Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Do I need to invite comments?

Posts

Do I need to invite comments?

#1

Do I need to invite comments?

Barry Irby

>I post OT stuff and get lots of comments. Now I have posted two wood working posts (The box below and the doors several days ago)and am getting no comments. Should I have invited them? Is it apart of the etiquette to not make comments unless asked for? Or is the lack of comments telling me something?

Re: Do I need to invite comments?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: comments

Moses Yoder

>How many men does it take to make a box? One to cut and fit, and 1000 to cheer him on ;) We are all looking for affirmation of some sort, but I don't think a woodworking forum is actually designed to give a guy a sense of purpose but to answer questions if you have questions. I don't usually comment on projects for this reason. It is kind of nice to post a project and get a 1000 responses telling us how good it looks, but I think we need a sense of purpose besides the woodworking forum. If you do the best you can on a project I think that you can give yourself a big pat on the back and know that you did the best you could. I think another thing to keep in mind is that we should be learning from our projects so the next one is better.

Your box looks very nice by the way. I love curly maple. Give yourself a big pat on the back for me.

P.S. It is not necessary to ask for responses, people will respond as they have the time and inclination to do so.

Re: Do I need to invite comments?

#3

Re: Yeah, we're tying to tell you...

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Barry,

We're trying to tell you to stick to the off topic posts and leave woodworking questions to folks who know what they're doing.

Seriously, I really enjoy your OT posts and considered saying so in reply to your "fixed some rotten doors" posts but, didn't have time upon first read. Then when I had time I became distracted by other posts. I found the door post educational and appreciated you taking the time to take pictures during the repair process.

Al

Re: Do I need to invite comments?

#4

Re: Do I need to invite comments?FREE BEER

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>A sure way to get a response is to put "FREE BEER or NAKED WOMEN" in the subject line and then post your question or comment.

Re: Do I need to invite comments?

#5

P.S.

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Nice Box

Re: Do I need to invite comments?

#6

See below your original post.

Marv

>

Re: Do I need to invite comments?

#7

Re: Do I need to invite comments?

Fred Davis

>It's my personal opinion that a woodworkers product , be it a house or a cigar box will speak for itself.

That's how more work is drummed up , should you want it.

Beyond that Barry, I find your OT posts interesting and a ongoing glimpse into your everyday life.

Keep it coming

FredD

Re: Do I need to invite comments?

#8

wooden hinges leave me speechless

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have a bad enough time figuring out brass hinges and getting them installed right.

Anyway, it is a handsome box and precisely executed.