Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

Posts

A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

#1

A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

Barry Irby

>I am about to leave to go get four exterior doors from my cousin's house. They have rotted at the bottom and I am going to repair them. I posted questions on this and got what appeared to be minimal response. Good information, just not a lot of interest. Would anyone be interested if I photographed the process and posted pictures? I am asking because I don't usually take photos as I am working, but I could.

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

#2

I'm always interested in learning

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>how other folks solve problems. Go for it!

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

#3

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

mike from american sycamore

>very much so...this will be good practicle information! thanks for sharing!

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

#4

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>A few years ago my front door frame dry-rotted out. The door is metal and is in good shape. You may have heard Seattle gets its fair share of rain. I bought a new pre-hung door frame from the original manufacturer. They now make them with a synthetic product instead of white wood for the bottom foot or so of each side of the frame reduce this problem. I also installed an awning over the front door to reduce both the afternoon sun and blowing rain.

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

#5

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I'd be interested in your thought process regarding the decision to repair versus replace. Is the cost-benefit favorable? Would a fiberglass door be less expensive and more weatherproof? Is there a plan to provide some protection for the doors? Or is this a free favor for a relative?

If someone asked me to do this job, I'd politely decline.

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

#6

Ellis Walentine

Inquiring minds...

Ellis Walentine

>...wonder how you plan to repair these doors?

Ellis

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

#7

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

Barry Irby

>This is an interesting house. Its on the corner of a property that is zoned for business and my cousin lives in it as the "caretaker" for the business she runs from the property. In five or ten years, she will move from the property to a new location and this house will be bulldozed and some sort of store will be built there. So, she is not really interested in spending a lot of money on long term repairs.

The replacement doors would cost $175 each and there are four of them for a total of $700. I will repair them by cutting away the rotted wood to a known depth and replacing it with so decay resistant wood. Any irregular rotted wood or rot deeper than the cut away part will be scraped out, treated with preservative, wood hardener, and rebuilt with epoxy filler. Then I will glue in the replacement wood.

I'm thinking I can do this for about $50 a door or $200 total. Maybe $300.

As a little side note, I tried to buy some Ponderosa Pine for the repairs, but could not find any locally. My cousin and I own about 4000 BF of walnut we cut off a family farm. Walnut is nicely decay resistant and should serve well for this purpose. It will be on the exterior and painted and no one will notice it does not match the pine that is naturally finished on the other side of the door.

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

#8

Re: One idea...------WebKitFormBoundarydAraCiKIf+f

Hamish------WebKitFormBoundarydAraCiKIf+frfyKM

>Hi Barry,

I have been thinking over your door problem and as you mentioned that the mortice and tenon joints might be compromised, I wondered if you could cut the stiles above the offending wood and glue on new stiles, following the same shape, with a scarf joint. That would mean you could make new M&T joints and renew the lower rail.

A number of years ago, I scarfed jointed two 4 meter lengths of 6x2, flat side to flat side, positioned on edge, to make up long roof beams. I made around a dozen in all. The scarf was first roughly cut with a chain saw, with a proportion of 8 to 1, then finished off with a jig on which I ran my router over, to plane it flat. The joint was stuck together with polyurethane glue, which cures by reacting with the damp in the wood and surrounding air, making it a good choice for outside doors.

The glued proportion of wood in a scarf joint is very great, making it a very strong one. My beams are still as good as new with no sign of separating.

Could this be a solution to your dilemma?

Regards Hamish.

------WebKitFormBoundarydAraCiKIf+frfyKM

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

#9

Re: Inquiring minds...

Barry Irby

>Carefully?

As mentioned above these doors have a relatively short remaining life.

Two of them are side lights, set in frames, independent of the two middle panels which are the working doors.

My plan is to use a router to cut away about 3/4" off the lower portion of the doors. On the side lights I may just cut strait across the rail and stiles. Then if I have gotten rid of most of the rot, scrap away the rest, Treat the affected area with Bora Care, wood hardener, fill with epoxy wood filler. Put walnut back in place of the wood I routed away, horizontally, all the way across. Spackle it in with filler. I may even fake the join between the rail and stile with a knife cut and prime the exterior. Since these are sidelights and not under any strain and the edges are not visible I think this will be adequate.

On the doors I plan a similar approach, I may route away the stiles vertically higher than the rail and then dowel the new thinner rail repair piece to the rail.

I may change the depth of the repair if necessary to remove the majority of the rot.

I would appreciate any advice or even speculation on the repairs.

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

#10

Re: A little poll on repairing exterior doors?

Mark Nowicki

>Barry

I don't know how badly you need the money, but you sound like a nice guy, therefore I have to say it. You sure are going to a lot of trouble to save your cousin money.

Respectfully

Mark