The Relative Value of a Class
Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada
>My Take on It,
I have taken a few classes in my time and have had a variety of experiences.
I have taken a class with Christian Becksvoort at Sheridan College in Oakville. He taught 5 full days and many of us stayed into the evenings, Chris stayed with us, easily putting in a 50 hour week and giving each of the 8 of us in the class full value for the $400 Canadian we paid. The value for me was not so much in the cost but the time Chris gave each one of us to our unique projects.
I have attended a few Rob Cosman classes, he packs in a solid 60 hour week for those who don�t know him. I think the classes are in the neighbourhood of $700, but for 60 hours it�s a prime deal to work with some one who can teach you what Rob does.
I took one class at Marc Adams, the experience was excellent, I took a Thomas Stangland Class along with 14 other students. Thomas gave what he could, and the support at Marc Adams was good. Thomas was excellent and I loved the class, he inspired me very much and I think I would love to take a class with him again. I did have a problem though with the time given in class, we were interrupted on a number of occasions by Marc Adams to listen to him pitch the school and also with �Prisoner Exchange� where we spent the better part of one afternoon visiting the other classes to listen to their pitches. I felt lectured at the whole time I was there. On the final day of class he had us packing up and cleaning up and out the door by 1:30PM. I liked Marc Adams, but felt I only got 3 � days of shop time, too expensive for my tastes and not what I wanted in time value.
I lastly took a one day class in Michigan with Chris Schwarz on hand saws. It again was a full day packed for value ($100). We started on time and went full that day, a class of 8 and Chris was fully attentive and an excellent teacher and communicator. Our class all came away with clear learnings on saws and I felt totally excited to get back to my projects with my new skills.
I have been interested in Rosewood near Almont Ontario, perhaps it is on my list in the next short while.
So these are my experiences, Schools are what they are, value is in the eyes of the student. You are right in questioning the relative value and pay attention to what you want to learn and from who. You need to ask what you need to know and go in with the expectation that you are the customer and should be supported in your learnings. I will say Class size is important, also the hours supported, contrast a Rob Cosman at 60 hours/wk of class vs my experience with a Marc Adams at 28 hours of real class time/wk.
Take care,
Jim