Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

Posts

Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

#1

Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

john lucas

>I like to watch antiques roadshow. They are constantly fretting over the fact that "thank god it has it's original finish". I don't do much antique repair but I do when asked. I've probably never done anything that was rare or actually worth a lot but here's my question.

The furniture I get is usually worn to the point the most people would not put this on display in their house. Consequently the customer want's it refinished so that it looks respectable. I feel the same way. If I had a nice piece that was rare but was butt ugly I would be very tempted to restore it. If you don't it would stay in the garage or attic until it deteriorates more. What would you do? If I stay in this business long enough I will eventually end up having to fix something that may actually be worth some money.

Some of the furniture they show is in serious need of repair or it would be totally useless in the house. They usually tell the person that this is worth $10,000+ dollars but only because it hasn't been restored or altered in any way. What do you think.

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

#2

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Old does not equal valuable, and 99.999% of old stuff is simply old stuff. It's the owner's responsibility to establish value, so if he/she wants it refinished, refinish it.

Clint

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

#3

I charge extra for appraisals

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

#4

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

steve mackay

>Just my two cents. If I'm wrong there is nothing to be had in sueing me, so . . . There is very little furniture still floating around out there that has not been identified by someone as VERY valuable. As in "pay-off-the-mortgage" valuable. If I can reasonable be sure a peice was not made before, say, 1860, I do as I plaese with it.

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

#5

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

Tony - Memphis

>My wife and I love "antiques," but none of what we own falls into the category where refinishing would make any difference. Value is a realtive thing. If its yours and you want it refinished to look nice in your home, then go for it. I don't mind a little character. My dad refinishes everything to the extreme (in my opinion). To each his own. Fortunately, I've only had to refinish a couple of our pieces. Usually, a good cleaning and some touch up is all they need, but again, we like a little character. Its all relative. Its funny though, I hear people with so-called antiques convinced by the tv shows that their piece will be ruined and worthless if they refinish it! And they say it with such authority!

Tony -who hopes to be an antique someday!

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

#6

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

Curly Smith

>I think that there are a couple of issues:

First, the very valuable piece of furniture that's in dire need of repair is only very valuable because it has historical significance. It's either an early, and hence rare, piece by a very well known maker or it was owned by a well known historical figure during a significant period in that person's life. The beat-up chair made by Anon Y. Mous and owned by your Great Aunt Helen is just a shade above kindling in value. A few questions of the owner will establish who owned it but it will take some work to be able to ID notable furniture makers.

Second, the concept of "antiques" is fairly new. Until about 50 years ago Antique Stores were called "Second-Hand Stores". People wanted to buy new stuff instead of the scratched and dented hand-me-downs that they got from relatives. The notable exceptions were the "heirloom" pieces by well known makers that were exceedingly expensive when new and, consequently, very well maintained. As Clint points out, it's now rather common for people to falsely equate "old" with "valuable" when the vast majority of "old" is just junk.

Lastly, when the folks on the Antiques Roadshow say that if your grandparents hadn't refinished their grandparents dining room table it would be worth $50,000 instead of $5,000, they don't mention that your grandparents had the choice of refinishing the decrepit eyesore and then using the table or sending it to the junk yard. When they say "if the leg hadn't been replaced" what they're really saying is "if the piece were still in pristine condition and hadn't been damaged" which is rather unrealistic since the piece had been damaged and the only choices the owner had were to either fix it or to scrap it.

To answer you specific question - I'd sell the butt ugly rare piece to somebody who didn't think it was butt ugly.

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

#7

interesting responses-thanks

john lucas

>

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

#8

Not just antique furniture people that say this

wilbur

>Over in the hand tool world, there's a lot of consternation as to how much you should restore a hand tool, especially if it comes to removing what some would call patina, and others would call dirt.

My feeling is that the "refinishing" issue is really a matter of fashion. It's fashionable to have old furniture and hand tools with the original finish. On the other hand, there are examples in other woodworking areas where bringing the object back to how it originally looked when it was first made is desirable. In woodworking, it's the restoration of vintage woodworking machinery. None of the OWWM aficionados care if you take an old piece of machinery, strip the paint, prime, and repaint it. That's actually considered to be desirable. If OWWM were treated like hand tools, no one would touch the flaking and worn paint.

To show how the pendulum can swing, in the fine art world leaving the patina/grime on famous paintings was considered to be the rule. Nowadays there is much more of an effort to clean the paintings to restore them to what they looked like when they were painted. Anyone who has seen the Sistine Chapel recently can attest to why this is a great idea.

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

#9

Re: Not just antique furniture people that say thi

Bill White

>I am a fan of the Roadshow, but they have not come to our home to value ANY of our old pieces, and I rather pride myself in being able to bring back the luster and charm of some of our older "stuff".

There are some items that have just been cleaned (properly), but I ain't havin' some crappy lookin' furniture 'cause all the kids want our oldies just like they are (not as they used to be).Bill

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

#10

Depends

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>If you're looking for the investment in something that looks abused and is valued only by others with too much money and little, if any, independent opinion or taste, then put the thing away and don't even dust it. That dust might be worth more (to some fool) than your house.

On the other hand, if you admire the craft and design of days-gone-by and respect the craftsman who put his heart and soul into making something to give pleasure and survive long past he brief time on this earth, then consider tastefully restoring the item.

But make no mistake, "restoring" is far removed from mere "refinishing". Research the piece and the methods and materials that were used to make and finish it when new. Then, being true to those parameters, embark on your effort.

I have a neighbor who had a 19th century convertible game table done in gorgeous mahogany. It was very much the worse for wear with the finish in the carved legs and pedestal dulled and grimed from many decades of neglect, and the top was scratched and worn on the edges. We carefully cleaned it and, after determining the finish to the a dark waxy shellac, proceeded to give it a good alcohol rubdown to remove the rest of the gunk and some of the original finish. We next smoothed some of the open pores in the edge grain, gently filling them with dark shellac. We left the scratches in the top, but filled them with dark shellac wet sanded level. Next we mixed up a quantity of dewaxed dark garnet shellac, added an appropriate amount of bees wax, and then used that to refinish the piece. The top received 7 coats by spray application, and the scratches were thus filled with finish. You can still see them if you know where to look, but the top was then rubbed out to about a 60% sheen.

The table is like a jewel in their living room and draws compliments from everyone on how wonderfully an old piece like that has been cared for.

I'd like to think that the guy who made it would feel we done him proud.

Re: Don't refinish-you'll ruin it's value

#11

ARG ! The "P" word !

steve mackay

>