Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Question on epoxy?

Posts

Question on epoxy?

#1

Question on epoxy?

Barry Irby

>I am using some of the epoxy from the borg. I occasionally used the type that came in the two syringes that had twin plungers, help to assure you got equal amounts. This time they did not have any of those, but did have larger squeeze bottles of resin and hardener. My question is, if you err in the amounts, would you lean toward a little extra hardener? Does it matter much? If you have less hardener does it still set, maybe more slowly? This is the 60 minute stuff.

Re: Question on epoxy?

#2

Re: Question on epoxy?

Bricofleur

>Barry,

Pour two beads, side by side. This way you will be able to pour them quite similar in thickness and width. As you mentionned, a little bit more or a little bit less will only affect the setting time.

By the way, I never used seringes, only two tubes and never got in trouble.

Best,

Serge

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com

Re: Question on epoxy?

#3

JL

Doesn't matter that much...

JL

>if you have a little extra or too little. I.E. if you are supposed to have a 50:50 mix and end up having 60:40 or 40:60 you really won't see a difference. It will make a little difference in hardening time. If you are talking about a lot of difference (30:70 resin:hardener) you will see a difference. We used to have problems in the some of the plants with people messing up the ratios and we really didn't start seeing much of a problem with the epoxies that we used until we had less than a 40:60 ratio - like 35:65.

Re: Question on epoxy?

#4

Re: Question on epoxy?

Bill Howatt

>I tend to ensure I have at least the equal amount of hardner which probably means I'm a bit generous with it. Somehow I once got it way out of whack and ended up with a non-hardening stiff mess. I agree that if you are anywhere in the reasonably-close range it doesn't matter.

I use both tubes and syringes. I also use the dollar store 5 minute stuff for lots of non-critical repairs - no sense using the expensive stuff to stick some trivial things together.

Bill

Re: Question on epoxy?

#5

Re: Question on epoxy?

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>I use, generally, the 5 minute Ace tubes. I prefer to err on more hardener if I must. I agree that a tad more of one or the other makes little difference.

Re: Question on epoxy?

#6

Re: Question on epoxy?

Gil Jones...Georgia

>I use West System 5:1 mix, and this is an excellent epoxy. I also buy the special pumps that deliver the correct ratio of resin and hardner. One pump of each gives me a 5:1 mix, and there are no troubles. It is not cheap, but it works every time.

Gil

Re: Question on epoxy?

#7

Re: Question on epoxy?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>So I suppose it makes a difference if you're using it as an adhesive, or a filler base. I've used it as a filler, and not had what I would call a screaming success with it.

I'm certain it's user error on my part. It usually is.

Re: Question on epoxy?

#8

R: Question(s) on Epoxy?

Joel M. Dibbern-Kramer

>If you change the ratio from a 50:50 to something different, do you not create a more ductile vs. brittle compound/joint?

Is the strength of the compound effected?

Is it also true that the sun's UV rays will turn/make epoxy more brittle more quickly (depending on the type of epoxy that is being used)? I understand that there is a marine epoxy, is this one of reasons (resist UV aging) for it?

Is there an epoxy that can be used outdoors (that is not as expensive as the marine epoxy is), or are there other glues that are "fit for the purpose"/better for the job?

Re: Question on epoxy?

#9

Re: Question on epoxy?

Jim Dillon

>Barry,

Yes, the ratio of the two ingredients (usually consisting of the epoxy containing polymer, and the "hardener" amine) can impact the curing time and final properties. While the cured epoxy may appear to be OK, if the ratios of the starting ingredients are not what the manufacturer recommends, the properties of the fully cured epoxy will not be optimal (though maybe good enough for your application).

The reason for following the manufacturers recommendation for mixing ratios is that only they know what epoxy polymer (actually a "prepolymer") is being used and how many epoxy groups are on that prepolymer. Based on that knowledge, a calculation is done to determine the amount of hardener (usually a low molecular weight chemical) is necessary. Having the right ratio, along with thorough mixing, guarantees that no unreacted epoxy groups (or stinky amine hardening agents) are around when the resin is fully cured. The initial viscosity of the prepolymer also plays a role in the curing process.

Bottom line is aim for following the manufacturers directions as best as you can. I like the suggestion of using two parallel ribbons of the epoxy and hardener; that seems like a better idea than my usual two "puddles" of stuff. Good luck.

Jim

Re: Question on epoxy?

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Question on epoxy?

Jesper, Denmark

>Jim Dillon has a good description of the properties of Epoxy. It is two different materials, which are designed to react when mixed in the right proportions and form a third material. Therefore the mixture should be in the recommended amounts or you will have unreacted "something" left over. It is not like polyester, where the "hardener" really is a catalyst, where the amount of catalyst is not critical - it just speeds up the reaction.

Epoxy - marine or otherwise - is degraded by UV light. If used outdoors or where there is light falling on i inside, it has to be protected by paint or at least with a varnish with UV filters included.

Re: Question on epoxy?

#11

Re: One more thing ...

Jim Dillon

>... and that is the role of cross-link density in the cured epoxy. In these type of epoxies, the "hardener" often serves as a cross-linker between the epoxy prepolymer. Think of a cross-linker as a chemical that can join two (or more) polymer chains and form a network. It turns out that the role of the cross-linker is critically important in controlling the final properties of the fully cured epoxy.

Here is what can go wrong, from a chemical standpoint. If a little hardener is good, then maybe just a little more is better, or so the thinking goes. Not good. What happens is that if the hardener is in "excess", all the reactive epoxy groups on the prepolymer react with the excess hardener BEFORE any cross-linking can occur. This is related to statistical probabilities of two chemical groups encountering one another, and later to the increasing viscosity of the epoxy. The end result is that the extent of cross-linking is reduced, and the final properties of the "cured" epoxy compromised.

Now, what is an "excess" amount. I don't know, but I would imagine that the epoxy manufacturer has built in a small mixing error factor to make sure they don't get too many complaints regarding their epoxy. This is probably more than you ever wanted to know.

Jim

Re: Question on epoxy?

#12

Re: R: Question(s) on Epoxy?

Jim Dillon

>Joel,

I would say "yes" to your first three questions with the caveat that the properties of the "cured" epoxy may still be adequate for your purpose - though not optimal; it just depends on what you are using the epoxy for. Again, I suggest following the manufacturers recommendations as best you can.

Regarding outdoor glue choice, again it depends on what you are using the glue for and the exposure conditions that the glue will see. Epoxies, especially marine epoxies, are not inexpensive. But they work very well in an exposed wet environment. I understand some of the advanced construction adhesives are very good as well. For more limited exposure, I have had no problems with Titebond III on outdoor, though semi-protected, furniture.

Jim (who just had to rerepair a botched epoxy repair of a old mailbox because he likely screwed up the ratio of "A" to "B" by eye-balling wrong (and not mixing enough)8-(

Re: Question on epoxy?

#13

Re: Question on epoxy?

Marv

>To simplify what has been said in the above posts....if the ratio is specified to be 50:50 between resin and hardener, you can obtain a good joint, generally speaking even though you are off on the ratio a little, say 48:52 for example. The effect of being off on the ratio is merely a matter of the integrity of the joint. When the ratio is varied, the cured epoxy will be degraded in terms of brittleness on both sides of optimum. This relates to strength of the joint.

Keep in mind, there are many many types of epoxies made by different manufacturers. Anything we say here has to be thought of in general terms. If you are working with something that you consider to be critical and requires the optimum joint, you should first perform a few experiments to test a joint's strength while using any one of the various types and makes of epoxy.

Marv