Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Any experience with wooden hinges?

Posts

Any experience with wooden hinges?

#1

Any experience with wooden hinges?

Barry Irby

>I made the Wooden hinges on the box below. They are 1/2" thick and the pin is 1/8" brass rod. They are about 1 3/4" wide. Glued into recesses about a 1/4" deep. Anyone have experience with them. We were very gentle with them. Glued them in and pinned them with ebony pins. This set of hinges were made of tibet, a nice oily exotic. I made other sets while I was at it. I am considering testing a set to destruction. Any suggestions on how to test them? Are they strong enough? Is testing them a waste of time? any suggestions on keeping the glue out of the knuckles?

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

#2

Ellis Walentine

Some thoughts for you...

Ellis Walentine

>Barry, I know you're avid for feedback, so here goes...

It seems to me that the reason to test something to destruction is to make sure the engineering will withstand normal use plus a reasonable safety factor. You mentioned earlier that the design of the box and/or the hinges is such that the lid stops at 5� over vertical. In the absence of a lid stay, this tells me that either the hinges themselves are stopping the travel or that the back of the box is meeting the edge of the lid at that point. It's hard to tell from your photos and description how this is being accomplished.

I always prefer a fail-safe mechanical stay for boxes to keep destructive forces off the hinges. This is why quadrant hinges are so popular on cigar boxes. I wouldn't bother testing the box to failure, because with the length of the lever arm (the depth of the lid front to back), you can be fairly confident that either the hinge or the attachment will break if it is subjected to a sharp force such as being opened too enthusiastically or falling off the coffee table and landing the wrong way. The back shoulders of the lower hinge halves will create the fulcrum and the force on the lid will at some point split out the wood between there and the hinge pin. Tibbet is strong, but not indestructible. Often, exotic woods are actually more brittle than more pedestrian ones. Something gnarly and indestructible like elm would offer greater resistance to splitting. If you design for function, and you aren't using a lid stay, you should go for material that is tough and has interlocked grain.

Another thing to consider is your method of installing the hinges into the mortises. The preferred way would have been to connect them to the back and lid as sliding dovetails, to create an actual mechanical connection to the box. An open recess doesn't provide that connection, so you are relying on your fasteners -- in this case ebony pins -- to provide the pullout resistance. Ebony pins are very hard and smooth and don't offer much pull-out strength even when glued, unless you install them at opposing angles to create some mechanical interference. If you had used the sliding dovetail method, you wouldn't have needed the pins at all, unless you wanted to use just one in each hinge to keep the dovetail from sliding apart, which is pretty unlikely.

There are lots of other ways to make wooden hinges, and all of them will have some design limitations, depending on the application. If you can anticipate the amount and direction of the destructive forces on the piece, you can do a meaningful test. Murphy's Law has a way of defeating the best laid plans. DAMHIKT.

Darn nice looking box. Good job.

Ellis

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

#3

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

Michael Bush

>You might be the foremost expert on wooden hinges on the board!

At least you've made some. It's never even crossed my mind.

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

#4

Why Can't I see the box?

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>I don't see any attachment.

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

#5

sharing a brain.....

Barry Irby

>At least what is left of mine. This is what happens when you make it up as you go. I actually thought of using a sliding dove tail. After my son finished the box of course, but I did think of it.

I also thought about the uselessness of trying to test them. I guess the best test would be to make a box and man handle it a bit, but I think you are right. Making things that are fool proof is pretty much impossible because the fools are so perversely clever.

I had some elm. Wonder where it went? (Now that would be a miracle, if YOU could tell me where my elm went.) Wonder if there Si a list of woods by toughness/interlocking grain?

Thanks for the input. I really do appreciate the thoughts.

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

#6

Go down about 3 posts to Maple box.....

Barry Irby

>

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

#7

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

Marv

>Barry,

There are ways to strengthen the wood you use for your hinges. Cut them to the shape you want, then soak the separate pieces in Boiled Linseed Oil. BLO will penetrate deep into the fibers. Allow it to dry for several days. Then fine tune the fit.

I'm sure there are other substances that will do the job. BLO is the first that comes to mind.

Expect the BLO to darken the wood though.

Marv

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

#8

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges? *LINK*

Marv

>Barry,

Here's a link to one guy's method of making wood hinges....

Marv


Making wood hinges

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

#9

Ellis did a great job of describing the situation

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>There are a couple of things that I might add to help you think about the weakest point of a project like this where we try to veer away from standard practice.

As I am sure you and everyone else already know that the weakest property of wood is the Tension Perpendicular to the grain. This is proven by the ability to split firewood with and ax. If it was the same in all directions, we could hit the wood anywhere with the same ax and force, with the expectation of it breaking every which way.

You should be able to find more information than you care to read by googling "Tensile strength perpendicular to grain, wood, tables"

The other thing that you should think about is leverage. The laws are fairly simple. If you measure from the center of the pin to the bind point, then divide that into the length of the lever arm, which is the width of the door. This will be the number used to multiply the force felt between the pin and fulcrum.

if you want to do a test. You could find a number that matches your hinge pretty easily.

Take a scrap of the hinge wood of the same proportions as your hinge. Into the end-grain, saw a slot to a depth of the pin to fulcrum point, wide enough to fit a strong lever, which is the length of the lid width.

Glue your test piece to a surface. As you pull against a spring scale hooked onto the end of your lever until it breaks, you will have a # which you can multiply X the lever length. Of course this will be a higher number than a shock load required to split the same part.

My advice, is to get something to limit the lid from hitting the maximum opening limit of the hinge.

Don't ask how I gained any insights into failing wood hinge parts. It is a mystery to me why some things that seemed like a great idea before, don't seem so smart anymore.

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

#10

Re: Any experience with wooden hinges?

Michael Bush

>That guy got nice looking results, but surely it doesn't *have* to be that complicated.