Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

Posts

Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#1

Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>OK, from my post below I'm interested in a jointer. From everything I've read it seems that these days going straight to the helical cutterhead is the thing to do. I haven't seen much of a negative to using them. The cut cleaner, don't need to be aligned, and I think even quieter.

But, since I can save a few hundred dollars on regular knives, are there any compelling reasons to stick with regular knives. I'd like a tool I don't need to upgrade or replace any time soon, so that's why I'm thinking helical.

Thanks,

Steve

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#2

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>Steve,

until they come out with the next "upgrade" for jointers Helical are pretty much the cutter of choice if you want a functional tool that requires very little upkeep... had mine three years and haven't dulled an edge yet, Knives are for butter, Right?

Photobucket

I have a Shelix on my jointer and planer, ....sweet

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#3

historical perspective

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>People have been successfully using straight knifed jointers since they were invented so one certainly doesn't have to have a spiral cutter head to make stuff. While working north American hardwoods I extremely rarely have any issue in getting a clean cut with a straight knife machine .

I think the most practical advantage would be ease of knife replacement. But since I only need to do that every 5 years or so that isn't much of a compelling reason for me.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#4

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

David Yoho

>Steve, I think it really depends on the type of wood you'll be passing over the jointer most. I have a Shelix head on my Delta 8-inch but I upgraded due to the amount of figured woods I've been using as of late.

If you'll be mostly jointing standard hardwoods without a lot of figure, then straight knives will do fine and cost less up front. I used to sharpen my own knives with my Tormek so sharpening costs wasn't an issue.

On the other hand, if you know you'll be using more woods with figure or knots (yes, the helical cutters slice knots very clean too), then going with the helical cutter is a better idea.

David

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#5

Re: Helical have several advantages

Larry Clinton at Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I used a Grizzly 6" joiner for several years and a 12 1/2" Dewalt planer - both with straight blades. A few months before I retired about 3 years ago, my son bought me a Yorkcraft 20" stationary planer with the Byrd helical head. I also purchased an 8" Grizzly joiner with the Griz helical head. I had changed the blades in both my previous joiner and planer a few times. The Helical heads really surprised me when I started using them on some woods that had chipped out on the blade units like figured Cherry, and honey locust. I had always gotten some chip-out when machining woods with knots or grain reversal. The Helical cutters cut cleanly on everything I tried. I just rotated the cutters on my 20" planer for the first time a couple of months ago, after over 3 years of pretty hard use. I had chipped a couple cutters slightly and it seemed that I was seeing a few lines (sanded out fairly easy) and I figured they should be worn by now. As it turned out I could have replaced 3 or 4 cutters and probably ran another 3 years.

The advantages of the helical are:

1) They are carbide and in my experience give at least 8 to 10 times the life of steel blades (on each of 4 sides) so probably last a total of 32 to 40 times as long.

2) If you have an accident and run metal through the cutters - only those hitting the metal will be damaged and require rotation or replacement.

3) Rotating or replacement of the cutter inserts does not require ANY adjustment - I did spend about 3 or 4 hours cleaning and rotating the 120+ inserts on the 20" planer - but when I was through it cut perfectly.

IMHO the only real disadvantage to the helical cutter system is the initial cost - the inserts are somewhat more expensive than replacement blades - but far less expensive in the long run.

Another minor advantage of the helical system is that it runs quite a bit quieter. I really can't see any difference in the quality of cut between the Byrd head and the Grizzly - although they are on two different machines so I might if I were using a Grizzly planer. I am completely satisfied with both units and if I outlast (doubtful as I am 68 yo) either unit I will definitely purchase a helical cutter again.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#6

Re: Helical have several advantages

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Thanks, that's a lot of good info. While I have a decent amount of straight hardwoods, I do like my knotty figured pieces, so it seems that helical is good for me. I like the ease of changing and setting, certainly a plus.

I've probably got the same Delta 12 1/2" planer, too.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#7

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I've got a lot of straight lumber, but I do like working with knotty and figured wood, so seems it might be a good fit for me.

Thanks!

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#8

Re: historical perspective

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Yeah, I was wondering about that. It seemed, though, that more machines were coming out with helical cutterheads. If I'm getting a new machine I don't want to replace or upgrade for quite a while, helical is probably the better choice. I've used straight knife jointers and they do cut perfectly fine, though.

Thanks!

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#9

Purty!

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>One thing I picked up on this thread is that I can probably go helical on my planer if I feel like it too. I'm sure it makes a good difference on the planer since those knives see a lot more use.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#10

why it makes more planer sense

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>A planer typically planes whole boards and the inexpensive ones do not have variable feed rate. There is little opportunity to adjust machine conditions to accommodate difficult grain situations. Hence, a cutter head that accommodates difficult grain makes some sense, especially if planing maple or birch. It makes mush less sense if one typically planes poplar, oak or walnut.

Typically one is jointing shorter lengths so there is less opportunity for grain reversals and a very slow feed rate solves tear-out issues in almost every case.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#11

bottom line economic analysis

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The answer isn't simply whether helical is preferred, or not, over straight, unless you have infinite money to spend. The answer is where to spend the money you have to spend. What would you do with the money saved by buying straight knives? If the answer is put this money into buying a jointer with a longer bed then I would go with the longer bed, or 8" vs 6" then I would go 8". In each of these choices the benefit is much greater.

If the answer is buy a better planer, then I would buy a better planer. If the answer is whether to put the money into a helical head for a planer or the jointer , then the planer is the preferred choice.

The bottom line is what benefit is to be gained by that difference in money spent. The benefit of spending it on the jointer knives is small in my opinion.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#12

Re: why it makes more planer sense

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Ah, I see. That does make sense. Hmm, now to contemplate another machine upgrade.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#13

Couple of Questions

Jesse Cloud

>Interesting thread. I'm thinking of making my next planer helical, but have to work out a couple of questions first...

1)If a helical insert gets a ding, can you rotate just that one? Wouldn't it be proud of the others and leave a mark? Someone told me you have to rotate the whole set at once, but he might not have known what he was talking about...

2)Following up on Bill T's advice "if the choice is between helical and a better planer, get a better planer" - what do you look for in a planer? My most frustrating application is planing thin strips to a very precise thickness (sometimes the planer 'eats' them, sometimes its very difficult to adjust the height precisely.

Thanks in advance!

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#14

Re: bottom line economic analysis

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>Hi Bill,

I agree with you on counts. I think that we all have a sense of economy and how we address our wood budget spending habits. Knives are all well and good and you know well your ways with them.

If I did it all over again I would still go helical, but yes, my planner first. My planner conversion was about $1700, my jointer was $500. The less expensive option was chosen first more to give me confidence to do the more expensive one later, in my case actually the planner option at Byrd was not available for 3 years.

Our hobbies are all not simply bottom line investments, some times we indulge in some tool options that are over the top. For me the helicals were about that and that I love working figured woods. If you think my helicals were over the top, you should see my hand planes... they make my machines look like a bargain!

;-)

take care,

Jim

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#15

The only real disadvantage is cost

John in NM

>As Bill's pointed out. In a jointer I might not bother unless I was using a lot of figured wood - birch and maple in particular I've had trouble with.

In a planer there is actually a significant performance improvement. A friend of mine put a helical head in an old 16" Powermatic planer and it basically now turns out strips like a Performax sander. Not sure what the smallest he can do is, but from what I've seen the limitation has more to do with the strip curling as it comes out than the planer eating it.

Even so, its a lot of money to do what can be done with a table saw and a good handplane. And when you do have to replace the inserts you get to pay all over again.

Bottom line for me - I would consider upgrading my planer if I were doing professional work or if time were a consideration, but for now I can buy an awful lot of lumber instead.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#16

Re: Helical have several advantages

Alex Grigoriev

>When you have 2 or 3 straight knives, each slaps against the whole board with great force. When you have those small inserts, they bite into a little piece of the border at a time. Makes smaller chips, too, easier to carry through the DC. And should be easier on the feed rollers and gears, too.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#17

Re: Couple of Questions

Fred Davis

>"if the choice is between helical and a better planer, get a better planer"

A helical Planer is a better planer.

Likewise for a Helical jointer.

The time to go for a Helical is when your buying a planer or jointer , the cost is much less then a retrofit to a existing machine.

If your tool buying budget is small, you might consider the Steel City

benchtop planer , for it is hundreds of dollars less then the cost of retrofiting my 20" Jet Planer, maybe even a thousand less.

FredD

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#18

Re: Couple of Questions

Alex Grigoriev

>Steel City bench planer has HSS cutters, not carbide; each with two edges, not with four. Still, I consider buying it. This planer is pretty much the same design as Ridgid TP1300 (now discontinued in favor of 3 knife model), except for the cutting head.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#19

Re: Couple of Questions

Fred Davis

>That is true Alex,

but on the other hand , you can get a much sharper edge on HSS then on Carbide , though the Carbide will not dull as fast, but then again you can chip a Carbide knife on a loose knot , especially in a jointer.

I have always run HSS steel knives in planers and Jointers, so I would enjoy a step up to a Helical system regardless of the knife metal.

There are pros and cons , but the bottom line is, the manufactuers are going Helical

FredD

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#20

Re While we're asking questions

Geary from NJ

>I have an old Foley Belsaw 12'planer, that I have special made profile trim blades to be used for decorative trim . If I were to upgrade to a spiral selix planer, then I wouldn't be able to use my straight knife trim blades in my new plainer,correct? Belsaw made a dozen blades for me,just by sending them a slice of the old trim I was trying to match.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#21

Re: Re While we're asking questions

Fred Davis

>Correct, but you could always sell them.

FredD

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#22

I believe there are straight carbide heads...

John in NM

>that will take cutters like you describe. Never seen one, but it's been described to me.

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#23

Re: Couple of Questions

Paul Leuba - Hunt Valley, MD

>What is your perspective on purchasing a combo jointer/planer and investing in just one helical head?

Paul In Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Jointers - Helical or standard knives?

#24

Re: Couple of Questions

Fred Davis

>Paul ,

I personally prefer stand alone machines located with a mind to the flow of work.

On the other hand if you are doing woodwork for fun and personal satisfaction, where time is not a over riding consideration , combo machines especially the European ones will do fine.

Each woodworker has their own needs , if combo machines works best for you then get one.

FredD