Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT strange electrical problem

Posts

OT strange electrical problem

#1

OT strange electrical problem

paul woolson

>So I've been finishing my basement for the last few months. Just putting the finial touches on it now.

When the carpet installers were here last week, the guy was stapling carpet to the stairway stringer when his stapler made contact with a heat vent and arched something fierce. Blew the circuit. I assumed there was something wrong with his electric stapler.

Until yesterday I was cutting an old vent pipe from my chimney when sawsall blade made contact with the heat duct. POP! Blew a circuit. Did it again and the same problem.

So I'm guessing I've got some sort of grounding problem in my heating system. Any thoughts as to were to look or how to fix this? Thanks, Paul

Re: OT strange electrical problem

#2

Re: OT strange electrical problem

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Take a 230 volt meter, attach one lead to a single conductor wire that is attached to a known earth ground. ie: grounded metal water pipe or outside service ground rod. Use the other probe and test your duct work for voltage. Then turn off the breakers (one at a time) to the furnace, air handler, condensing unit, etc. to establish source of power. If not found, proceed with all other breakers in the building. You could have a fastener thru romex that is then screwed into duct work. Once the source is known, proceed with caution. Make sure that your "known" ground is truly ground. Test it with the small prong of a wall outlet for 115 volts.

Re: OT strange electrical problem

#3

Re: OT strange electrical problem

JoeW in Detroit, MI

>Is it the same breaker that trips? And is it the breakeer suupplying power to the furnace or is it another circuit? If it is the furnace circuit, I'd check the line going into the furnace. Check the piece of EMT that the Romex goes into, the Romex may be worn.

If it is a differnt circuit, I'd kill that circuit and visually try to follow it to where it crosses the ductwork and look there, agian it sounds as if the insulation on the hot wire is worn and contacting the ductwork.

Be careful that you do not touch the ducting and a cold water pipe, ceiling grid or other metal objects. The cold water pipe is ground, the duct is essentially a live wire and you would complete the circuit.

This is just a astarting point. Proceed with caution and good luck.

Re: OT strange electrical problem

#4

Re: OT strange electrical problem

Bill Howatt

>This is indeed strange. Since 2 devices caused the breaker to trip it sounds like that the duct is hot. However, if the sawsall and the stapler were plugged into the same outlet then it could be faulty.

The furnace should be grounded by virtue of the cable supplying the fan motor, possibly a pump motor at least.

If the breaker(s) suppling the tools popped then the furnace ducting is OK and the tool circuit is wrong - most likely mis-wired and putting 120V onto the frame of the tool. If the furnace breaker popped then the problem is likely with the furnace circuit.

I agree with the recommendation to get an AC voltmeter and start checking the furnace ducting relative to a known ground. If that is OK, that is 0 volts indicated, then check from the receptacle ground pin hole to a known ground - that should also be 0 volts. If it is anything else you have a wiring problem on that circuit.

Be very careful. If your furnace ducting is live you have a very big bare conductor lurking in your house including floor registers.

Bill

Re: OT strange electrical problem

#5

CALL A LICENCED ELECTRICIAN!!

mark nowicki

>...before somebody gets killed. Yes I am yelling.

When you renovated your basement, did you do any electrical work? Move wires, add circuits, etc.

Mark

Re: OT strange electrical problem

#6

Re: CALL A LICENCED ELECTRICIAN!!

Fred Davis

>I seond the motion.

FredD

Re: OT strange electrical problem

#7

Re: CALL A LICENCED ELECTRICIAN!!

Bill Howatt

>You're right. I'd never call one but the original poster didn't claim any knowledge of things electrical and this is certainly not a run-of-the-mill problem.

Bill

Re: OT strange electrical problem

#8

Questions

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Did the same circuit blow each time? If so can you follow the wire from teh breaker box to wherever it goes? Do you have a voltmeter and know how to use it?

If all the answers are yes, then proceed, otherwise call an electricain.

If this was the furnace circuit, follow the wiring o the furnace and look where teh power goes through the furnace enclosure tothe blower motor. Most likely your hot has an insulation fault and is touching the metal of the furnace and the furnace is not properly grounded. You can check to see if the furnace is "hot" with the volt meter to a convenient ground such as a cold water pipe.

If this was not the furnace cicuit, follow the wiring from the circuit breaker to where it goes. Look for places where it comes in contact with or passes through the duct system. You will likely find a place with melted or worn insulation touching the duct work. Any wire passing through or touching the sides of the duct should be carefully checked.

Once you find the power leak to the duct work, turn off the power and fix it. Then find the wiring running to your furnace and make sure the ground wire is attached to the furnace frame. This will prevent any future problems because as soon as they occur the circuit will short to ground and blow the breaker.

Lee

Lee

Re: OT strange electrical problem

#9

Re: Questions

Jay Lombardo

>Lee's got it right. IF the answer to the questions is yes, proceed as he says.

Jay (Electrician)

Re: OT strange electrical problem

#10

Re: OT strange electrical problem

Rick Christopherson

>It is not likely that the problem exists with the outlet being used for the tools, because if you had phase and ground reversed, those tools would not function.

The most likely cause is that you have a wire passing through the heat duct or laying on top of the heat duct, and the insulation has been cut through by sharp sheetmetal. A second thing to consider is that the screws that secure some vent covers are very long and could have pierced an adjacent wire. Track the path of the wire and you are likely to find the problem is rather simple.

Re: OT strange electrical problem

#11

UPDATE

paul woolson

>Here's what we (a professional electrician and I ) found out:

We went through and tested all of the outlets. All of them tested as if phase was reversed. Though the wiring was right. HMMMMM?

So we started back at the outlet where the two tools in question were plugged. We went back to the junction box and tested things there. Voltage was all wacky. The electrician said that when that happens, it's often a problem with the neutral. So he untied the wires and found that some of the older wires where not in good shape. Fixed those and retied them all together. The outlet now worked fine.

Here's the kicker: the other outlets no longer read as reversed polarity. And they are on a different circuit. He said that when there is a problem with neutrals, it can travel all over the house because there is no switching to stop it.

Pretty far over my head but I found it quite interesting.

We went ahead and tested for voltage in the ducts but found nothing. All is well. Thanks for the tips!