Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Bathroom underlayment - recommendations

Posts

Bathroom underlayment - recommendations

#1

Bathroom underlayment - recommendations

Terry Alexander

>Bad as I hate to, I have to put a new underlayment for my bathroom. (Actually my BIL's bathroom as we are building a new house). Very old house and after pulling carpet, original floor is pine planks.

Q: Should we use 3/4" MDF, plywood, or particle board?

Q2: Should we put down with ring shanked nails or screw it down?

As always....TIA

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: Bathroom underlayment - recommendations

#2

No, Maybe, No

Barry Irby

>I am not thoroughly familiar with MDF, but I don't think it is suitable for wet locations. Some types of plywood are suitable, but particle board is definitely not. I believe MDF swells like crazy if it gets wet and particle board turns back into sawdust.

Actually, we need a little more info. what floor covering are thinking about. If It is 3/4" oak flooring, the boards you have are fine. (But I personally frown on wooden flooring in a bathroom.)

If it is to be vinyl, Underlayment grade plywood would be good. Actual plywood and real Underlayment grade. This type of plywood is usually 5/8" thick and has a plugged and sanded face, but an important feature is that the second ply is also plugged so that there is little or no chance a high heal or chair leg with punch through into a void in the second ply.

If you are putting down hard tile such as ceramic or quarry tile, Durock or Wonder Board, or Hardie board would be the ticket. Probably the 1/2" version. I just did a house with that in it and it worked well. I screwed it down, but you can lay it in thinset.

Re: Bathroom underlayment - recommendations

#3

Re: May I add...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>There is no reason that makes ANY sense in my book for wimping out on doing the floor right in a bathroom. Bathrooms are too essential to the function of a home to make do.

Overbuilding, using good, tested, well known materials, means that you have one less thing to worry about for a while.

None of them last forever, but I hate redoing one I already did. And since this is family, then...

Re: Bathroom underlayment - recommendations

#4

Re: Bathroom underlayment - recommendations

Fred Davis

>Terry,

you didn't specify the new floor covering , but if your going Vinyl sheet goods , 1/4" underlayment grade plywood is all the thickness you need. The guys and myself who do this regularly over the years have come to use 1 1/4" narrow head Senco staples , very fast and they don't back out .

what is equally important in my view , when using sheet goods is to use a installer who can cove the material up the wall a few inches.

This looks very attractive , water proofs the underlayment, and separates the handyman installer from a Professional installer.

Because the outside and inside corners of the walls and maybe the Vanity base require a experienced installer in this method , make sure he understands what you talking about.

Amateur attempts at coving look terrible.

If your doing Ceramic Tile and you don't provide a mortar base or cement board underlayment , keep the tile small or they will crack when the floor flexes under walking pressure.

Hardwood flooring in the bathroom , requires adult tenancy, no kids , big dogs or accidents.

FredD

Re: Bathroom underlayment - recommendations

#5

Re: Bathroom underlayment - recommendations

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>If the sub floor is rotted, you need to replace that with 3/4" plywood. Do not use MDF or particle board, tehy fail quickly if they get wet.

If you are putting down vinyl then you will need to build the floor up to the same level as adjoining floors with plywood and 1/4" water resistant underlayment. If you are going ceramic tile then you need to put down at least 1/4" cement board and screw it in place, then put your thin set and tile over that.

Lee

Re: Bathroom underlayment - recommendations

#6

Re: Bathroom underlayment - recommendations

Jim Dillon

>Terry,

Have also torn up our bathroom floor and went with 3/4 inch T&G plywood screwed down. I also used construction adhesive along the floor joists (in addition to the screws). I used the noncorrosive screws sold by McFeeleys, but that was because my subbasement is sometimes damp and the previous nails had all rusted quite a bit. Do NOT use MDF as it is a moisture trap. I chose to use ceramic tile to cover the plywood. If you do as well, I suggest using the thinset that is polymer-based as it allows just a little expansion to accommodate any small movement of the plywood. In fact, look at the lable on the thinset and it will say if it is OK for applying to plywood. So far (7 years), no cracks in the grout joints and the floor hasn't collapsed - which is good 8-). If you do decide to put down tile, the $100 tile cutter sold at the Borg worked far better than I ever thought it would and I have used it on other tiling renovations so it has easily paid for itself. Go for it!

Jim