We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I've see the one in FWW 191. I think it is reasonable for stretchers and aprons. I'm more interested in one for legs.
Does anyone have any recommendations for shop made jigs? I've seen the various commercial ones and I don't really want to spend that much. I do have time and lumber though.
>For a job-specific, down and dirty jig (before I owned two horizontal mortisers), I used to make a routing template from a piece of 1/2" plywood and attach wooden flanges perpendicular to the template, forming a U-shaped template that can be clamped to the leg or stile that you're mortising.
If you want an adjustable jig, there are probably dozens lurking in past issues of just about all the wood mags. I haven't checked with the indexing guys lately, so I have no idea how to steer you to likely candidates.
>I have one I made - similar to Barber's. Anything you make up with a horizontal router lifting vertically with an X and Y table will do fine. Just be sure the piece is firmly clamped to the table as shown by Barber. I use that type of clamp also.
>... at the College of the Redwoods. I have not heard whether the side pressure of loose tenoning took its toll on the bearings, but I would suspect it.
>The machines they used were old Davis & Wells boring machines modified to use a chuck instead of a screw in drill bit. They are pretty heavy duty machines with some beefy bearings, the amount of use they got in a year would probably be a lifetimes worth of work in a one man shop. The table is fixed on them so you would mark out your joints and slowly move the piece to be mortised back and forth by hand. I would much rather be able to clamp the board down and have the table or head move back and forth. Much better repeatbility and safer.
This was in the mid 1980's don't know if they still have them or what they use now..
>I guess I'm the oddball on the "fixed or adjustable" issue. My philosophy is that anything that can be adjusted, must be adjusted and will probably go out of adjustment at the worst possible time. For legs I make quick and dirty jigs like Ellis described. That way I know the mortise will be in the exact same place each and every time.
>Didn't say how much time and effort you want to spend on making the jig - but here's one that's sort of a hybdrid of the LEIGH FMT idea with a micro adjustable fence for keeping the bit paralleling the front ege of the part.
The problems with almost all the mortising methods/jigs, especially when working with set backs - like your table apron to leg - are:
1. working out set backs for the mortises
. . .in the legs to get the reveal you want,
. . .given where you want the mortise in the
. . .end of the apron. Takes some mental
. . .gymnastics.
. . .3/4" apron. mortise centered so it's 3/8"
. . .from the show face to the centerline of
. . .the apron mortise
. . .Add your set back, say 1/4" and you've got
. . .3/8 plus a quarter so the leg mortise
. . .center line needs to be 3/8+2/8 = 5/8, so
. . .5/8" back from the show face of the leg
2. Once you've got the centerline set back
. . .the show face you've got to scribe a center
. . .line on at least one of each type of part
. . .for alignment in the jig or mortising
. . .machine - and that's just for one axis
3. You've still got to layout the ends of the
. . .mortises - for each type of part so you
. . .can STOP the mortising cutter at the
. . .desired locations. And the stops have to
. . .be reset at least for the legs and unless
. . .the mortise in the apron is perfectly
. . .centered on the height of the arpron, for
. . .the apron parts as well
4. And once you get the part IN the jig or
. . .machine you've got to hold it there. If it
. . .move while you're cutting you're screwed.
. . .So clamping is required, and the clamp(s)
. . .can't interfere with moving the cutting
. . .bit - which is often a "challenge"
:
:
:
Until the DOMINO came along I saved loose tenon joinery for pieces that really really warranted the time and effort, to say nothing of the Paying Attention So I Don't End Up With Two Lefts and No Right that was involved. With the DOMINO, I can bang out some pretty nice display tables for my oldest's bonsais in under an hour, including stretchers near the bottom of the legs, with all the mortises taking maybe 10 minutes to cut - and that's with reveals so I can do edge treatments on the legs to pretty things up some. As fast and accurate as pocket hole joinery - but a lot nicer looking since there's no visible pocket hole to have to hide somehow.
I tried all sorts of ways to do mortises for One Shots - horizontal mortiser, chisel and bit mortiser, shop make mortising jigs, the TREND M&T jig. But mortises were always a hassle - layout lines. alignment, stops, etc. .
With the DOMINO, I started using loose tenon joinery for all sorts of things - because it was so fast and easy. Ideas I'd kissed off because of the hassles involved became easily doable.
Think in terms of Pay Me Know - in a chunk of change - Or - Pay Me With Time Effort and Aggravation.
It's odd that you don't think much about dropping a chunk of change on a tablesaw, joiner and planer to make the parts - yet when it comes to tools and machines to hold them together money becomes a major issue.
Any way you can organize a group purchase? It's not like each person in the group will need to have the DOMINO for days or weeks at a time. It'll cut a LOT of mortises in under an hour - where you want them. You'll find all kinds of uses - for things you hadn't even consider before.
BTW - there are TWO mortises in each end of each of the apron parts, with two corresponding mortises in each of the two sides of the legs. That's 32 mortises just for the leg/apron joinery - and 16 more for the stretchers. That's 48 mortises - all cut with the parts laying on a workbench - without ANY clamping involved - show face always up - NO layout lines - at all - . . .
>I typically have used my end vise and a fence and just marked the starts and stops on my end vise (9/4 maple). Yours may be a time hog to build, but it will be easier to use.