Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

The economy and wood classes.

Posts

The economy and wood classes.

#1

The economy and wood classes.

Michael D-Man

>I know I will get ripped to shreads, but hey, we all have an opinion.

Why do these wood instructors charge so much? A lot of classes are over $700 for 5 days with a class limit of 15! You're talking about $11,000 for 5 days while there are other classes going on at the same time.

Sorry, I will assuredly get flamed, but that really seems excessive in this bad economy or not. Between Lonnie Bird and Marc Adams, they should be about rich by now (do the math). I'm not begrudging them having money or making it, but it seems a bit excessive, whether they fill the classes or not. A lot of us are being left in the dust. Although I'm sure you learn a lot, it's not the point I'm making. Lonnie and Marc are making money hand over fist. Yes, I know that their instructors don't work for free and sometimes they include a light lunch, and yes, they put their time in, but still........too highly priced. I'd love to see their W-2's at the end of the year.

Michael

p.s. Okay, let me have it and tell me how wrong I am. I have real thick skin.

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#2

Re: The economy and wood classes.

mike from american sycamore

>You are right that seems to be a high gross but when you take in account of the investment that they have in the building and tools and the insurance would scare you to death. I have decided to make my classes smaller and go to one-on-ones. Pick the week you want to come and we will build or work on the project or skills that you want to learn, A one-on-one is $850.00 per week plus I have a nice private room for 250.00 which includes breakfast and lunch. Bring a friend and the sliding scale goes to 750.00.

I have three friends coming next week to each build a Shaker tall chest. The class will be 650.00 each plus material. No waiting in line or waiting for the insructors attention. We all are just trying to make a living. If you think it is so easier and such a cash cow You can own your own school. I will sell you mine LOL!!

Mike

Mike

American Sycamore

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#3

Re: The economy and wood classes.

Jesse Cloud

>Interesting topic. I used to be in the training business (computer stuff) and 700 for a week's class was about what we charged several years ago. I have never been to Marc's or Lonnie's class, but I suspect they have facilities with mortgages and high maintenance/utilities. I can't imagine what their insurance must be like. Machine maintenance, consumables, and project supplies add up. It costs $$ to develop the class and prepare the handouts, etc. etc.

And from what I have seen when I have tried to register, they both are pretty much booked up. Supply and demand. I say more power to them!

On the other hand, I can take a semester long class at the local community college for less than $700...

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#4

Re: The economy and wood classes.

Michael D-Man

>No Mike,I never said it was easy, nor did I imply it. But........I knew someone would say that. Believe me, I am educated and realize that there is insurance involved as well as the tools, building and other variables that you yourself did not mention, but still.

Do the math on Lonnie Bird's classes for a year and you will be blown away. A highly skilled professor doesn't make that much and they've spent years and years of research and most likely have obtained a PhD along the way. Someone called Lonnie on it once (don't remember where), but he would not respond. Sorry Mike, I still feel it's a lot of money when you add up 12-20 students and take into account the amount of classes per year. But...........I am glad that you responded and appreciate it very much.

Michael

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#5

Re: The economy and wood classes.

wilbur

>$11,000 for 5 days of instruction is $275 per hour for professional level instruction for your class of 15, assuming 8 hours per day. And that's assuming that all of the tuition cost is going to the instructor.

For your individual $700 tuition, the price drops to paying $17.50 per hour of instruction, again assuming that none of your tuition is going to things like shop or project supplies. To get professional level hands on instruction for less than $20 an hour is a real bargain.

The total cost may seem like a lot, but it is really on the low end of this level of training and education.

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#6

Re: The economy and wood classes.

Barry Irby

>I have never been to one of these classes, but I did attend a turning class at Arrowmont. When you go to a flat work class to make say a chest, does each student bring their own wood and other consumables?

If the instructor provides the wood, that would be a significant expense. The prep time on that wood would be a significant setup cost.

I am asking, because Arrowmont provided the turning blanks.

I don't know, but I suspect that many of these people do not have classes every week, probably more like once a month.

And they have to put up with idiots like me. I broke David Ellsworth's personal hollowing tool. He took it better than I expected. Of course, I expected to be impaled.

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#7

Re: The economy and wood classes.

Michael D-Man

>That is true Wilbur, but that's where the theory of volume comes into play which reduces the price point. In 6 months, Lonnie grosses just under $185,000 (if my math is correct), that does not include DVD sales, private lessons not listed, write-offs, router bits sales, etc.....it works both ways.

But don't be surprised, I'm blown away that they pay a man, any man, millions to try to put a puck in a net or a ball in a hoop. Why? Because without breaking down every detail, that's what the market pays. TV rights, bonuses, seat prices, concessions, et.....I live a stones throw from Detroit and could care less that the Wings loss to Pittsburg or even if they won. How does it affect me? I can get free tickets, even playoff tickets, due to where I work, but I never go. I'd rather watch a doctor perform surgery or learn how to build something, but not for $945 a week.........too much.

So then if Lonnie can get that much, more power to him, but I don't agree with it. We are woodworkers, sharing a passion, or at least trying to. We are not spoiled athletes.

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#8

Re: The economy and wood classes.

Michael D-Man

>Barry, the 2 guys that I'm talking about go about half a year (April till Sept., Oct.), with classes most weeks or weekends. It's not an attack on Marc or Lonnie, just an observation. We all have an opinion.

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#9

Re: The economy and wood classes.

Mark Nowicki

>Since you are looking for opinions, here is mine.

Set up a woodworking school and charge less.

Mark

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#10

Re: The economy and wood classes.

wilbur

>Efficiencies of volume do not come into play in a teaching situation. As your class size goes up, the amount of work you spend in teaching increases along with it. You have more questions, which takes time to address, which slows you down as you are trying to cover the material you need to. You also have less time per student. In my experience, in woodworking classes these issues are multiplied by the fact that the skill level of the students often can be all over the map, so some time also needs to be spent making sure that everyone is on the same page. Usually this was due to my beginner level status. :@)

I can attest to this, as I teach residents and medical students as part of my duties at the hospital and university where I work. Things are much different if I have one student with me as opposed to if I have three. My sister is a high school teacher, and she has exactly the same experience.

The only question is whether less than $20 an hour for teaching is worthwhile to you. How much the instructor makes in total should not be an issue at all. What I can say is that a rate of $20 or less is very reasonable for the classes you describe, and not exorbitantly high, regardless of the subject being taught.

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#11

Re: The economy and wood classes.

Stuart Hough

>It boils down to this...if your personal economics can't support the cost...don't go. Personally, I'd kill to be able to go, but my finances preclude that for now. So I'll bide my time, reading and watching everything I can get my hands on, so that WHEN I get to attend, I'll have smarter questions to ask!

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#12

Alternative?

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Michael - the classes you mentioned are indeed expensive. Are they worth the money? That's up to the people who take them.

As an alternative to expensive, week-long classes, over the last several years I have taken SEMESTER-LONG classes at Palomar Community College near me for less than $100 plus materials. The instructors there are world-class craftsman who build boxes, chairs, rockers, antique reproductions and even kitchen cabinets. They have studied under the likes of Maloof, Adams, Byrd and Krenov. The one-on-one teaching is outstanding.

These sort of classes offer an excellent option at an affordable price. I'm sure there are schools near you with the same quality instruction.

Doug

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#13

Re: Alternative?

Michael D-Man

>Thanks for an educated and well meaning response Doug. I will honestly keep your post in mind as an alternative. Much appreciated.

Michael

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#14

JL

Re: The economy and wood classes.

JL

>Insurance - liability, etc. - over $3K a month.

Wear and tear on equipment - depends on the equipment, but figure having to replace a bandsaw every 3 years. Drill presses - about every 5 years. Cabinet saws - about every 15 years. Lathes - 5-10 years. 5" ROS - 1-2 years. Small power tools - 1-2 years. Handtools - 5-10 years.

Utilities - easily $2K month (heating/air conditioning, power, water, sewage).

Add it up - figure on at LEAST $8-10K a month in overhead.

I help over at JCC Folkschool every once in a while. The wear and tear on the buildings is also a factor. OK - so these guys charge a bit. Is it worth it? Perhaps. You don't have to pay it.

My personal opinion is that I would rather have a week long class than a 1 day seminar.

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#15

Re: The economy and wood classes.

Michael D-Man

>My friend makes cabinets and has a big shop, I mean big shop. He does not pay $2,000 in utilities. Materials, yes, utilities, not even close. That's my take. Not saying your 2k is wrong, just not what I know of here in Michigan.

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#16

The Relative Value of a Class

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>My Take on It,

I have taken a few classes in my time and have had a variety of experiences.

I have taken a class with Christian Becksvoort at Sheridan College in Oakville. He taught 5 full days and many of us stayed into the evenings, Chris stayed with us, easily putting in a 50 hour week and giving each of the 8 of us in the class full value for the $400 Canadian we paid. The value for me was not so much in the cost but the time Chris gave each one of us to our unique projects.

I have attended a few Rob Cosman classes, he packs in a solid 60 hour week for those who don�t know him. I think the classes are in the neighbourhood of $700, but for 60 hours it�s a prime deal to work with some one who can teach you what Rob does.

I took one class at Marc Adams, the experience was excellent, I took a Thomas Stangland Class along with 14 other students. Thomas gave what he could, and the support at Marc Adams was good. Thomas was excellent and I loved the class, he inspired me very much and I think I would love to take a class with him again. I did have a problem though with the time given in class, we were interrupted on a number of occasions by Marc Adams to listen to him pitch the school and also with �Prisoner Exchange� where we spent the better part of one afternoon visiting the other classes to listen to their pitches. I felt lectured at the whole time I was there. On the final day of class he had us packing up and cleaning up and out the door by 1:30PM. I liked Marc Adams, but felt I only got 3 � days of shop time, too expensive for my tastes and not what I wanted in time value.

I lastly took a one day class in Michigan with Chris Schwarz on hand saws. It again was a full day packed for value ($100). We started on time and went full that day, a class of 8 and Chris was fully attentive and an excellent teacher and communicator. Our class all came away with clear learnings on saws and I felt totally excited to get back to my projects with my new skills.

I have been interested in Rosewood near Almont Ontario, perhaps it is on my list in the next short while.

So these are my experiences, Schools are what they are, value is in the eyes of the student. You are right in questioning the relative value and pay attention to what you want to learn and from who. You need to ask what you need to know and go in with the expectation that you are the customer and should be supported in your learnings. I will say Class size is important, also the hours supported, contrast a Rob Cosman at 60 hours/wk of class vs my experience with a Marc Adams at 28 hours of real class time/wk.

Take care,

Jim

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#17

Re: Alternative?

Thomas S Stockton

>Years ago I took a month long class at College of the Redwoods in Fort Bragg, California. It ran 6 days a week full time and instate tuition was $25 add a couple hundred for a campground and it was a bargain. As Doug said Palomar College has a good reputation I caught there display at the San Diego fair last year and there was a very wide range of work, from people just starting out to seasoned vets.

So look around at community colleges and adult continuing eduction courses you might find some gems. Other places to look is some of the traveling wood shows have good instructors, the seminars are shorter and not always hands on but it a whole lot less than a week. Other options are the Furniture society annual seminar and the Woodworking in America seminar(I hope I got the last one correct), not necessarily cheap but a lot of knowledge in one spot.

My opinion if there is a week long course and it is was either taught by someone I thought would be very interesting or it was something I really wanted to learn I wouldn't hesitate at all.

One last thing join your local woodworkers group might cost $50 a year but well worth it and some have their own seminars.

Tom

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#18

Re: The economy and wood classes.

mike from american sycamore

>Michael;

Let's do the math. Last week I had a beginning student and in six days we built a cherry entertainment center. We started Monday am at 8am and worked each day till 6 pm.

We finished up on Saturday at 4:30pm. We started with rough sawn cherry wood and machined our wood, made frame and panel construction, raised panel doors, dove tailed drawers, and made our own crown moulding.

I charged the customer $850.00 for shop time and $250.00 for the weeks lodging which includes breakfast and a nice home cooked lunch each day. The customer had $600.00 in material. You can go on the internet and find a piece of furniture like we built that sells for over $3500.00.

I feel my classes are a bargain. I also took this student from building "ducks on a stick" and gave him a big boost on hos way of being a furnture maker. The grass always looks greener on the other side. Do not be jealous of some one that has worked hard and made a success out of his business. I know Mark & Kelly also had a lot of lean years getting started.

Mike

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#19

Re: Alternative?

Alex Grigoriev

>I think the community college is funded mostly by local taxes, not by tuition.

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#20

Re: Alternative?

Nick Tuzzolino

>Doug: We are both lucky. Palomar is a great school and I am fortunate to have Cerritos College near me. Both top notch. Been going for ten years and see no end insight.

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#21

Re: Alternative?

Michael D-Man

>Tom, thank you for the decent response. Some good info there for sure and the college route may be the way to go.

Michael

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#22

Re: Alternative?

Michael D-Man

>Doug and Nick. Yes you are both lucky and I'm jealous!

Michael

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#23

Re: The economy and wood classes.

Michael D-Man

>I'm not jealous at all, as I stated, and I don't begrudge them a thing, nor you Mike. I simply asked if $945 per week is too much, and to me it is. Your example is fine and I'm sure you're a great teacher, but that's a one on one thing. If you did the same thing in a class with 10 people or more, at the same price,........see where I'm going. My example was not your example.

Please re-read my post. I said some of these classes have a dozen people or more at $795-$945 a pop. You and I are not talking about the same thing. I don't begrudge you one bit and have heard nothing but good things about your school. Actually, if I recall correctly, you were the guy who went to church and came back to have his shop partially emptied. If I'm wrong, I apologize, but my mid to late 30's mind might be to blame. Grouping together "in volume" brings more money, there's no getting around it.

Sorry, but I don't see it the same way that you do. $11,000 for one week of teaching, less than 8 hours a day is a good take, no matter how you slice it.

Michael

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#24

Re: Alternative?

Thomas S Stockton

>Yes community colleges are heavily funded by taxes but I think mostly from the state level unless there is a local parcel tax or sales tax that is for that purpose. Tuition is set at the state level at a certain $ amount per unit and higher amount for out of state residents. They also some of the best education bargains in the state.

Tom

Re: The economy and wood classes.

#25

Re: The Relative Value of a Class

Michael D-Man

>Well written Jim. I am doing only as you have mentioned, questioning the value of what I am paying for and asking others how they feel about it. It's called a discussion, and for the most part, it's went well.

Please let me guess. You took the class with Chris "Popwood" at the Sterling Heights Woodcraft? Am I correct? Matthew is the owner and he is one heck of a woodworker as well. He's been featured in the gallery section of Finewoodworking twice, not an easy thing to do. I was out of town with my family and could not attend that one, but heard it went well. How many miles did you have to drive to get to Sterling Heights, if I am correct in my assumption?

I know I've heard your name before, but maybe from another forum.

Anyways, thanks for the well thought out and informative post.

Michael