Re: Helical have several advantages
Larry Clinton at Frankfort (Central)., Indiana
>I used a Grizzly 6" joiner for several years and a 12 1/2" Dewalt planer - both with straight blades. A few months before I retired about 3 years ago, my son bought me a Yorkcraft 20" stationary planer with the Byrd helical head. I also purchased an 8" Grizzly joiner with the Griz helical head. I had changed the blades in both my previous joiner and planer a few times. The Helical heads really surprised me when I started using them on some woods that had chipped out on the blade units like figured Cherry, and honey locust. I had always gotten some chip-out when machining woods with knots or grain reversal. The Helical cutters cut cleanly on everything I tried. I just rotated the cutters on my 20" planer for the first time a couple of months ago, after over 3 years of pretty hard use. I had chipped a couple cutters slightly and it seemed that I was seeing a few lines (sanded out fairly easy) and I figured they should be worn by now. As it turned out I could have replaced 3 or 4 cutters and probably ran another 3 years.
The advantages of the helical are:
1) They are carbide and in my experience give at least 8 to 10 times the life of steel blades (on each of 4 sides) so probably last a total of 32 to 40 times as long.
2) If you have an accident and run metal through the cutters - only those hitting the metal will be damaged and require rotation or replacement.
3) Rotating or replacement of the cutter inserts does not require ANY adjustment - I did spend about 3 or 4 hours cleaning and rotating the 120+ inserts on the 20" planer - but when I was through it cut perfectly.
IMHO the only real disadvantage to the helical cutter system is the initial cost - the inserts are somewhat more expensive than replacement blades - but far less expensive in the long run.
Another minor advantage of the helical system is that it runs quite a bit quieter. I really can't see any difference in the quality of cut between the Byrd head and the Grizzly - although they are on two different machines so I might if I were using a Grizzly planer. I am completely satisfied with both units and if I outlast (doubtful as I am 68 yo) either unit I will definitely purchase a helical cutter again.