Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Howcan I get hemlock and fir to look alike

Posts

Howcan I get hemlock and fir to look alike

#1

Howcan I get hemlock and fir to look alike

Larry Rupprecht

>Are there any simple methods to get stair rail components of hemlock and fir to look alike? The reddish tone of fir and the white/creamy color of hemlock seem to defy my efforts at reducing the difference. Any help is appreciated.

Re: Howcan I get hemlock and fir to look alike

#2

Re: Howcan I get hemlock and fir to look alike

mike from american sycamore

>Paint! both woods are paint grade and intended to be painted...Sorry!

What look are you after? Would a dark stain be OK?

Re: Howcan I get hemlock and fir to look alike

#3

I should have told more....

Larry Rupprecht

>It is a basement stairway of treads and risers in fir from 1970s. Owners are redoing the entire home and did not want to replace the serviceable fir materials. However, to meet IRC requirements, we need to add a railing/guard on about 8 diagonal feet of one side of this stairway. Our local suppliers of stair components (balusters, newels, and associated trim pieces) have only hemlock available. The owners wish to keep the appearance of the straight grained fir with a clear coat and thus comes the problem of matching hemlock to fir.

We may have resolved the issue by finding a beautiful, straight-grained fir 4x4 to serve as a newel post and enough 2x12s to cut 2x2 balusters. The shoe rail and handrail can be machined from fir flooring that is trimmed and formed into appropriate shapes.

So it looks like the problem is resolved by finding enough fir to get away from the hemlock issue. Even in retirement, I am finding there are many more things to be learned....

Thanks for the response.

Re: Howcan I get hemlock and fir to look alike

#4

Ellis Walentine

Sounds like you have it covered

Ellis Walentine

>Apparently you are talking about Douglas fir, which has that reddish cast and strong grain pattern you mentioned. Your plan sounds like a good one.

Ellis Walentine, Host