Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Design, Wood Grain & Wood Figure

Posts

Design, Wood Grain & Wood Figure

#1

Design, Wood Grain & Wood Figure

charlie belden

>Tom Watson posted this over in the usenet news group rec.woodowrking in response to a thread about the "high price" of wood. Thought it might strike a chord with some, or perhaps many- here, maybe giving newbies a hint of their possible future.

On Design, Wood Grain and Wood Figure by Tom Watson

When I am working on an individual piece that I hope will be

meaningful both to myself and the client (these days, mostly my wife,

myself and my children) I usually begin with the gross parameters,

such as size, shape and function, but this inevitably involves the

recognition of how the grain, color and figure of the piece will come

into play. To design otherwise would be to deprive myself of one (or

two) of the premier elements of a wood object. Taking these into

consideration makes me a painter. Ignoring them makes me a draftsman.

Grain and figure are not entirely the same. I have not read the FWW

article but I would hope that they admired the difference between

grain, which is a structural consideration, and figure, which is an

aesthetic component of a piece.

They inform each other but are not equal.

Grain comes into play mostly in the engineering area of the design. It

informs you as to how to do the joinery. When it becomes a design

component on the visual level, as in QSWO stuff, the line is blurred.

Figure comes in on the visual level in a different way. It talks

about how the piece is viewed as a piece of woodworking art.

This is not an absolute delineation. I am mindful that 'joinery is

the beginning of ornament'. However, in a general sense, once you

have gone beyond the basics of size and shape, it is figure and color

that describe the piece.

There are some craftsmen who begin with the wood. Nakashima might be

considered one, although his ultimate form was also informed by the

grain and figure.

There are others who would make a piece of a given form and look to

grain, color and figure to give it life.

That's where I live. While I am drawing a fairly rectilinear object,

like the desk I am building for my daughter, I am thinking about what

wood, what grain, what color and which figures to use in the piece.

Then I go looking for the wood that fills my eye.

It is a kind of design circle, you see. You may start with the need,

and the room that it will be in goes a long way to determine the size

and shape and color. The use of figure will determine if it is to fit

in, or to stand out.

You might also start with a beautifully figured stick and say to

yourself, "I wonder what I can best make from this?"

I have wood that is waiting to be a jewelry box. I have wood that is

clearly meant to be a chair. I have wood that is useless for joinery

and needs to be turned.

Right now I have a desk to make. Because it does not have to fit into

any particular room, excepting to be small enough to fit in a college

dorm, I get to go crazy on the color and figure. It is a wildcard. It

is a surd. It is a gift.

And you should see the figure and color of the fiddleback cherry.

That I saw in my mind's eye when I was drawing it.

Found the perfect sticks.

Nirvana.

Regards,

Tom Watson

http://home.comcast.net/~tjwatson1/

Re: Design, Wood Grain & Wood Figure

#2

carrying to the next step, and a recommendation

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I agree with the thoughts expressed but to work this way necessitates a considerable wood stash or a supplier willing to let the customer do lumber selection at the lumber yard. Our typical retail customer bought exactly (well, usually one board short) what they needed for a project, which left them to deal with forcing the cuttings and wood appearance of their lumber into what they were making.

For the reasons expressed by Tom, as well as others, I advocate that serious woodworkers should pick a favored lumber and buy a wholesale pack (500-1000 bdft) of it. This quantity will enable lumber to be selected for best appearance, best efficiency of making cuttings and best price. Lumber is a good to excellent investment as historically the price goes up and the quality goes down. A good example is the 500 bdft of 10-16" mahogany we cleared out of inventory some years ago at $2 bdft. because locally it was not in demand. Today the price would be $9 bdft and it is impossible to find old growth mahogany legally for sale.