other KCMA spec film finish.

Re: About a maple countertop...

#5

No

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You stated that this is a baking center, not a carving board. I bake, regularly. Baking does not involve spilling liquids. This surface will be cleaned by scraping with the dough scraper. A depression will accumulate stuff that can't be scraped clean. In fact I don't know how one could easily clean any sort of gutter. A perfectly flat surface works best for me. I don't know what you mean by a drip edge, but what ever it is it is unnecessary for a baking preparation surface.

Re: About a maple countertop...

#6

Re: About a maple countertop...

Glenn Madsen

>Finish will be left as natural. The cutting board in the other counter is natural, and looks used but fine after two to three years of cutting board use.

Still undecided on the juice groove...

Re: About a maple countertop...

#7

Re: About a maple countertop...

Fred Davis

>Glenn ,

a couple of things entered my thinking on your post .

Regarding a gutter or groove , I wouldn't do it, especially for a surface that will be used for rolling dough flat.

I know you want to have a hand in your daughter's baking counter , but you picked out a project that would not approach the quality and finish in a John Boos and company Rock Maple countertop.

I have installed dozens of them in Kitchens I fabricated and I would not dream of wasting my time and material trying to emulate a counter of their superior manufacture.

Your not far from Union City, toddle over there and go to J. E. Higgins Hardwood Lumber and ask to look at a John Boos counter , they would have it in stock at 61" x 25" x 1 1/2" .

Save your rough Maple for something else for her.

Just a thought or two mind you, ;-))

FredD

Re: About a maple countertop...

#8

that's presumptuous....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>but you picked out a project that would not approach the quality and finish in a John Boos and company Rock Maple counter top.

I admit I have not seen this top, but what is there in a maple top that can be better or worse? Maple is plain as dirt unless figured. As far as finish, for how I use a top it needs to be unfinished. I clean it by scraping with a dough scraper and any finish other than oil is going to scrape off into the French Bread. And one would have to have an exceptionally high priced source of maple lumber to not be able to beat the price of a commercially made top after it passes through various middle men.

Re: About a maple countertop...

#9

Re: that's presumptuous....

Fred Davis

>Um, Mate , what's the word here ?

Well since you admit you haven't seen one, much less used one , here's a few facts about John Boos and company Maple countertop material.

They are, or at least were, the only wood countertop approved by the State of California for commercial food handling.

The "finish" is not a film finish though it is shiny.

It is pulled into the wood about a 1/4" to 3/8ths deep, if you had ever cut one , you would notice this right away.

As for cost of material , Formica sounds like it would serve your needs well.

The process they use to bond the wood strips is not available to anybody in a home shop that I am aware of.

Beyond that I posted the reply to Glenn , thinking since it was for his daughter , he would perhaps consider another option.

If he thinks it was "presumptous" he is perfectly capable of saying so.

FredD

Re: About a maple countertop...

#10

Re: that's presumptuous....

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Fred, I know you only from here on WoodCentral, but we have a somewhat common background. I think it not at all presumptuous.

I'll toddle over to Union City, and see what they have, and what the toll is on the Boos block.

What I have to work with is red or silver maple, air dried and really nice, that I was going to strip laminate in 8/4 x 3" edge lams, and install. I'm $80 into the wood, and can easily use it for other things.

The Boos block would be MUCH easier, assuming the economics come close. That's an issue right now. However, so is the time involved. There are other projects needing doing, and the list stacks up...

Re: About a maple countertop...

#11

Re: A Boos block is very cool...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>We'll see how it works. What else can I spend money on? ;) It's just the grandkids.

There are thriftier ways to do it, but not necessarily better. We'll see.

Thanks for looking out for my somewhat tattered wallet.

Re: About a maple countertop...

#12

Bill, look at the bottom of a window sill

Barry Irby

>A drip edge or drip groove is the little round bottom groove in the bottom sill. It's difficult for the water to bridge across it and it drips off. It's actually quite functional and important to protecting the house from water seeping under the sill. In the case of a counter top it would work to keep liquid from running back under the edge. It could be set up to cause the drips to fall to the floor rather than run down the face of the cabinets if the over hang were wide enough.

I agree with you. A gutter or blood groove on a baking center would be a PITA. In fact it's probably a PITA to clean on any top or cutting board.

As an aside, I made a round rose arbor that was 12' in diameter. It had a huge finial that was 40" tall and 12" in diameter. I put a drip groove under the largest ring. The painter caulked it. Sloppily. I was amazed that he went to so much trouble to negate something that was so obviously done on purpose. Oh Well, I tried.

Re: About a maple countertop...

#13

Re: About a maple countertop...

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Glenn,

I mentally debated the desirability of a groove in a baking surface for the same reasons advanced by Mark and others. I felt if the surface was used inadvertantly as a carving board, a groove would be beneficial without compromising the function of the board for baking. A groove = utility.

George

Re: About a maple countertop...

#14

Lee Grindinger

Fred has a good idea

Lee Grindinger

>Unless there is an emotional reason for doing this simple project yourself I'd look into a top you simply cut to fit. These are superior tops to what most can make if you don't mind the strip look. They are thicker, better finish, and more stable than what you would probably make. Perhaps look into the price, then decide.

Lee

Re: About a maple countertop...

#15

Re: A Boos block is very cool...

Thomas S Stockton

>A word of warning when dealing with Higgins, get another price check from either a different supplier or call one of their other yards. My experiance with them is that unless you have a salesperson that knows you your chances of getting put in the full full retail catagory are extremly high. Check the manufacturers web site for a distributers list.

An example about 10 years ago a friend asked me where he should get some nice walnut plywood from my usual recamondations were Pals and Mt storm he asked about Higgins and I told him my experiances. They wanted $225 a sheet and Pals was $110 for the same product. They have a great selection but when I lived near one I would always call and check prices with a salesman who knew me.

Tom

Re: About a maple countertop...

#16

Re: A Boos block is very cool...

Fred Davis

>J.E. Higgins is a wholesale yard , not a retailer and they cater to Cabinet shops and large fixture companies and schools.

I ran a account there for twenty years and though I knew everybody , did some workd for some of them , the account was charged out wholesale.

On reccomendations from people like me , they would sell to a individual.

One case in point is when I was a instructor for the Newark, CA. USD ,adult education for a few years in the evenings , I sent the class to Higgins for material if they did'nt have their own.

Well , I heard about that , Pete the accounts manager said "a bunch of Ladies showed up and said it was ok to sell them material , according to me," they did so and asked for a heads up the next time.. ;-)))

Firms like Higgins and Dale's hardware were indepensable for Contractors and Cabinet shop owners, I wish we had them locally.

FredD

Re: About a maple countertop...

#17

actually....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>the maple tops I made for food preparation have served us well for since 1970.

Considering how easy and inexpensive they are to make I would encourage anyone needing a maple top to make one.

As far as the endorsement from the State of California, the last package of snap swivels I bought for fishing "were KNOWN by the State of California to cause cancer", so it said on the package. I have credibility issues with the State of California.

Re: About a maple countertop...

#18

I don't think you need any drip prevention...

John in NM

>or rather drip containment. Factory counters don't have any, and as many others have pointed out, baking is a largely dryish activity. In the event that some fluid does escape, the cabinet finish is there to protect the cabinets from it. Cleaning up such drips is a chore, but such is life.

I wouldn't finish the maple top, it doesn't need it. Maybe something easily renewable like tung or linseed oil for aesthetics if required. Or if you go with Fred's suggestion, then the top will come pre-finished with some sort of impregnated resin. Problem solved either way.