WE MOVED...
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Leaking toilet question? (OT)

Posts

Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#1

Leaking toilet question? (OT)

Barry Irby

>I have an off brand toilet that has an unusual flapper in it. The flapper is hard plastic and has a disk on the business end that has a sort of cone on the under side that closes into the drain port in the toilet tank. On the opposite end, there is a little cup about the size of a film canister. The canister has an open top and a small hole in the bottom. When you lift the flapper the little cup is full of water and holds the flapper up until the water drains out of the cup.

The one that came with the toilet lasted something like twenty years. It was a real scavenger hunt to find a replacement. When I finally found it at a specialty plumbing supply house, it cost nearly twenty bucks. Now after about two years, the toilet is wasting water again. I cannot detect any defect in either component. The underside of the flapper is smooth and so it the rim of the seat. I tried putting a little Vaseline on both parts and that seemed to help for a few days. Now it is leaking again. The water level in the tank drops until the filler valve refills it. Water is not leaking onto the floor, but through the bowl and down the drain.

The soft rubber ring the stand pipe flush valve are mounted in has become degraded to the point that if you touch it you get sooty black finger tips. I am trying to figure out if somehow the water is leaking through the rubber and into the bowl or if it is just the flapper. Any Suggestions? Just replace the flapper again?

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#2

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

Curly Smith

>Can you remove the flapper assembly and fit a bathroom plunger over the hole to seal it? If so, then you can refill with water and determine if the standpipe is leaking.

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#3

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

Barry Irby

>Good Idea. I don't think a plunger would work, but I might be able to Sela something like a rubber ball into the opening of the drain port and that would tell me if it is the flapper or the rubber seal. I'm wondering if the rubber has dry rotted all the way through or if it is just a surface thing.

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#4

Stop Fussing With It

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Drain and remove the tank, then replace the entire flush valve assembly to get a new seat, flapper, and fill tube. Seems silly to spend $20 on an obsolete float valve when you can put the whole thing in new for $10.

YMMV

m

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#5

20 year old toilet

Dustmaker Mike

>If it is a 3 gallon per flush toilet you might better off replacing it with a good 1.5 or better per flush toilet. It may save more water in the long run. Now if the water saving don't add up to the cost of the new toilet then it is up to you.

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#6

Concur

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>During my time working as a maintenance man in a 160 bed nursing home I worked on a lot of toilets. There comes a time when replace makes more sense than repair.

BTW, I know exactly the type of valve described. I'll check with the local "got everything" supplier and see what he charges for one. He's high on everything.

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#7

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

GalenV in Iowa

>Put about three drops of food coloring in the tank and sit and watch where the dye is being drawn to. The dye being heavier than water will be drawn to the leak if it is any size at all.

The last tank I repaired the gasket holding the main flush assembly to the tank bottom in which the flapper seats was bad and the water leaked to the bowl. I could see the dye being drawn to it.

Galen

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#8

(OT) new toilets - new math

Victor P

>How do they figure three flushes on a low flow toilet saves water over the old toilets that worked on one flush?

Victor

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#9

Re: (OT) new toilets - new math

Barry Irby

>As a Home Inspector, I have made that joke plenty of times. It was true of the early low flush toilets. They have gotten better. New designs that include enlarging the port in the bottom of the tank. I think some have an opening as large as three inches now.

Already in use are ones that offer a two stage flush. Less water if the contents are yellow and more if they are brown.

Toto gets rave reviews.

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#10

Variable speed......

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Just like our power tools... variable speed.... well in this case variable flush.

With my Kohler you can vary the amount of water used for each flush depending on the need :)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#11

Old and new....

John in NM

>Very true, the new ones we installed a couple years ago work as well as pre-low flow, if not better. I had a rather technical article with model ratings that someone had posted here on WC, so we were able to make a very informed choice.

Now the toilets at work are almost all of the early 1990's low flow ilk, and true enough, they don't work so well. In two years working here though, I've never had to triple flush, and about 80% of the time a single flush does the job. So as lousy as they are, I think the triple flush stereotype is a bit of the worst case being universally applied.

Re: Leaking toilet question? (OT)

#12

Re: Old and new....

Dan Donaldson

>My experience has been that a single flush usually does it if it is going to flush at all without plunging, but I have had to plunge a lot on the low water toilets.