Ellis did a great job of describing the situation
Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6
>There are a couple of things that I might add to help you think about the weakest point of a project like this where we try to veer away from standard practice.
As I am sure you and everyone else already know that the weakest property of wood is the Tension Perpendicular to the grain. This is proven by the ability to split firewood with and ax. If it was the same in all directions, we could hit the wood anywhere with the same ax and force, with the expectation of it breaking every which way.
You should be able to find more information than you care to read by googling "Tensile strength perpendicular to grain, wood, tables"
The other thing that you should think about is leverage. The laws are fairly simple. If you measure from the center of the pin to the bind point, then divide that into the length of the lever arm, which is the width of the door. This will be the number used to multiply the force felt between the pin and fulcrum.
if you want to do a test. You could find a number that matches your hinge pretty easily.
Take a scrap of the hinge wood of the same proportions as your hinge. Into the end-grain, saw a slot to a depth of the pin to fulcrum point, wide enough to fit a strong lever, which is the length of the lid width.
Glue your test piece to a surface. As you pull against a spring scale hooked onto the end of your lever until it breaks, you will have a # which you can multiply X the lever length. Of course this will be a higher number than a shock load required to split the same part.
My advice, is to get something to limit the lid from hitting the maximum opening limit of the hinge.
Don't ask how I gained any insights into failing wood hinge parts. It is a mystery to me why some things that seemed like a great idea before, don't seem so smart anymore.