Would birch make a good mallet?
North of the Border
>I have a few blocks around and could turn one into a mallet on the lathe. Is it hard enough? Thanks.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Would birch make a good mallet?
North of the Border
>I have a few blocks around and could turn one into a mallet on the lathe. Is it hard enough? Thanks.
Re: Would birch make a good mallet?
Glenn Madsen near San Francisco
>What do you want to hit with it? How hard? How long? How large?
The thing about mallets is that they need not be works of art to function well. And when they are no longer useful as mallets, they work well in the fireplace.
Mine's tanoak. Another is anigre'. Neither is an heirloom, but they're both useful. Both were scrap and 15 minutes work with the lathe.
Yellow?
John M in mid-Mich
>If yellow birch, then yes. Should be ideal as it is really hard, heavy, and tight grained. I think sweet birch is similar, but others would be too soft.
I have 5
steve antonucci
>I have made many turned from various species-
Red Oak is too splintery
Maple works great, but dents easily
Ash is the best I've used.
From time to time, I remount them on the lathe and "fix them"
Steve
Thanks all - I'll just try it out with the birch b
North of the Border
>
Re: Would birch make a good mallet? *LINK*
Thad
>according this janka scale, sweet birch is harder than hard maple & white oak, with yellow birch being slightly softer than red oak.
I use pecan (hickory) & dogwood, but those are plentiful here in middle GA.
With those species of birch being comparable to white oak & hard maple, you should be fine
~ Thad
a janka scale
another scale *LINK*
Thad
>this one has the birches together, for comparison
http://www.sizes.com/units/janka.htm