Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

Posts

Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#1

Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

Terry Alexander

>Installing a ceiling fan.

Separate switches for fan and light.

Already installed 3 others in house.

Light would work but fan wouldn't.

Figured I would check the switches first since this is the easier "first" check.

Turn breaker off.

Checked for power using volt/ohm meter....nada.

POW! Got bit by what felt like 110 volts.

Scared heck out of me.

Called my BIL used to be a linesman for the county.

He said:

If you have anything that has a capacitor anywhere on that leg it can hold a charge and it will NOT show up on a volt/ohm meter. But, it will only bite you once! (that's 1 time too many for me).

I continued with my checkout, didn't get "bit" anymore and determined it is a defective fan. URGHhhhhhhhh. Uninstall and take back to store for another one.

So....what about this "hidden electrical" charge that won't show up on a volt/ohm meter?

As always.....TIA

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#2

How capacitors work

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Capacitors store electricity. One could think of them like a battery (they are not but they act like one). When a capacitor is charged from a 110 V source it will deliver its charge of electricity at 110 volts (some simplification here) when you touch its leads. Fortunately for you most don't store very much electricity. Small capacitors will scare you. Big ones could be lethal. I have been told to be wary of the big ones in TV power supplies.

The fix.... To discharge and render benign, always short the leads across a capacitor before working one something that has one.....or wait a while as they self discharge once disconnected from the 110 source.

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#3

But where is it?

Terry Alexander

>As always Bill....a very good post.

What I don't know is where the capacitor is that got me is.

I have flourscent lights on the leg, and the ceiling fan (that didn't work...it just "hummed" but didn't move).

Let's suppose the fan was the culprit, how would I "discharge" the capacitor?

TIA

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#4

Separate Light Form Fan

Tom Rex in TX

>I have a house that was built in 76, before fans were preinstalled.

We have fans in every room now but they are hooked up to the ceiling light.

The switch on the wall controls the light and the fan.

Is there a way to have a switch for the fan separate from the light?

In other words, I would like to have a switch for the light and one for the fan.

Thanks,

T Rex

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#5

Mine came that way....

Terry Alexander

>...but maybe some of the other "real" electricians and engineers on this board can help you.

Terry

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Separate Light Form Fan

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>There are generally two ways to accomplish what you want.

1. This is the more involved method, potentially very difficult if the wiring is not accessible. You would open up the box where the single switch is and remove that box. Enlarge the hole to hold a double-gang box. The tricky part is that you would need to run 12/3 or 14/3 wire to the fan so that there are two hot legs in the fan box. More than likely somewhere in the fan assembly, either above the fan, or between the fan and the light, the power leads for the fan and the light are wired together and to the switched hot from the switch box. These need to be separated, so that one switch leg controls the fan and one switch leg controls the light. Clear as mud, no?

2. The easier method is to buy a remote control unit for the fan/light assembly. This remote unit will have a single power lead which gets connected to the switched hot from your single wall switch. The remote unit will then have two power leads exiting it (black for fan, blue for lights), which you need to wire to the leads in the fan/light as in #1 above--they're wired together now, they need to be separated.

Of course, all the standard safety recommendations apply--shut off appropriate breakers, etc.

Jason (two fans installed and WORKING, 2-3 to go...)

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#7

May not be capacitor

Bill Howatt

>I don't think a lot of ceiling fans use capacitor start motors. Also, it would discharge through the run winding if the start switch was closed (not rotating at speed) and if the switch was open it wouldn't have charged up since there is not a complete circuit.

What probably happened is that you put your ohmmeter across the winding which built up an magnetic field in the motor coil from the ohmmeter's battery. You then deliberately or accidently broke the charging circuit by disconnecting the ohmmeter while touching the motor leads. The field rapidly collapsed and induced a significant voltage into the coil which you felt. Depending on the speed of field collapse you will get a much larger voltage than the ohmmeter battery voltage. I have been zapped more than once from this mechanism.

Bill

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#8

clarificaton...

Terry Alexander

>I got bit when I was testing the off/on switch on the wall...not at the actual fan/light assembly.

I have one of those "stacked" switches where they turn off/on sideways and take up only the space of a single switch.

My first "test" was to see if the switch controlling the fan was faulty.

That is where I got bit.

Tks

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#9

On Hunter fans, there are two different wires *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>for lights and fan, which can be tied into the single incoming power from the switch or separately. Code in this area requires two separate switches, so I had to take the first approach recommended when we rewired the house.

The physically hardest part is running the extra wire; even harder if your fan is on the first floor of a two-story house, since you then have to open up access spots in wall and ceiling (but see next paragraph). The other tricky part of this approach is that you need to know whether the power feeds through the switch to the fan and light, or whether power comes into the fan box from the ceiling, with a cable running down to the switch box.

If, you lucky devil, you live in a jurisdiction that required conduit when your house was built, you may be able to pull another wire from switch box to fan box. Count the wires going into the conduit, figure out the size of the conduit, and consult any good table to make sure your cable fill is appropriate for the conduit size before proceeding.

You can get a "stacked" switch that will allow you to have two switches in the space normally occupied by one. The switches work sideways and take the kind of plate normally used for outlets. This will save you the grief of hacking a larger hole in the wall, getting the old box out, and mounting a new one solidly; it will extend your lifetime curse inventory's expiration date by about six months. I use these in one room for the fan/light switches and in our back bathroom for everything, due to space constraints, and, while they're more expensive than single switches, they're very reliable.


just in case you have conduit

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Hot wires into ceiling box...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>If the power runs into the ceiling box, with a run of wire to the switch and back for switching purposes, then you would need two more conductors from the fan to the switch to switch the fan and light separately.

I did forget about the stacked switches, since I'd rather put in a double-gang box (I don't care for the look or function of the sideways switches--I want up to be on and down to be off).

What you said about the Hunter fans is what I meant, and is all I've ever seen--one lead for the fan, one for the light, a neutral and a ground. If both the fan and the light are on the same wall switch, those two leads and the switched hot from the wall switch would be wire-nutted together.

For the remote unit, this is what I installed:

http://www.lowes.com/lowes/lkn?action=productDetail&productId=31594-1811-RCB-103L&detail=cr&lpage=none

My disappointment with it was that the remote receiver only had one lead for "power in"--I would have preferred the fan and light "power in" to be separate so that I could still control the fan and light separately with wall switches. I ended up not using the remote light control (left the "light power out" wire unhooked), in favor of an electronic dimmer switch on the wall. I had already cut the hole and installed the double gang box and switches when I discovered the single "power in" wire on the remote receiver unit.

Jason

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#11

Oh...

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Doesn't seem to be a capacitor event. I would find the ground( the bare wire) and measure between it and everything you could have touched. Somewhere in there you may find 110V where you weren't expecting it, if indeed you got a 110 V shock.

This is probably not your case but I have been "shocked" twice and neither time was the source 110V. I once got pricked by a sharp wire end and my paranoid body interpreted the sharp pain as a shock. And then, I was working outside and the neutral touched a cut (bare meat not skin) and I definitely got a shock. Turned out my neutral was floating 12 V off true ground.

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#12

Re: clarificaton...

GalenV in Iowa

>Hard to tell what connections you were testing across in a stacked switch but I know you can get zapped by not checking across the breaker you think you shut off first.

Just a wild guess but I have had breakers that the switch does not always trip the internal contact. You may have thrown the breaker switch but it did not release. When you were testing the stacked switch you may have cause a short circuit and that did trip the internals of the breaker. You would get one zap and not again since the breaker now is open. If the fan was defectiive then you may not know how the power was being completed back to the switches and if you had the fan and light still connected common or seperate in the unit.

Just trying to show that a breaker may not be open till you check it first before working on the line.

Not sure how there would be very much capacitance on a lighting circuit.

Galen (Zapped more times than I can remember due to resulting brain damage)

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#13

Re: clarificaton...

Bill Howatt

>I'll still go with my assessment above if you were measuring between the fan wire and either neutral or ground.

Bill

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#14

All GREAT responses....

Terry Alexander

>...tells me to double/triple/quadruple check before pulling this stunt again. I "think" I did double check.....but the zap kind of makes things fuzzy now ;-)

Thanks to all

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#15

Re: May not be capacitor

Alex Grigoriev

>Modern ohmmeters will produce too negligible current, to cause any such induction effects.

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#16

Re: How capacitors work

Alex Grigoriev

>The sure way to discharge is to plug an incandescent lamp (or any other DC-conductive load) to the circuit. A motor *is* DC conductive, too.

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#17

check for ground wire from nearby circuit

Victor P

>The nearby circuit would be on a separate circuit breaker, but electrician may have inadvertantly grounded your circuit to the other circuit ground. Maybe 90 volts or so. It'll get your attention.

damhikt.

Victor in Hot and Humid Houston

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#18

Further thoughts, as we wander OT

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I understand not liking the stacked switches, but life consists of tradeoffs - if I could save myself an hour digging out a larger hole and fussing with fitting a double box, getting used to sideways switches might be a small price for someone to pay.

If the power comes into the ceiling box, don't you still just need three wires to the switch box (not counting the equipment ground wire) - one line hot and two load hots? We're talking about an amp apiece here for fan and light, so a separate line hot wire seems like overkill.

Incidentally, Tom Rex:

1. This is not a small project, but it's not a huge one either.

2. If you can distinguish white, black, and red wires; if you're a careful worker and don't hot dog stuff*; if you can learn from written instructions; if you can do decent drywall patching; you can probably do this.

3. Your friendly local library has got books on home wiring. Get one or more out and read through them about basic wiring practices. The online home maintenance sites (DIYnetwork, for instance) probably have videos on running wires from a switch box to a ceiling box, to give you an idea of what's involved, although remember that the videos always make a two day project look like it takes five minutes.

4. If you've got a neighbor familiar with electrical work, find out whether s/he prefers beer, BBQ, or both, and sweeten things up before asking for a walk-through of how you'd do it; or offer to mow the neighbor's lawn or some similar trade of effort.

5. If the idea of maybe zapping yourself is too scary to contemplate, go back to #4 but more so, or get a quote from an electrician.

*When I was young, I thought it was macho to work live circuits. Since then (age 60), I've realized that there are macho electricians and white-haired electricians, but darned few white-haired macho electricians.

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#19

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Further thoughts, as we wander OT

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Yep, you're right, you could in essence pass the power to the switch box, and pigtail off it for both switches. My brain was stuck on separate switch legs for the fan and light.

I see new homes wired with power to the ceiling box first all the time, but I don't get that--I prefer to have the power to the switch box, so if the switch is off, there's nothing hot in the ceiling box.

Jason

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#20

Part of the reason

Dan Donaldson

>There are things that after the fact seem odd to someone looking at a job, but actually make sense. I have roughed in a lot of houses and we many times ran the home run to the ceiling box. This is because it is big (easier to make connections), centrally located so can jump easily to anywhere, and if the homeowner later wants to add something, it is easy to get into the attic and pick up power from a ceiling box without having to hunt or cut up walls to get a hot wire. We also wired everything with #12 wire. That way, everything is 20 amp and I can grab power anywhere without worrying about whether it is 15 or 20 amp. At that time, the cost of wire was insignificant compared to the time it took to keep them separated. Maybe not with today's prices. We also used 3 way switches for everything. That way, if it was regular, wire it that way, and if 3 way, wire it thus. Same rationale, took time to get the switch from the truck, and had to stock two kinds. Also, where we were wiring, it could be a 2-3 hour drive to go get a part that you forgot.

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#21

Re: May not be capacitor

Bill Howatt

>If by modern you mean digital then you are probably correct. I never cared for digital ohmmeters so my trusty analog us usually the one I reach for.

Bill

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#22

As to remodels

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>or, I should say, rewiring, something I did to our place a decade or so ago, running the line side in the attic was the only efficient way to do it - I can't imagine the amount of plaster I'd have had to patch running the hot side to each switch box.

It was a good job to do - the existing house was a mix of knob and tube, BX (shielded metal cable), and utterly frightening non-code-ever wiring, like the ceiling light fixture in one closet that consisted of a ceramic light bulb fixture screwed to the homasote covering the ceiling - no box, just the wires terminating at the fixture, where they were perfectly positioned, if they'd gotten loose or broken and arced, to set the homasote on fire.

It was also a great job to get done, after crawling under the house and in the attic, occasionally in spaces not designed for adult humans.

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#23

Re: As to remodels

Dan Donaldson

>I helped one of my sons remodel a kitchen a couple of years ago. As a part of that remodel, we redid all of the kitchen wiring and most of the sheetrock. While I had the walls apart, I ran a couple of wires from the panel in the basement to the attic. I didn't connect them to anything on either end, but later he wanted to add some stuff and it sure was nice to just add a breaker on one end and a junction box on the other and have power available. No fishing etc.

Re: Let the debate begin - Hidden electricity chg

#24

That reminds me...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>of one of the worst "shocks" that I ever got. I was doing some wiring in a basement for a customer that involved cutting into an existing romex cable. I knew for a fact that I shut off the breaker before cutting the wire. Just as I bit into the old wire with my cutters, my cellphone went off. Since it was set on vibrate, I thought for sure that I was getting bit. I almost fell off my ladder. 8^]

Gary