Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

What Wood for a Dark Stain?

Posts

What Wood for a Dark Stain?

#1

What Wood for a Dark Stain?

Jim Rahbe

>Guys..

I�m planning on building several face-frame style cabinets. They will be stained a fairly dark color and I�m not sure what wood would be the best to use. The doors would be a simple frame, with a plywood panel. I�ve tried to stain Oak a darker color without much success and I�m not too crazy about the heavy grain pattern of Oak either.

Any suggestions on what would be the best wood to use for this project?

Thanks,

Jim R.

Re: What Wood for a Dark Stain?

#2

Bart Goldberg

Re: What Wood for a Dark Stain?

Bart Goldberg

>Well, I think picking a wood species for most projects is a major design consideration. For cabinets - cherry and maple are pretty typical woods to use and don't have the same heavy grain pattern as oak. Either can be stained, it all depends on what look your striving to achieve.

For some understanding of what different stains look like on different species of wood - check out most stain manufacturers sites and they usually show a palette of samples to provide a guideline for what to expect. Bartleys has such a palette as does Minwax I believe. Just Google them.

In all cases, you do want to try out your stains on the lumber you intend to use. and pick the one color you like the best.

Hope this helps

Bart

Re: What Wood for a Dark Stain?

#3

Re: What Wood for a Dark Stain?

Randy Stukenberg

>If money is no object, walnut would stain fairly dark. It will, however, lighten up a little over time if it gets a lot of sunlight. Cherry will take dark stain and will actually get darker with time.

Re: What Wood for a Dark Stain?

#4

Re: What Wood for a Dark Stain?

Fred Davis

>I would suggest my favorite Cabinet wood , that being White ash.

It is a chameleon of woods and takes any color stain nicely.

If you go with it , try to get plain sliced Veneer for the door panels,it's nicer looking and more subdued then rotary cut , fact is , if your budget allows it and you can get it , go plain sliced all the way ,on the sides and bottom of the uppers and any that shows.

FredD

Re: What Wood for a Dark Stain?

#5

JL

Re: What Wood for a Dark Stain?

JL

>How much do you want to spend? How pronounced of a grain pattern do you want? How soft/hard of a wood do you want to use? What are the cabinets for?

Poplar can look good when stained with a good gel stain. It is soft though and you have to be careful when staining so it won't blotch.

Soft maple can be attractive. So can hard maple.

Re: What Wood for a Dark Stain?

#6

Ellis Walentine

My take -- long

Ellis Walentine

>Pardon my wonkish answer, but I see a chance to talk about my favorite woodworking topic, namely design. Rather than recommend a species in answer to your question, I thought I'd suggest a process for making your decision.

First, the wood has to function, which means it needs to be durable, strong and stable enough. Just about any hardwood will do. Even softwoods might be okay if you don't mind that they dent easily and don't have as much strength or stiffness. You can design around those shortcomings if you need to.

Next, it has to fit in with the surroundings. Presumably, you want a dark wood because it will complement this particular decor better than a light wood. The exact hue and value of your stain will be chosen based on the color palette of the room. If this is a portable piece that will not be built in, it changes the equation. In that case, you have more flexibility with color choice, styling and construction methods. But I digress.

Another variable to consider is texture, which in my mind has more to do with the visual aspect than the tactual. (Whatever wood you choose will be smooth to the touch.) By texture, I mean how busy the wood looks, which in turn has to do with the grain pattern and the way it is presented. Oak, ash and other highly ring porous woods can look pretty garish if treated only with pigment-based stain because the earlywood absorbs a lot more pigment than the latewood. Generally, I don't care for that look, but that doesn't make it an invalid choice unless you don't like it either, or if it clashes with the surroundings in a distracting way. If you do use pigment stain on ring porous wood, you need to be very careful about choosing the individual boards so that the strong grain patterns complement each other. In other words, you need to compose with the grain. Often, woodworkers select rift or quartered stock to avoid this problem.

Dye stains produce a much more uniform color, to the point where you can be less concerned with grain matching, although I still recommend being aware of the composition as you are getting out your stock.

You also might want to consider price and availability, and weigh the visual and structural differences before deciding on a more expensive wood over a cheaper one. Why spend $5 a foot for cherry if you can get soft maple for half that, given the fact that you plan to stain it? One possible reason is that cherry is a richer looking wood and will darken nicely without stain, if your customer can wait a year or so. (You didn't mention if this is for you or someone else.)

I would recommend preparing some finish samples -- representative pieces of several woods with different stain treatments -- and see which one speaks to you (and/or the customer).

Sorry for the nosebleed.

Ellis

Re: What Wood for a Dark Stain?

#8

Nice - worth saving as a guide

Chicago Bob

>

Re: What Wood for a Dark Stain?

#9

Thanks all...

Jim Rahbe

>Thanks all, I appreciate the advice.

I�ll pick up some samples and do some stain tests as suggested.

Thanks again,

Jim R.